Social Profile: 
… View more
Located in the heart of historic Yaphank next to Upper Lake, The Mill House Inn has been a home town staple. We pride ourselves on using the best ingredients available to us. We provide our fish from local purveyors, antibiotic free chicken, fresh produce, and more. We work hard to provide every customer a pleasant experience from a romantic dinner to a fun night out with friends!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 284 Mill Rd, Yaphank, NY 11980
Phone: (631) 345-0361
Website: http://millhouseinnyaphank.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Millhouse Inn – Yaphank, NY
Located in the heart of historic Yaphank next to Upper Lake, The Mill House Inn has been a home town staple. We pride ourselves on using the best ingredients …
Mill House Inn | Yaphank NY – Facebook
Mill House Inn · Meet the amazing team dedicated to making your visit memorable and enjoyable. · Hey seafood lovers! · Enjoy good company and great drinks in a …
Mill House Inn (@millhouseinnyaphank) · Yaphank, NY – Instagram
Photo by Mill House Inn on March 16, 2026. Enjoy good company and great drinks in a lively atmosphere that’s perfect for unwinding. #MillhouseInn #Yaphank # …
Reviews
V M
Delicious lunch served timely the exact way I ordered. Piping hot and good portion. Beautiful view. Clean restrooms. Very sweet waitress that took wonderful care of elderly patrons. It was a pleasure dining there.
… moreKym Mirabella
What a lovely restaurant/cafe. Food was excellent. I had the big clams which I loved, and the seafood fra diavolo! Everybody else got different things and they all loved what they got I would say go to this place. It’s not fancy but sometimes not being fancy get you the best food and plenty of it. Would go there again. The staff was friendly and excellent. I did not go to the bar and everybody was having fun. So maybe one day I’ll stop by the bar cuz it looks like it’s a hit!
… morePatty Lofaro
We had a delicious dinner with starting appetizers of the clam soup and famous baked clams along with two of the best Martinis. It was all so good. Our entrees were the German mixed plate with the best Sauerbraten I have ever had. My husband really
enjoyed the Long Island platter – fish variety with vegetables. We are in town from Sunset Beach NC (former LI residents) and we always try to seek out these restaurant gems when we travel.
… moreenjoyed the Long Island platter – fish variety with vegetables. We are in town from Sunset Beach NC (former LI residents) and we always try to seek out these restaurant gems when we travel.
Brittany Katzdorn
Cute little restaurant overlooking a pond with great food and occasionally live music. Food was decent. Large portions. Very busy.
… moreMarlene is Key
I’ve dined at Millhouse Inn a few times. The parking lot will always be a challenge as it’s dirt and not so friendly on certain luxury cars. For some reason whenever I go there, it seems they’re a bit short staffed but overall it’s great service. The food portions are very generous and the menu has many selections, my mixed drink was a bit bland but I always enjoy going as the space itself is nice. I did not visit the restroom but I would recommend trying it at least once! The area itself just needs a little love.
… moreKeith From NY
I had a steak and it was very good. It came with mashed potatoes and makes vegetables. No salad. The tables are crowded together and the silverware that I got looked like it had never seen a dishwasher. I told the waitress and she never brought a replacement set I had to get it from someone else from another table. Not impressed for the prices they charge
… moreAaron P.
Millhouse Inn was delicious. A great hidden gem. Went for lunch and was very pleased with the quality of food. I never, ever order a salad when out to eat, but on the recommendation of the waitress, we both got the millhouse salad… it was awesome! Will definitely be going back!
… moreKanishka Wijesekara (Kanishka)
Went to this American/German restaurant by the water with my wife for lunch. The ambience and service is amazing. Plenty of parking too. Had the German sampler and the only thing I liked about it was the bratwurst and the potato ball. The homemade ginger sauce was too sweet for my liking. My wife had the chicken ALA Rachel and that was quite good. Didn’t get anything to drink since we were driving.
… moreElise Skidmore
We tried Millhouse Inn because we’re were given a gift card. We’d never been before. We enjoyed it very much. Had a chance to try some German dishes we hadn’t had in ages, which were very good. The portions were large, and the service was friendly. When you enter, there’s a foyer that separates the bar from the dining room. Even though the bar was busy, we didn’t have to listen to it while enjoying our meal.
… moreLee Knight
As soon as I walked in I was greeted with a smile from Lauren, a pleasant and lovely server. The Mill House Salad has every one of the my favorite things in one salad. Avocado, seared tuna, candied walnuts, mangos, cranberries, no goat cheese unfortunately but I can’t complain when everything else was there! Lauren suggested other cheese options! She laid out extra napkins without me having to ask. Nice view of the lake.
… more