Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 140 Grey St, East Aurora, NY 14052
Phone: (716) 805-7924
Website: https://www.mcduffies.com/
Related Web Results
McDuffies Bakery
Frozen Pot Pies, Fresh Baked Breads and Pastries and More!!! … NY; Williamsville, NY; and the surrounding areas in WNY. Pot Pies, Specialty Cakes & More!
Mr. Pot Pie, 140 Grey St, East Aurora, NY 14052, US – MapQuest
In addition to their famous pot pies, Mr. Pot Pie features a variety of baked goods, including fresh-baked breads, pastries, and specialty cakes, all made with …
Driving directions to Mr. Pot Pie, 140 Grey St, East Aurora – Waze
Mr. Pot Pie · (716) 805-7924 · mcduffies.com.
Reviews
Matthew Bellaus
Honestly the best thing I’ve tasted in a long time it definitely has that homemade taste to it anything you get from here is just perfect!!!! I heard about it for a long time before I actually tried it and now that I’ve tried it I am completely obsessed!! AMAZING for a cold day great comfort food! the crust is seriously the best I’ve ever tasted and it has a PERFECT blend of ingredients! If you have never tried it you are really missing out!
… moreLyndsey
Owners are absolutely the nicest people ever! The quality of food is AMAZING! We bought a broccoli chicken pot pie to cook at home and it’s hands down the best pot pie I’ve ever had!
… moreThe Truth
Had the regular chicken pot pie and it was fantastic. We also tried the cheeseburger soup and seafood bisque soup. The cheeseburger soup was great as well as the bisque. Bisque was tasty, but could’ve use a little more meats. Still very good though. The girl working the counter was super friendly. We will be back to try more deliciousness!
… moreKathy Gronahan
We love this pkace.We haven’t had a bad one yet!!!highly recommend it 8
… moreCandace Monroy
Heard this place was good from my co workers so I went for the first time and bought 2 of these pies, and all I can say is.. WOW!!! So creamy, lots of turkey and so much flavor!! My husband and I were very impressed.. we will definitely be a reg customer for sure!!
… moreAmanda D
We normally go in for their short bread, it’s to die for. They recently started offering fudge which is very good too. I love their macaroni and cheese to have in my freezer for a quick dinner. Their pot pies from what I hear from family are delicious (I am biased as I don’t like pot pie). I highly recommend giving them a try!
… moreJoni Williams
I ordered the chicken pot pie for a birthday luncheon for my husband. I ordered three of them. The serving size was four substantial slices per pie. Everyone raved about how delicious it was. I also ordered the Italian Bread and served both with a Caprese Salad. Absolutely wonderful. Mr. Pot Pie will be my “go to” place for informal entertaining. Cannot wait to try some of the other selections.
… morePaige Rubach
Always amazing! The soup is so good! I love their pepper soup when they have it, but its seasonal. Great almond ring and caramel walnut coffee! So sad that the samples are not offered due to covid, but when they are, they are very generous.
… moreJohn Spooner
Outstanding chicken pot pies. Big chunks of chicken, flaky crust and low sodium. All the pies fall into the top of “wow” factor. Great soups – the seafood is my favorite. All the baked goods are top quality and most important yummy!
… moreA Laskowski
There was not a huge variety of pot pies when I went. I also went later in the day. Pies are a little pricy but extremely tasty. I’ll definitely be trying other varieties.
… more