Easygoing, veteran Italian restaurant in a traditional setting with a wraparound bar.
Clarence Jefferson Hall Jr.
i grew up near Plattsburgh and it only took me 46 years to come to Mickey’s. the food was excellent, the service was outstanding, and the atmosphere was relaxing. will definitely be back. delicious!
… moreJames Jock
Dinner with my daughter. She had balsamic chicken and I had chicken parm with spaghetti. I was surprised at how much water was on my plate. It really made it sloppy. The dinners didn’t seem as hot as I had expected. The brownie sundae came with a delicious and warmed brownie. The peanut butter pie was super sweet like you’d expect. Worth the $83 price? Undecided.
… moreJulie L
I message on facebook that my birthday was coming up and I loved a certain meal and asked if they thought they would be serving it in the future. They wrote back and asked if Thursday was good! I was in heaven it was so good! Our waitress, Jillian was excellent! Thank you for making my birthday special and the chocolate cake …. WOW!
… moreTom V
We went here for a last minute choice and we had a great time. Menu has variety but it’s not a novel. Staff are great and down to earth. Nachos were delicious and the burger was cooked perfectly. We will be back
… moreJoel Partlow
I did not make it to the lounge however it sounded fun. We sat at the restaurant, which was cozy and bustling with wait staff. We where promptly seated and arranged for drinks. We only ordered appetizers and drinks. The loaded chicken nachos are over the top! So much cheese! The onion strings and honey mustard where pretty good and a unique twist on fried onions. Wings, the honey lime jalapeno wings where off the cart amazing! Nice size to the wings and the flavor was delicious!!!
… moreRiverday D
After calling ahead, our party of 6 was seated immediately. Everyone enjoyed the meals. Our server, Jillian, was very attentive and waited on us with a smile. We would go back if ever in the area. It was a pleasant experience.
… moreAndy Sharma
Amazing food paired with awesome service. Must recommended if you are in Plattsburgh and looking to have lunch or dinner. They have good vegetarian selections as well. We will surely visit again.
… moreclaudia baker
Thoroughly disappointed, will not be going back. Our burgers and fries were cold, like they had been sitting around the kitchen. Meatball grinder was also cold and looked old and disgusting. The nachos, which are our usual, were also ice cold and poorly dressed. Our waiter, Demetri, was good but should not have served us such poor quality food. Is anybody managing it because nobody seemed to care.
… moreCaitlin Roy
Fall has arrived at Mickey’s!! Got the opportunity to try their weekend special cinnamon apple crunch cheesecake (rotating weekend special) which was, by far, the best dessert I’ve had from here. It was just the right balance of sweet and savory while also being a great end of meal treat that doesn’t make you feel over full. The pumpkin drink special, made with pumpkin rumchatta, butterscotch liquor and pumpkin whiskey was creamy, sweet and body warming. My pizza, pepperoni, mushroom and hot sausage was cooked to perfection and never disappoints!
… morebryce colwell
Chicken Marsala, yum! And they make a good one! ((EDIT: so much for that, I got one for take out and it was disgusting. So much so I almost got in the car to return it. We’ll, so much for that) However, the beef tip one is better and they refuse to substitute. I think it’s BS Customers should get what they WANT, most places I have been do, except the most pretentious. The place is also so very small. But they are doing it right, still packing in after all these years..
… more