Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4900 NY-52, Jeffersonville, NY 12748
Phone: (845) 482-3900
Website: http://michelangelosfamily.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Michelangelo’s Restaurant & Pizzeria in Jeffersonville, New York
the best Italian Restaurant & PIZZA in Sullivan county, NY! · Join our mailing list · Join Our Newsletter for Exclusive Offers and Special Savings! · PRIVATE …
Michelangelo’s Restaurant & Pizzeria | Jeffersonville NY – Facebook
Michelangelo’s is everyone’s favorite bite in town. Whether you’re craving saucy BBQ chicken pizza, creamy baked farfalle pasta, crispy mozzarella sticks, or …
Menu – Michelangelo’s Restaurant & Pizzeria
Hungry? Order Now for pick-up (845) 482-3900. MENU. Download PDF. Loading files. 1/2. Next. Show More. Copyright © 2025 Michelangelo’s Restaurant & Pizzeria …
Reviews
Raymond Suarez
This place has some amazing food pizza slice is one of the best I’ve ever had very highly recommended worth the trip from Orange County
… moreLisa Prosper
We were passing through town early afternoon, in time for lunch. We noticed Michelangelo’s. It was very clean looking from the outside and their special board looked good so we thought we would give it a try. Everything was wonderful! The inside of the restaurant was just as clean and crisp, bathrooms were too. Loved the large sink!
Those working there were so nice, polite and helpful. I had a BLT wrap, my husband had a Philly cheesesteak sandwich. The wrap was full of goodness, nothing lacking there. The cheesesteak was bursting from the bun , melted cheese all over the top. It looked delicious and he said it was. There were no leftovers to take back to the hotel! I can only imagine the rest of the food was just as good with the steady stream of customers for eating in and takeout. If I’m in the area again, it’s a guarantee we will be stopping back.
… moreThose working there were so nice, polite and helpful. I had a BLT wrap, my husband had a Philly cheesesteak sandwich. The wrap was full of goodness, nothing lacking there. The cheesesteak was bursting from the bun , melted cheese all over the top. It looked delicious and he said it was. There were no leftovers to take back to the hotel! I can only imagine the rest of the food was just as good with the steady stream of customers for eating in and takeout. If I’m in the area again, it’s a guarantee we will be stopping back.
Samuel Kaplan Art com
If you gotta have Pizza… your journey has ended rigjt here on Rt 52 on Jeff..
Mmmmmm good
… moreMmmmmm good
Ro C
Nice pizzeria/restaurant. I’ve been before and had their standard pizza and chicken roll which was good BUT today we stopped in and we tried the bbq chicken slice and garlic chicken slice with shaved Parmesan and both were outstanding. These slices are reminiscent of specialty city slices and are just as good if not even better than some I’ve had.
… moreKelly Rajkovic
Was here last weekend visiting Villa Roma Resort and was told to check out Michelangelo’s. Wow! Best Chicken Marsala I have EVER had! Seriously. Portions were huge; staff was incredibly friendly. My family and I actually went back two days later because all of our meals were “that good.” Be sure to call ahead and make reservations because even though they may look like the local pizza joint, they are far beyond. The locals know it and so does everyone at the resort. Can’t wait to go back next year! THANKS GUYS! Delicious!
… moreSara Barakat
Michelangelo’s Restaurant really came through for us on a 10-day catering event. We had several dietary restrictions, including attendees who were vegans, had a strict gluten free diet, and one person with serious nut allergies. Steve and Alex were able to accommodate each of these restrictions with delicious options for each of them, handling everything with professionalism and care. The gluten free attendee noted that he gets sick easily, even when food is labeled gluten-free, but he felt great after eating at Michelangelo’s. The food was consistently excellent, with a great variety and inclusive options that kept everyone happy throughout the event. Steve and Alex were always so pleasant to work with for the full 10 days. I first came across them last year and will continue to use this restaurant every year when we come back to Jeffersonville for our course.
… moreJoann Lare
The food is always amazing, I especially love their chicken Marsala, and you can always count on leftovers for the next day!
The staff is always friendly and give great service! 5 stars for this amazing restaurant!
… moreThe staff is always friendly and give great service! 5 stars for this amazing restaurant!
Keith Bentzel
Second visit for us we enjoyed both times. We think the food is tasty and the service is good. The place is very clean. I enjoy eating here and walking to the stores to shop local.
… moreMiguel Cruz
The food was wonderful. The service was amazing and the pizza was out of this world.
If you’re in town you should definitely stop by.
Very clean and very professional.
… moreIf you’re in town you should definitely stop by.
Very clean and very professional.
Jaun Smith
Would never come back. Raw and soggy pizza, paid over $34 dollars for this. All of the employees are extremely rude don’t waste your money here go to Callicoon or Monticello was told if I take review down I will get a refund still waiting on that I called the pizza shop to discuss my refund again extremely rude says they dont know anything about it and I will have to wait for the owner very sad this business is just down right failing I would give a zero if that was a option!
… more