Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 223 Cedar St, Chillicothe, IL 61523
Phone: (309) 270-8600
Website: https://www.facebook.com/Mollys-Pizzeria-236519944985964/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Molly’s Pizzeria | Chillicothe IL – Facebook
Hello Chillicothe, Illinois! There is a new pizza place coming to town and we could not be more excited to be part of this great community!
Molly’s Pizzeria 223 W. Cedar St. – Order Online
Molly’s Pizzeria 223 W. Cedar St. · 10 Bread Sticks. $11.75 · 5 Bread Sticks. $6.75 · Bacon Cheese Fries. $9.00 · Combo Basket. $14.50 · Fried Mushrooms. $9.50 …
Molly’s Pizzeria – The Chillicothe Voice
If you’re tired of the corporate type of restaurants and want a pleasant change, go to 223 Cedar Street in Chillicothe, Illinois.
Reviews
Brian J.
Great pizza, plenty of toppings, friendly staff, nice atmosphere and vibe, reasonable prices, great place to stop in for pizza and more! We tried a half and half Hawaiian and their version of meat lovers. Good stuff!
… moreElizabeth Bennett
OMG! The pizza was SO GOOD! The crust was the best I’ve tasted. The options for toppings were vast, and the specialty pizzas were very unique and tasty.
Will definitely be back. Maybe I’ll try out the lunch buffet.
… moreWill definitely be back. Maybe I’ll try out the lunch buffet.
Mikaela Kozak
Busy evening, no big deal. I waited as staff completed their tasks. Both promised they’d be right with me. Waited ten minutes for service while they played pass the buck between them, and made damn sure to wait on other customers around me. First and last time in. If you don’t want to wait on customers, just say so. My money can be better spent elsewhere.
Edit: Staff said literally nothing to me when I went to pick up my food. Didn’t even look me in the eye. No, “I’m sorry you were overlooked,” or, “Thanks for being patient.” She couldn’t be bothered. You’d think, being small business, they’d want to treat their customers fairly. This chick treated me like I was an impediment to her evening.
… moreEdit: Staff said literally nothing to me when I went to pick up my food. Didn’t even look me in the eye. No, “I’m sorry you were overlooked,” or, “Thanks for being patient.” She couldn’t be bothered. You’d think, being small business, they’d want to treat their customers fairly. This chick treated me like I was an impediment to her evening.
S B
This pizza is the worst!
For pick-up ordered 1 thin crust small, extra pizza sauce, pepperoni w onion and 1 classic (which is pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers) w extra pizza sauce.
Said be 15 minutes so immediately got in car to go get it.
When I get home(which is less than 3miles away) its ice cold. No extra sauce, burnt around edges, so I said I’ll try a piece, aweful and all ingredients in middle of pizza no distribution all over pizza, no wonder edges were burnt. It was very loud and noisy inside as well.
In my opinion DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY HERE.
… moreFor pick-up ordered 1 thin crust small, extra pizza sauce, pepperoni w onion and 1 classic (which is pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers) w extra pizza sauce.
Said be 15 minutes so immediately got in car to go get it.
When I get home(which is less than 3miles away) its ice cold. No extra sauce, burnt around edges, so I said I’ll try a piece, aweful and all ingredients in middle of pizza no distribution all over pizza, no wonder edges were burnt. It was very loud and noisy inside as well.
In my opinion DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY HERE.
Brandon Lawson
Best pizza and wings around! The new salad bar set up with the pizza buffet is AMAZINGLY good!!!! The owner and staff take extremely good care of making sure the entire establishment is MEGA clean. The kitchen area is rated on my top 3 of the CLEANEST kitchens I’ve been in. If great food, great service and an extremely clean establishment is priority on your list, I highly recommend Molly’s in Chillicothe.
… moreSteve Weber
One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time. I had the hand tossed crust. Lots of topping and cheese. Great home-made crust. My wife had the Gluten Free crust and she said it was great! Tried some of the appetizers as well and they were all delicious, wings were exceptional.. We will be coming back here soon
… moreAt Acdad
Stopped in for lunch on Sunday and found the place slammed by the after-church crowd. Nonetheless the manager got us (2) in at the bar and rushed our simple pie and drink order ahead of the table of 14.
Had the 8”classic and iced tea. The pizza was delicious. More than plenty of toppings and tasty. Hand tossed crust had a little crunch to the bottom and a nice chewy edge.
Updated 11/24/24: called in a pizza order from the road, 8” Classic ftw! The feature that stood out was the lack of grease. That’s not to say that there wasn’t any, but you know how some of those chain pizza places use meats and cheese that leave the pizza box waterproof? Not a problem with my takeout. Just great pizza – will be back the next time travel brings me through. Have to mention the “garage door windows”, very nice.
… moreHad the 8”classic and iced tea. The pizza was delicious. More than plenty of toppings and tasty. Hand tossed crust had a little crunch to the bottom and a nice chewy edge.
Updated 11/24/24: called in a pizza order from the road, 8” Classic ftw! The feature that stood out was the lack of grease. That’s not to say that there wasn’t any, but you know how some of those chain pizza places use meats and cheese that leave the pizza box waterproof? Not a problem with my takeout. Just great pizza – will be back the next time travel brings me through. Have to mention the “garage door windows”, very nice.
Greg Dodd
From when you first enter Mollys the atmosphere is very pleasant. And then you’re greeted with a very warm welcome. Katie was our server, she did an excellent job! The pizza, as you can see all the toppings came clear to the edge of the pizza and plenty of sauce. Which is very hard to find these days. The pizza was excellent. This place definitely earned my five stars. We will definitely be making a trip back to Molly’s pizzeria. Thank your WEEK TV 25 for steering us towards this place.
… moreKaede Marise
I absolutely LOVE the Chicken Bacon Ranch Specialty Pizza and the Bacon Cheese Fries. I have never tasted anything more wonderful in my entire life. The staff was kind and caring. 10 out of 10, would come again.
… more