James Moran
Been here 3x’s now, first time was wonderful. Second time was terrible service, didn’t get my brothers drink order right, took forever to get a refresh on the fish, and then took an extended amount of time to recieve the check. Today 3/6/26 I didn’t get a refresh on my drink until after the food arrived, and then when we told the waitress we were done she walked off with my brothers plate and didnt return until after another waitress came by and asked if we wanted a refresh to which we explained we wanted the bill. Then that waitress walked off for an extended period of time and our initial waitress came over and asked if I wanted a refresh on my drink. We explained to her we had asked another waitress for the bill and she walked off. Within ~3mins the other waitress walked up with the bill and then our waitress walked up with the bill. The only prompt service we got was getting the bill paid. Not sure what that’s about but we will NOT be returning as they weren’t even half capacity tonight and last week (last time) they were packed. Lies? Like what you had the bar, 4 tables and one outside table when I told the first waitress that we didnt want a refresh. She walked off and completely forgot our table, we already had the bill from a second waitress when our original walked up with the bill. She concerned herself with a bigger table and forgot about us. I don’t lie and if that’s what you have to resort to in order to combat a bad review than I am happy to say you have lost our business. When my brother and I both feel like we weren’t welcomed there than it’s a you problem not a me problem. I would much rather have good service than comp’d food /or drinks.
… moreBrian Brenhoch
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Molly Malone’s is the kind of place that makes you wonder why you ever went anywhere else. Even on a packed night, the staff manages to be warm, welcoming, and on their A-game—smiles, quick service, and amazing positive attitude.
Bonus discovery: it’s a Buffalo Bills backer bar. As a proud Bills fan, I showed up on Sunday night and found myself in football heaven. The energy was electric—fans of all teams were there, but the sea of Bills Mafia made it feel like Orchard Park had relocated to Molly’s.
Naturally, I had to test the wings (mandatory Bills fan ritual). Verdict? Crispy, meaty, and dangerously good. The bartender steered me toward Molly Malone’s house hot sauce, and let’s just say it earned its spot in my wing hall of fame. Not too crazy hot, but bold, flavorful, and addictive—kind of like the bar itself.
Drinks? Ice cold, with plenty of options to keep everyone happy. Menu? Loaded with good choices. Atmosphere? The perfect blend of rowdy fun and friendly vibes.
Long story short: Molly Malone’s just became my official football season hangout. Come for the wings, stay for the laughs, and if you’re Bills Mafia—consider this your new home away from home. Go Bills!
… moreHaliNichole
I only went there to have a few drinks with my coworkers after our company christmas dinner…. not sure how the food is. The all around atmosphere was very chill. They had live music (he wasnt the best singer but it wasnt irritating or annoying, kind sounded like it was a woman singing smh) the waitress was attentive and made sure to keep no ones drinks ran out. Not sure about pricing because my suoervisor paid for everyone’s drinks. They do have locally made beers that are fantastic, like the apple cider.
… moreJames Selover
This is my favorite place. Thou 20 miles from my home, I get there every weekend. Their ability and professionalism shines. They also are very charitable with the community, which makes me proud to support and recommend it highly. As a Irish man this is important. Thank you for all you do
… moreRon DeShetler
We’re not regulars here, but we do stop in every so often — especially to watch Ohio State games.
Last night we came in specifically to watch the game. A couple we were sitting with had even called ahead and were told the game would be airing. While the TVs did have the game on, the jukebox was playing random music the entire time, and we couldn’t hear the broadcast at all.
We politely asked if the jukebox could be turned down just a little and the TV turned up so we could hear the game. That request was flatly refused.
What made it more frustrating was that it was obvious no one was actively paying for the jukebox — every time I selected “Hang On Sloopy,” it played immediately and cut off the previous song. I did this a few times to make the point that people were there to watch and hear the game.
At that point, whoever was behind the bar (I assume the owner) started cutting my paid selections off — while still refusing to turn the game volume up. So now not only were we unable to hear the game we were told would be on, but I was paying for music that was being shut down.
I understand it’s your business — but we’re paying customers. If you advertise that you’re showing a game, letting patrons hear it should be part of the experience. We weren’t trying to cause an issue; we were just trying to enjoy the game we came there to watch.
… moreJ R
Hit and miss on the food. Typical bar atmosphere. Fish and chips was not good. For being a special. All you can eat isnt a good value if it doesnt taste good. Also had a burger that was way over cooked. We sat for a while before being served.
… moreBilly Enfinger
The wings are cooked from raw to cooked and they are perfect. Great sauce. Jessica is the best bartender ever and the beers are great and so is the atmosphere. You have to check this place out.
… moreAl McCord
Great fish fry! Very busy when we arrived but seated fast. Service is very good and attentive! Lots of menu items. But we had fish fry! Big and tasty
… moreJulie Valdez
Ive been here before so the food is good, tonight my other half and i went in, it was slow, megan was soooo rude and acted like we were bothering her that we ordered one drink and left and went to taso italiano. Her dismissive rude behavior made us not want to be there fix your attitude megan,!!! Cause its normally and enjoyable bar
… moreShelly Welch
Stopped in and sat at the bar for an after dinner drink. Mango Cart on draft is delicious. Bartender was very friendly and helpful. Nice vibe. Definitely will go back and try the food!!
… more