Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Molly’s Pizza – Oneonta, NY – 5006 NY-23 – Hours, Menu, Order
Discover a new favorite by trying the top pizzas in Oneonta. Local residents have made Molly’s Pizza one of the most popular in the area.
Molly’s Pizzeria in Oneonta serves perfect pizza – Facebook
Molly’s is hands down the best pizza in Oneonta without a doubt. I’ve worked at several local pizza spots and they all have their own awesome …
Molly’s Pizza – View Menu & Order Online – 5006 NY-23, Oneonta …
Specialty Pies … Mozzarella, fresh mozzarella and light olive oil. … Garlic, ricotta and mozzarella. … Sausage, pepper and light onion. … Tomato sauce, cheese & …
Reviews
Damien Burch
Pizza is delicious. In a town with many good pizza places, this place isn’t talked about enough. I had the mollys cheese pizza with half pepperoni and some garlic knots… perfection. My only “complaint” I might have is that I can agree with other costumers that the owner might be a little stiff. Could be because he’s always busy and sometimes as the owner, you take on the stress of all the jobs at hand. Regardless of that… great pizza.
… moreJuan Lima
The pizza here is fantastic. Can’t get enough of that crust which is reminiscent of Brooklyn style pizza from NYC. We had their large mushroom pie with fresh mushrooms and a Schweppes and Canada Dry soda flavors we haven’t had before. The owner was friendly and it wasn’t very busy until after we left. Had the rest of the pie to go.
… morekristy williams
Hubby stopped after work to grab a pizza. He got a meat lovers pizza (don’t know what the official name is) and it was huge. lol There was so much toppings. It was delicious. I ate one slice and was full. You definitely get your money’s worth. So good!
… moreTamRootbeer
We heard about this pizza place recently and decided we had to try it (our granddaughter’s name is Molly). It was excellent, had plenty of pepperoni, and the crust was flavorful and had that slight chewiness we love. Excellent price!
I did ask if they had gluten free crust, but they do not.
Please like this review if you found it helpful.
… moreI did ask if they had gluten free crust, but they do not.
Please like this review if you found it helpful.
Heather B. Denture DiVa
So I came here twice to give them the benefit of the doubt to try their Pizza and in this town we have a ton of pizza everywhere I would say this one is the one that I would not recommend. And plus no matter what your political beliefs are you probably shouldn’t be chatting with people saying horrendous things in front of kids. Never mix business with politics. But I would never recommend their pizzas aside from any of that before I knew when my son went with his grandfather she get shoes for school and the things he told me that this guy said who owned the business I don’t know it’s more garlic than anything and it’s not cohesive with the pizza hut. There’s many other pizza places I would recommend more
… moreAlyssa Zynda
I visit with my daughters frequently. One of my favorite local pizza places! We get the garlic ricotta pizza half cheese and knots!
… moreTheresa Yejin Chung
Best pizza in Oneonta and even approved by NYC natives! Vegetarian pizza is overflowing with fresh veggies; every part of the pizza is covered in a pile of broccoli, mushrooms, peppers, tomato, and cheese. Highly recommend the thin-crust Margherita – best one in all of Oneonta and its many pizza places. Right after taking it out of the oven, fresh basil and olive oil is drizzled on to perfection! Pizza crust is always crunchy and perfectly golden! Always worth the wait!
… moreAriel
Really loved the pizza ! I had white sauce pizza with broccoli and chicken. I also had a slice of pepperoni . Both were cooked perfectly. The down side the soda machine was down,but they had canned soda so, I gave them a solid 4 stars ⭐️.
… moreP D
Best pizza in Oneonta. Just wasted money AGAIN, trying a place across town last night, Found MOLLYS today and it’s Amazing. You will LOVE this pizza.
… moreSamantha Escobar
Molly’s pizza is delicious. Their pizza is very flavorful which other pizza places lack. My favorite is either a plain slice, Sicilian, or a white cheese slice with broccoli. Even my family that visits from the city always asks to get a Molly’s pie when they are in town. Thank you for your great pizza!
… more