Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At MOD Pizza Surprise Lake, pizza is personal. Create your perfect pizza or salad with unlimited toppings for one set price at your local MOD Pizza in Milton, WA! Choose from over 40 fresh toppings, 8 finishing sauces, and 8 dressings to build exactly what you’re craving. We also offer gluten-friendly and cauliflower crusts, vegan options, and delicious desserts to round out your meal. Order online or through the MOD app for pizza delivery or carryout today, or stop by 940 Meridian Ave E., Suite 101, Milton, WA to watch our amazing MOD Squad handcraft your perfect pizza. MOD Pizza Surprise Lake is proud to support local causes and give back to the Milton community.
Counter-serve, industrial-chic chain restaurant known for build-your-own pizzas.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 940 Meridian Ave E Suite 101, Milton, WA 98354
Phone: (253) 254-7547
Website: https://locations.modpizza.com/usa/wa/milton/940-meridian-ave-e.?utm_source=google&utm_medium=yext
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Pizza near Surprise Lake | Milton, WA – MOD Pizza
Conveniently located at 940 Meridian Ave E., Milton, WA our Surprise Lake MOD Pizza restaurant is a perfect option to grab a delicious lunch or dinner.
Restaurant Directory | Milton, Washington – MOD Pizza
View all MOD Pizza Milton, Washington locations including directions, restaurant hours and contact information. Find a MOD near you.
Menu – MOD Pizza
View the 40+ toppings, 8 finishing sauces, and 8 dressings to elevate your unlimited-topping pizza or salad — or try one of our signatures!
Reviews
Wild Child
Workers at 10:50pm 1/23/26 are 5 stars . They were wrapping things up putting things away. It looks like they were about to close, but I walked in in the last minute and they still made my pizza with great attitude. I don’t know their names. I didn’t ask. I just figured I’d put a review and send a shout out to those two. To that one dude n chick working that night. Thanks again.
… moreElena
I should’ve got the name of the lady who was manning the front so smoothly whilst back stock was being taken care off. She did a wonderful job maintaining prep and cooked food efficiently. Sure it’s a run of the mill chain but I still think she did awesome and should be appreciated for it. And no lie couldn’t help but take a bite before a photo, Thank you for your time.
… moreAlessia Burst
I wish I could give this location less stars. The staff is rude and has the personality of a brick wall. We got 2 pizzas. 1 I asked for extra meat and was told no, the other I made a statement and ordered every topping I could to prove that their method is flawed and the sign saying unlimited toppings is a lie. So 1 pizza was mostly crust. Go to any other location than this. I have eaten at tons of Mod’s and this is the absolute worst. It was an absolute waste of money.
… moreJ G
I don’t know if this location is a franchise under new ownership or what but boy has the quality ever diminished lately! When you spend $20 (including tax and tip ) for a pie with six tiny slices, you expect it to be halfway decent. Unfortunately, it’s our opinion that Domino’s offers twice the value these days. Did a mobile order and when we entered the store, the staff seemed very disinterested in simply handing us our pie, Does not surprise us that the place was basically a ghost town. I attached our receipt as demonstration that we ordered extra of the toppings, just to see what would happen, and as other reviews here have commented, it was a very large disappointment. It is our opinion that the toppings were actually fewer than the normal portion of toppings in recent history. Maybe they’re getting stingy and trying to squeeze a couple extra pennies out of the customer?
… moreSoulie
Firs time having MOD Pizza last night. I had always wanted to try it, so I went around 8pm and grabbed some. I got one regular pizza with several various toppings on it, which all of the toppings looked and tasted very fresh so that’s a plus. The unlimited toppings option is a great deal too!
I also got the garlic cheesy bread with the Sriracha Ranch dipping sauce, now I usually strongly dislike Ranch, but this Sriracha Ranch was insanely good, I would definitely get it again, went great with the cheesy bread and the pizza. I believe they put rosemary on the cheesy bread too as it had that lovely flavor of it.
All in all, nice workers and good service and fairly tasty food that seems well worth the price, my only dislike is I feel like the bread/dough and red pizza sauce were a bit too sweet for my liking and I wished they were a little more savory. But besides that, I would definitely go again.
… moreI also got the garlic cheesy bread with the Sriracha Ranch dipping sauce, now I usually strongly dislike Ranch, but this Sriracha Ranch was insanely good, I would definitely get it again, went great with the cheesy bread and the pizza. I believe they put rosemary on the cheesy bread too as it had that lovely flavor of it.
All in all, nice workers and good service and fairly tasty food that seems well worth the price, my only dislike is I feel like the bread/dough and red pizza sauce were a bit too sweet for my liking and I wished they were a little more savory. But besides that, I would definitely go again.
Devin Caldwell
This has to be the worst location I have ever been to. The people who work here are insulting. and they don’t allow you to make your pizza the way you wish. If something does not change, this location could go out of business. The pizza was horrible…
… moreIrina B
Walked in at 925pm today, placed our order at 929pm. Nothing exciting was happening, the place was empty. Still… 30 min until closing. We assumed it’s 30min of business, buying food, eating. The purple hair girl… Anything she had to set down, she threw it into place. Huffing and puffing and mumbling under her breath. If she had to answer any of our questions, she made sure to be short and snarky. Just a shitty attitude overall. We took our orders and headed out the door. Crappy service and interaction.
… moreStephanie Ferraro
They just left the pizza on the counter for over 15mins. Nobody called my name, they didn’t place it on top of the glass for me to see it was done. I had to go up and ask if my pizza was done after 20mins of waiting. When asked the employee said she didn’t know and asked the one that TAKES THE PIZZAS OUT OF THE OVEN how long it had been and she claimed she didn’t know either. Mind you there was only 1 other person in the store. I am so over this store’s carelessness and bad customer service.
… moreNataliya Lee
We came in about 40 minutes before closing… the girl with the colorful hair had the worst attitude. The moment we walked in, she became visibly irritated and was stomping, throwing things around, slamming doors.. they need some basic customer service training for their employees
… moreMark S
The new mod location has a great team. As usual, mod does it right with the pizzas and salads. My go to is always a family salad and a regular mod pizza. Customer service was great, the gentlemen cleaning up asked how to food was and took my plate awat like a 5 star restaurant. Obviously its not, but i thought that was really nice.
Thanks mod for another great location
… moreThanks mod for another great location