Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 312 W Interlake Blvd, Lake Placid, FL 33852
Phone: (863) 699-1219
Website: https://www.facebook.com/pg/Mr-Sammys-NY-Style-Pizza-293295577687783/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mr Sammy’s NY Style Pizza Bistro & Italian Cuisine | Lake Placid FL
Wonderful family staff & friends making Mr. Sammys pizzaria & bistro into what you now know today as the best pizza place in Highlands county!
Mr. Sammy’s New York Style Pizza – 312 W Interlake Blvd, Lake …
Welcome to Mr. Sammy’s New York Style Pizza – 312 W Interlake Blvd, Lake Placid, FL, 33852. Low prices, excellent and prompt service.
Mr Sammy’s NY Style Pizza Bistro & Italian Cuisine – MapQuest
Get more information for Mr Sammy’s NY Style Pizza Bistro & Italian Cuisine in Lake Placid, FL. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Ric Gonzales
This is the spot! If you want that David Portnoy experience-here it is. New York style, great sauce (not salty), tasty cheese(not to much) and the crust has a perfect crunch!! Pepperoni is not super salty or spicy, it was perfect. Great find, please try it. Beer on tap also for those looking for a slice and a brew. Definitely coming back soon to try the other toppings. Top 3 for sure 9.3 for me. Great service from the staff. Thank you!! Don’t sleep on this one. Wow!
… moreAndrea Harder
I would absolutely love to dine here but the 3 times I drove 30+mins they weren’t open or closed earlier then the advertised times. I even called to confirm. For now based on smells alone, the pizza smells great! Maybe I’ll even get to try it this year.
… moreMcCall Aulbach
We had such a wonderful experience! Our kids got to make their own pizzas, and got signed aprons. The experience was wonderful! I had a salad and it was delicious! All the staff were so friendly and attentive! Such a great family friendly experience in Lake Placid, a real gem!
… moreSoup10
We just moved to Lake Placid and went out to find dinner after a long day of moving
Well we found our new favorite place !
Great pizza YUM great salad and breadsticks YUM ! Great service (wish I could remember her name) but super sweet nice atmosphere
Just a good experience
Our new go to spot ! 🙂
… moreWell we found our new favorite place !
Great pizza YUM great salad and breadsticks YUM ! Great service (wish I could remember her name) but super sweet nice atmosphere
Just a good experience
Our new go to spot ! 🙂
Smiffun Weston
Awesome people, great menu of delicious items, super cozy environment, ny style is an understatement for this great spot, it is New York pizza, safe to say that it’ll be my go to spot for Italian cuisine!!
… moreSierra Bergsgaard
We ordered two take out pizzas, the Hawaiian was decent but the veggie was pretty sad. Canned mushrooms, uncooked spinach. Wouldn’t get it again.
… moreRob Massa
Came across Sammy’s while house hunting in the area. Amazing NY Pizza. Great crunch and delicious sauce. Canoli was amazing. Loved the welcoming atmosphere and family spirit. My kind of people!!! Must stop if your any where close!
… moreRodney Wood
I’ll be living in Lake Placid on August 1, 2025. I was there to get a place to live this past weekend and received a word-of-mouth advertisement for this place. It lived up to the hype and my expectations!! I had the baked Zitti, it came with a side of meatballs. Delicious!!
… moreSteven Rudnick
What a special day they made for my Daughter on her 8th birthday. Wonderful bunch of nice guys who really care about you having a great experience, even if it’s “not on the menu” = they gave us Italian icy for the birthday gift too! (We didn’t even ask!)
… moreTim Elyea
Pizza was excellent. Friendly, hometown pizza joint. Warm atmosphere. I’ll be back.
… more