Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Warm, homey restaurant offering an array of sandwiches, frozen yogurt & soft-serve treats.
Hours
| Monday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 48 S 1st E, Rexburg, ID 83440
Phone: (208) 356-0847
Website: http://millhollowrestaurant.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Millhollow Restaurant
Founded in 1983, we brought the first soft-frozen yogurt to Southeast Idaho. In 1995, we also brought the first toasted sandwiches to Rexburg.
Millhollow Restaurant (@millhollowrestaurant) • Instagram photos …
Sandwiches, salads, & soft-frozen treats! Mon.-Th. 10:30 am – 10:00 pm. Fri.-Sat. 10:30 am – 10:30 pm. Closed Sun. 48 S. 1st E., Rexburg, ID · Photo by …
Millhollow | Rexburg ID – Facebook
Dine-in · Curbside pickup · In-store pickup · Outdoor seating ; MESSENGER. Millhollow. Frozen Yogurt Shop. . SEND MESSAGE ; . SEND MESSAGE ; MESSENGER. Millhollow.
Reviews
Jace Meyer
Best Sandwich in rexburg hands down! The bread is soft and delicious and the sandwich’s are massive as well! All the toppings tasted fresh and they were very generous with the portions as well! For $13 I was very happy with my meal as well! I love the old style feel of the whole restaurant as well. The log cabin feel and the beautiful landscaping as well, makes it feel like a small local gem which it is! I didn’t know that they had frozen yogurt when we first got there, my wife and I will definitely be back for the delicious sandwich and some frozen yogurt as well! 10/10 would recommend to anyone
… moreSavannah Dennert
Staple for for rexburg, hidden gem small business. Super yummy sandwiches, and frozen yogurt. Lots of variety. You can build your own. Fun environment! Servers are friendly, very clean space.
… moreEmi Ly
Decided to try it out since it is a local favorite. Has a similar layout to a Culver’s or a Wendy’s. Earthy and country tones.
Veggies were fresh and crisp, just what you want in a sandwich. Yogurt was good, and good selection of soda options. Choosing the meal combo and then mixing the yogurt and soda yourself is cheaper than ordering a float.
Over priced just because of the serving sizes. Quality of the food was great and the staff were really nice.
… moreVeggies were fresh and crisp, just what you want in a sandwich. Yogurt was good, and good selection of soda options. Choosing the meal combo and then mixing the yogurt and soda yourself is cheaper than ordering a float.
Over priced just because of the serving sizes. Quality of the food was great and the staff were really nice.
Kelly Cook
Sandwiches are so good. Especially the turkey peppered bacon! And my husband loves them too and he’s not normally a sandwich type of guy. This is the only place I go nowadays when I’m up in Rexburg!
… moreTanni Bowers
This was a quaint little restaurant in Rexburg Idaho. They offer sandwiches, salads, yogurt and shakes. We got sandwiches and chips. Next time we will try the shakes and yogurt. They had grilled or cold sandwiches and plenty of toppings to your design. It was a nice stop for a quick and healthy bite. Definitely will return.
… moreL B
I’ve been coming here for 20 years and it’s still as good as ever! The toasted sourdough sandwiches are the way to go! I like to think of it as the 5 Guys of sandwiches. You can choose from so many toppings and they don’t cost extra. It’s hard to find a place that has sprouts for a sandwich! I would come just for the sandwiches, but combine that with the best frozen yogurt in Idaho, and you have a perfect meal! I used to always get the blenders, but more recently I’ve become a fan of the fresh yogurt flavors with tart peach, huckleberry, and coconut being my favorite!
… moreRyan Petersen
I like this place. It is good. I wouldn’t say I love it only because sometimes the food isn’t my favorite. Their sandwich’s are pretty tasty and have a good selection of vegetables but often times I have gone they have been out of stuff. Their frozen yogurt though is heavenly. Definitely get some frozen yogurt!
… moreCharise Mills
The milkshake here is AMAZING!!! I love the flavors of the strawberries!!! It’s my Number 1 place to get drinks now.
The pistachio ice cream is pretty good too! Would have gotten the frozen yogurt but they don’t have the flavor we’d like to try!
The sandwich is pretty good too! Definitely get them toasted. Half sandwich is a decent amount of food for me along with the drink. Pretty cheap overall!
*** update:
I came back here and got the chocolate milk shake. It is SO GOOD!!! Love it!
… moreThe pistachio ice cream is pretty good too! Would have gotten the frozen yogurt but they don’t have the flavor we’d like to try!
The sandwich is pretty good too! Definitely get them toasted. Half sandwich is a decent amount of food for me along with the drink. Pretty cheap overall!
*** update:
I came back here and got the chocolate milk shake. It is SO GOOD!!! Love it!
Glenn Stimpson
I’ve only had their frozen yogurt. It is really good. We usually get a chocolate frozen yogurt with cookie dough on top. I’ve only been there around 8 pm. They seem fairly busy at that time, but I’ve only had to wait for a little bit to order only once. I can usually pull up, order, get my order, and be back in my car in about 5 minutes (except for 1 time).
… moreIgnacio Rodríguez
Classic Rexburg spot for ice cream. Sandwiches are okay. DO get the Italian sandwich. DO NOT get the grilled chicken sandwich. As far as the ice creams go they’re all pretty good.
I would say you will definitely need at least a whole sandwich. Unless you’re not hungry at all I would recommend not getting the half one.
Parking is kind of limited but for whatever reason I’ve never had problems finding a spot to park.
… moreI would say you will definitely need at least a whole sandwich. Unless you’re not hungry at all I would recommend not getting the half one.
Parking is kind of limited but for whatever reason I’ve never had problems finding a spot to park.