Ian Prokes
We had a great experience! We got the Pesto Chicken and the Pickle Play breadsticks. To be honest the Pickle Play is worthy of the 5 star rating alone. The one star reviews I see are so harsh, pizza is very solid. Sure it is a little pricey but literally everything is pricey, everything. Two pizzas from anywhere is gonna cost $30-$40 easily. The pesto chicken was real good and I will be back to try more.
… moreHeather Jurmu
Pizza was small for the price. There were space toppings. The pork was dried out. The crust was tough to chew. The garlic knots were so hard to chew the dough was over processed and there were so small. Also they forgot the ranch dressing very disappointed ☹️
… moreSteven Merriott
Disappointing pizza for $16. Pizza was overcooked and sun dried tomatoes were burnt. We always like the convenience of getting food while we’re on the lake but the quality doesn’t match the price.
… moreJoseph Zeeuw
I agree with much of what was said in reviews from 4+ months ago but they really seem to have turned it around. The crust seems closer to the GR location. The pizza was ready on time, and the staff was very professional. This has been the case the last several visits so not just a fluke! I encourage locals to give them a second chance. It’s a great pizza and cool company who gives back to the community.
… moreJeanette Prince
The prices to add on toppings are a little out of control considering the size of the pie. I added basil and each piece had one chunk of leaf on it. It would make sense to sprinkle some thinly sloshed basil over the whole pie, no? There’s not enough cheese on the pizza, and it’s super frustrating to be forced to enter a tip before you can checkout. I get that you can type in zero, but that feels a little risky when they haven’t made your pizza yet. Don’t force a tip when you don’t even offer delivery.
… moreJohn Harpst
Ordered Curse of the Goat and Plain Cheese pizza. It is definitely a curse. Very soggy and doughy crust. Could barely cut through it with a steak knife. Cheese pizza was a little better. Sauce tastes like it’s just tomato paste, very acidic and instant heart burn.
Too bad as this is close to my house. I don’t remember the pizza at the brewery on Leonard tasting like this. I will definitely go to Vitales down the street.
… moreThomas Cruttenden
I really wanted to like mitten pizza because it’s just around the corner. Sorry, no. If I can save my neighbors some disappointment, this review will be worth it because I don’t like to give bad reviews.
Crust was very tough and pretty flat.
I really like that they have a range of toppings, it’s too bad they all taste like the same thing which seems to be cheese and a spicy sauce.
We ordered a custom pizza with five traditional toppings that nearly doubled the pie price. The toppings seemed to be placed on the inner portion of the pizza rather than the whole thing.
Considering how circles work it seemed like we got about 1/3 the total amount of toppings we should have. It was a good science illustration to consider the area of a circle. I’m trying to find positive things here.
So we did get some enjoyment from this experience, it’s just that we won’t be back.
… moreKatie Hoekstra
Outstanding pizza and prompt, friendly service! We love the OG Mitten and it’s great to have this location a bit closer to home. Don’t miss the pizza flight where you can combine 4 of their unique flavors. Thanks y’all!
… moreKyle Cushman
Hands down the BEST Pizza in the state of michigan. Anybody who rates this below a 5 doesn’t know pizza. I’ve been ordering pizza every Friday for 10 years. All of my prior loyalty’s went out the window the day I ordered from here for the first time. It’s been 2 years now and it’s the only pizza I eat! I’m ordering two right now!
… moreKristin Wolden Nitz
Last week I came in and gave the person at the counter the name of the person who ordered the pizza. The server checked the warmer and said it wasn’t ready. Fifteen minutes later, I checked again. Our pizzas had been in the warmer the whole time!
This is unacceptable.
I don’t know if the server misheard my name or what, but this is a training issue. I blame management. The pizzas themselves were great as usual. My intent is to take this review down once it’s acknowledged.
… more