Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2776 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Phone: (716) 446-9026
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Molinara’s N.Y. Pizza & Caffe – Tonawanda – Menu & Hours …
Specialty Pizza · Steak Fandango Pizza. Sliced rib-eye, 3 cheese blends, pepperoni, and our famous stuffed hot peppers with a choice of sauce. · Eggplant …
Molinara’s N.Y. Pizza & Caffe Menu – Slice
Molinara’s N.Y. Pizza & Caffe · Steak Fandango Pizza. Sliced rib-eye, 3 cheese blends, pepperoni, and our famous stuffed hot peppers with a choice of sauce.
Molinara’s N.Y. Pizza & Caffe | Tonawanda NY – Facebook
Molinara’s N.Y. Pizza & Caffe, Tonawanda , New York. 289 likes · 242 were here. Pizza place.
Reviews
Blair Dixon
We ordered a sicilian crust sweet sauce cheese and pepperoni pizza. Delivery was on time but the food was horrible! Burnt crust and no taste other than Grease. I highly discourage this place. Never going back again.
… moreJoelle Guarino
Stopped going after having a bad pizza many years ago. Decided to try again and not going back. Ordered a steak sub with cheese, oil, and mayo. Cheese looked like liquid, the mayo tasted like vinegar, and they don’t use real steak. They used steakumm type meat. Called to tell them and they offered a replacement sub. Went in and was told the cooler was off and everything spoiled. Nothing like giving us food poinsioning. Ordered a calzone that says on the menu ricotta and mozzarella cheese and added steak, spinach, and black olives. Got a burnt calzone that was supposed to be light baked. Had no Ricotta cheese in it, barely any meat Steakumms again and a few shavings of spinach. Bother the sub and calzone had the minimalist amount of ingredients. Ordered a shrimp dinner and the shrimp was overcooked and dried out. That’s 3 strikes not going again.
… moreEdward Litchard
We ordered Spaghetti and Meatballs, Stuffed Mushrooms and Antipasto Salad. The sauce tasted burnt, the Meatballs were definitely burnt, but the Stuffed Mushrooms were good and the Antipasto Salad was ok even though it was more like a Julianne Salad
… moreAnne Birt
The dining room is not glamorous, but the chicken molinara and the chicken marsala were excellent. The entree came with a good-sized salad and a tasty garlic knot/breadstick. The best part was that I could eat enough to be satisfied and still have leftovers for lunch tomorrow!
… moreNoah
Wish I could give you guys a 0 star review. I ordered a sweet sauce pizza with light cheese and was given a traditional sauce pizza with extra cheese. They closed early so when I called back they didn’t answer… called me back the next day and was told the “owner” said he could give me $5 back.. after I spent $17, that’s less than 1/3rd of what I spent. I declined, now you’re going to lose far more than $5 you’re going to lose the $100s of dollars I spend there yearly, learn how to make food correctly the way it’s ordered and you won’t have this issue.
… morebarb williams
The pizza is fine if you don’t want any sauce, it was so dry without any visible sauce. Very average turkey sub with mid level turkey and only 2 slices, one tomato that was the end with the stem cut out, barely a half of a piece of cheese and the lettuce was non existent. Also ordered blue cheese, paid online and never got it. With the price of take out..do better ♀️
… moreDave Nickens
First let me state that their stuffed pizza, pepper roll and wallbanger sub are very good. I’ll miss them. I’ve been ordering from them for at least 10 years. This Saturday I ordered a wallbanger sub. After paying $48 for my order I noticed the bag was a bit lighter than it should be for a wallbanger sub. When I got home I found an assorted sub. I called to complain because this is an $18 sub and have to argue with some a–hole that would not believe that he had made a wrong sub. He agreed to remake the sub and I have to drive back. When I get there he slammed the sub on the counter. I had the first sub in my hand and he never ask for it so I turned to leave and he yells at me to throw the sub away. I replied that I’ll eat it. He started screaming at me that I can’t eat it cause it is $17 worth of sub that I made him remake. I handed him the sub so he could see that it was just an assorted sub worth $12. In front of other customers, he smashed through the sub wirh his hands and started yelling at me that I ate the roast beef off of it before bringing it back and he’s been making this sub for years. I suggest that he must be kidding to accuse me of stealing and I tell him I won’t be back but he’s ignoring me now while eliciting sympathy from other customers because I drove a half hour twice and spent $48 to beat them out of $5 worth of luncheon meat. I would have expected an apology, maybe keep the first sub or offering to deliver the correct sub but no. Just an angry worker screaming at customers. I can’t go back. If the owner reads this, I expect an apology.
… moreMario Gomez
Great food and very good deals on combos. The food always tastes better than any pizza joints around.
… moreNukix 31
Close to home! Best pizza joint in the area. Better than the big chains. This mom n pop is my go-to for game day. They even delivered to my job sites with hazardous conditions! Thx guys. Keep up the good work.
… moreNick Julien
Do yourself a favor and order somewhere else.. ive been going here for years and lately if you try to order a supreme pizza the way you want it…the owner will deliberately leave out pepperoni just because he hates making the supreme.. i should have known to stop going when someone found a steel bolt in their slice of pizza and almost broke a tooth on it, but i gave it two more chances and both times the pepperoni is magically missing off the entire pizza, place was empty and dirty looking with slices that looked so old you wouldnt even think about buying let alone eating…plenty of other pizza joints in buffalo that would appreciate the business far more than this old guy
… more