Sof K
Good food, but depends on the person. Great fries all around. Milkshakes and other ice creams are crazy expensive. Lots of family and kids. Those are my only complaints, its a great place, very wonderful.
… moreRick K
Pizza aficionados who find themselves in either Pittsburgh or Cleveland should definitely make a pit stop at Milky Way Pizza. Both locations offer distinct experiences, and here’s a comparative review to guide your pizza journey.
Pittsburgh Location:
Milky Way Pizza in Pittsburgh is a haven for lovers of New York-style pizza. The crust is thin, allowing for that iconic fold, and strikes the right balance between crispy and soft. The tangy sauce, combined with generous toppings and perfectly melted cheese, makes for a delightful bite every time. The ambiance is lively, reminiscent of the bustling pizzerias in New York, and the staff is both friendly and efficient.
Cleveland Location:
The Cleveland branch of Milky Way Pizza offers a different take. The dough here is reminiscent of bread dough, which gives it a thicker and softer texture. However, there have been instances where the dough feels a tad undercooked, which might not appeal to everyone. That said, the toppings are fresh and abundant, ensuring a flavorful experience with each slice.
… moreNikolas J Orlowski
Excellent service, excellent food, and compassionate staff that reintroduce a universally paramount ingredient that seems to be difficult to come across now a days – LOVE. They love what they do, and you can taste it in their food. 10/10 definitely recommend! You can even order online for delivery or take out through their website!
… moreRabbi Yisroel Bernath
Ah, the Milky Way pizza, where cheese and toppings form constellations in a galaxy of flavor. An epicurean voyage worth taking, each slice a celestial body of culinary delight.
The egg salad wrap—ah, the humble egg elevated to aristocracy! It’s like wisdom wrapped in humility; simple ingredients composed into a masterpiece of taste.
And the cheese pretzel? Think of it as life’s twisty, salty roads, enrobed in the comfort of cheese. A lesson in harmonizing contrasts, if you will.
In short, a trifecta where flavor, comfort, and a dash of whimsy collide!
… morerobert webb
I like that they make their own bread. That’s never a bad thing. They call there fries spicy but they’re just seasoned for people a little intimidated by the name they’re good.I will try the pizza next time. I’ll definitely be back.
… moreJapo Parcero
I was passing through Pittsburgh going to the East coast and was looking for vegan places to eat in and came across Milky Way. I love how straightforward the place is. It was easy to order, the food came in pretty quickly, and the food was amazing! I ordered the veggie chicken parmesan and it tasted fantastic! Very filling as well. I also ordered The Cowboy burger which uses their house-made veggie patty and it was phenomenal. Would def come back when I pass Pittsburgh again!
… moreShmuel Ackerman
Fantastic hidden gem. Expected a little pizza place. Found the most unique selection of pizza I’ve ever seen. The cheddar ranch was delicious as were the fries. The menu was huge and everything was delicious.
… moreThank you Hashem!
This restaurant is a real good one. The food here is delicious , and fantastic staff. I highly recommend this place
… moreD
The pizza wasn’t cooked all the way through and quality of the cheese and the sauce weren’t good at all. The fries were pretty good.
… moreCardiologist At Heart
I’ve been at many pizza shops but I find their salad bar to be exceptional and very fresh. The service is quick and professional. The portion sizes are very large for very fair pricing.
… more