Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 139 W High St, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone: (717) 422-5591
Website: http://www.mollypitcher.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Molly Pitcher Brewing Company – Carlisle
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Carlisle, PA.
Molly Pitcher Brewing Co. – Cumberland Valley Visitors Bureau
A locally-owned and operated brewery and taproom located in historic downtown Carlisle, Molly Pitcher Brewing Company offers a constantly changing selection.
Molly Pitcher Brewing Company | Carlisle, PA | Reviews
Molly Pitcher Brewing Co. is the most polished brewery-restaurant in Carlisle, PA. It’s got exposed brick down the length of the wall where the bar is, a real …
Reviews
Phillip Michael Whitley (Mr Phab Photos)
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
We had such a great experience!
Preston started with the Billy Haze 6.5 Columbus Centennial Cascade Citra – fruity and a little sweeter than expected, but still had a nice hoppy quality. I went with the Big Hill Ciderworks hard cider, which was light, crisp, and not too sweet.
The food was fantastic! The Old Bay wings are top notch – crispy, flavorful, and definitely rank in my top ten wing spots in Central PA. The grilled blackened hop spice wings were savory (not overly spicy) with that perfect charred flavor from the grill that tied it all together. The tater tots were clearly homemade, crispy, and delicious, served with a house-made charred onion mayo and smoked chile ketchup. The mayo especially stood out – next-level flavor. The French fries were extra crispy, exactly how I ordered them – it’s rare a kitchen actually listens, but they nailed it!
Service was just as impressive. Padraic was super attentive behind the bar, and Garret was funny as hell and made a real connection with us. Between the food, drinks, and service, it was a wonderful dining experience.
We’ll definitely be back!
… moreWe had such a great experience!
Preston started with the Billy Haze 6.5 Columbus Centennial Cascade Citra – fruity and a little sweeter than expected, but still had a nice hoppy quality. I went with the Big Hill Ciderworks hard cider, which was light, crisp, and not too sweet.
The food was fantastic! The Old Bay wings are top notch – crispy, flavorful, and definitely rank in my top ten wing spots in Central PA. The grilled blackened hop spice wings were savory (not overly spicy) with that perfect charred flavor from the grill that tied it all together. The tater tots were clearly homemade, crispy, and delicious, served with a house-made charred onion mayo and smoked chile ketchup. The mayo especially stood out – next-level flavor. The French fries were extra crispy, exactly how I ordered them – it’s rare a kitchen actually listens, but they nailed it!
Service was just as impressive. Padraic was super attentive behind the bar, and Garret was funny as hell and made a real connection with us. Between the food, drinks, and service, it was a wonderful dining experience.
We’ll definitely be back!
Eric Harker
Great Beer, Great Food, and Even Better Service
Stopped into Molly Pitcher Brewing Company and had an awesome experience. The place has a laid back, comfortable vibe, great for grabbing a couple beers and a bite to eat.
Our waiter honestly made the night. Not only was he super helpful with beer recommendations, but he had us cracking up the whole time. It’s rare to get someone who’s that good at what they do, and keeps the table laughing.
I ordered the fish basket and my wife got the chicken basket, both came out hot, crispy, and way better than we expected for bar style food. Paired with a couple of their house beers, which were excellent, it hit the spot.
Definitely planning to come back. Between the beer, the food, and the service, it’s one of the best spots in Carlisle.
… moreStopped into Molly Pitcher Brewing Company and had an awesome experience. The place has a laid back, comfortable vibe, great for grabbing a couple beers and a bite to eat.
Our waiter honestly made the night. Not only was he super helpful with beer recommendations, but he had us cracking up the whole time. It’s rare to get someone who’s that good at what they do, and keeps the table laughing.
I ordered the fish basket and my wife got the chicken basket, both came out hot, crispy, and way better than we expected for bar style food. Paired with a couple of their house beers, which were excellent, it hit the spot.
Definitely planning to come back. Between the beer, the food, and the service, it’s one of the best spots in Carlisle.
Wanderers Compass Travel Blog
We love this place. We have been many times and somehow keep forgetting to do a review and our pictures get lost in all our others. We will update next time.
The Molly tots are great and be love the charred onion dipping sauce and the spicy ketchup. We also really enjoy their chicken sandwiches and the white stout.
All their bees and food are good. There is a nice patio in the back with shade and a smaller room upstairs for events. It’s a great local spot with family’s, locals, and business people always coming in.
… moreThe Molly tots are great and be love the charred onion dipping sauce and the spicy ketchup. We also really enjoy their chicken sandwiches and the white stout.
All their bees and food are good. There is a nice patio in the back with shade and a smaller room upstairs for events. It’s a great local spot with family’s, locals, and business people always coming in.
Hannah Perez
The food was excellent. Nice variety of beer. Our waiter Garret was very friendly.
… moreMichelle Lender
Really enjoyed!! Carter, our server, was excellent!! The food+beers were very good…I thought quite busy for a Tuesday, which is good…we sat at a table by the front window which was nice!!! Seemed like a nice, hometown kind of place with a lot of regulars…cozy!!! I felt the prices were quite reasonable…Happy hour 5-7pm! Would highly reccomend!!!
… moreKevin Smith
We stopped in last night for the first time and had a wonderful time sitting at the bar. Garrett was our server and he was fantastic offering the perfect beers for us to try and his service was fantastic. Overall, we loved the food and the beer and we will be back.
… moreRobert Hoagland
We enjoyed stopping here for food and drinks. We parked on the street but found out there’s parking behind the building and a rear entrance. We sat outside because it was a beautiful day. They had live Irish music when we were there.
… moreRachel Erotika
My two favorite beers on tap were “Black Powder Stout,” very smooth with dark chocolate flavors and “Peanut Butter Porter,” creamy and sweet with some peanut butter and hazelnut taste/smell. Food is really good, you must try their “Molly Tots” their charred-onion cream sauce and smoked-chili ketchup sauce are so good! The Bacon Burger is another great option, well cooked and a big portion of fries. Great atmosphere and good customer service.
… moreMelanie Madamba
This has become our go-to spot. The beer is great, LOVE the music and the food is solid. They definitely have their own twist on things that are a little boring on other menus.
But by far the best thing there is the staff. EVERY single person is extremely friendly and makes you feel like you belong there.
… moreBut by far the best thing there is the staff. EVERY single person is extremely friendly and makes you feel like you belong there.
melody laurel
Looking for an excuse to go back.
I have not had fried baloney since my grandmother passed away. Great varieties of beers, hard seltzer and local ciders.
… moreI have not had fried baloney since my grandmother passed away. Great varieties of beers, hard seltzer and local ciders.