taryn weber
My favorite bakery! ❤️ been a lover of this bakery for a long time now. Not only are their cookies and baked goods absolutely delicious, but their customer service makes you feel like family. My favorite go-to cookies are their yoyos & oatmeal cream. My husband loves the double peanut butter ones and the little loves everything (obviously!). I also LOVE getting their specialty decorated sugar cookies for Christmas, Valentines & Easter. HIGHLY RECCOMEND!
… moreiraq sucked
I’m from Fayetteville, every time I’m in the area, I stop by and grab some of these delicious cookies. The taste is so good, it’s hard to put to words. They are better than any grocery store bakery by far. I’ve tried cookies I would normally never think about, just because of how good all the other ones are. Nothing can compare to these. It’s like Gramma cooked them and I’m a kid again. My wife and I love this place.
… moreBeckie Northrop
I highly recommend this bakery! We bought a delicious “almond joy” cookie full of chocolate chips, coconut and a yummy filling. We also had a buttery soft pretzel. I wish I lived closer to Sanford so I could go more often! Also, the owner was super helpful in recommending a good local Mexican restaurant as well.
… moreK
Oh. My. God. When I say these were the best cookies I’ve ever had in my life I absolutely mean it. Even Gideons at Disney Spring couldn’t hold a candle to these divine treats!!
And the service was phenomenal!!!
I was told about this place 2 years ago when I used to work at a lil blt shop in chapel hill and I’ve thought about it ever since- saying when I make my way to Sanford I will be going there! Well, for 2 years I hadn’t had any reason to go to Sanford until I caught a sick little bird, so feeding two birds with one worm I dropped the baby off at Holly’s Nest and popped over to Millie’s where I was warmly greeted immediately.
I ordered a banana bread cookie, chocolate chip, and turtle. White I saw they have a caramel apple cookie, it (of course) was sold out, and most places will tell you that’s it for the day but not Millie! She had the oven on and when I asked how long she was more excited than I was to tell me only 45m and even gave me a few places to check out during my wait!
My boyfriend, my employee, and I were all blown away by how delicious these cookies were! While I shared most of them, the chocolate chip didn’t even make it home!
Might I add, I do not have a sweet tooth either.
So now I went from having no reason to go to Sanford to Millie’s being the reason I will definitely be returning!!
… moreJulia Sears
Delicious local cookie store. The owner is super friendly. You can’t go wrong here. Everything we had was good — classic chocolate chip, sugar cookie, key lime and the one with Reese’s in it. Get a cookie and explore downtown Sanford!
… moreMelissa Boro
The cookies and pastries I bought for game night with my girl friends were delicious. Everyone enjoyed the delicious treats. Moist and very tasty.
… moreKerrianne Dudek
I honestly can say these are the best cookies I’ve ever tasted. Once I discovered these cookies I drove an hour round trip to pick up cookies on a weekly basis until the store opened. I’m so excited for the store because I can go pick up cookies almost any day I crave one. They’re sweet but also perfectly salted. I’ve had so many bad cookies and didn’t know it until I had one of these. Chocolate espresso is my absolute favorite but they’re all delicious. The store is beautiful and it’s in the cutest part of town. Go get some because just 1 is not enough!
Also the macrons are incredible- they’re everything they should be and the flavors are like heaven
… moreJulia Martinez
The sugar cookie looked cute and simple, but the taste was DELICIOUS. That has got to be the best sugar cookie I’ve ever had. They also have great customer service.nvery friendly! 🙂
… moreKatrina Garrison
UPDATE: MMB never disappoints! My all-time favorite flavor is Key Lime Pie, but truly I’ve never had a bad flavor. Customer service is always excellent and the quality of their cookies and macarons are top notch!
Amazing!! I was gifted some of Millie’s Mama Bakes delicious cookies and scones today from a friend. I shared them with my co-workers and they loved them so much that they bought their own boxes of cookies! So good:-)
… moreCrystal Tighe
Literally my favorite place for baked goods, and cookies aren’t even usually my thing!
… more