Down-to-earth counter-serve outfit dishing up pizza with gourmet ingredients like truffle cream.
Sean Feig
I finally made it to Miami slice after hearing all the food critics on YouTube rave about how it’s the best pizza in Miami, spoiler alert… it’s not.
I put two photos of slices of their Margherita pepperoni and plain cheese and their hot honey. I will start with the good, very firm, well done, almost no flop, crispy pizza.
Here’s the problems with the pizza. When I bite into a fresh slice, I expect flavor that resonates with and kind of explodes flavor of delicious mozzarella, good tomato sauce and high quality dough. This is a cheat food, it’s supposed to make you go mmmmm when you get that first bite, and sadly, this pizza just didn’t have that. The cheese was dull, they added feta to it for some reason and it was just really bland.
I also put a picture of their hot honey which is sacrilegios to me to put on pizza. But oddly enough it actually made it taste better. Also this place ain’t cheap about $6 a slice or more. Just not worth the hype, it tries to be fancy with fancy toppings but in the end the pizza itself just is void of flavor. I won’t be going back, 3 stars.
… moreMaria Castillo
Miami Slice has a lot going for it. The dough was thin, light, and well made, which I really enjoyed. While the Margherita pizza didn’t quite match the high expectations set by the rave reviews, it could have used more sauce and cheese, they did include a small container of burrata on the side, which was a nice touch and helped enhance the flavor.
The space is very small, and because the patio wasn’t comfortable due to the cold and windy weather, we had to take our pizza to go, so I didn’t get to fully experience the atmosphere or service. Overall, it was a solid pizza with good quality dough, I’d be open to trying it again, maybe dining in when the weather is better.
… moreRachael
the pizza was very good, but it was over $15 for 1 slice. i have had pizza almost exactly the same tasting as this one at other normal places where a whole pizza was about the same price. i guess good to try once just because of the popularity and more of a snack, but probably wouldn’t pay for it again. the $8 extra for the white cheese on top didn’t even really have a taste, and had to come in a cup on the side if you got it to go. not many seats inside, and have to fine and pay for street parking
… moreCristhian Cedeno
Best pizza I have ever had. The pepperoni with spicy honey is amazing and was my favorite. And we tried that and the mushroom and another with pesto. But the pepperoni was the best. Pepperoni is just different. Is not like your regular Pizza Hut or papa John pepperoni is high quality pepperoni that melts in ur mouth. And the honey on top is perfect. This place gets packed for obvious reasons. But the pizza came out extremely fast I was surprised how fast. So everything perfect.
… moreVictor Arellano
I believe that sometimes a five-star review can ruin a restaurant’s reputation. You set such high expectations that it’s impossible to live up to them. In this case, I literally refuse to believe that my pizza could be that good. I thought it was just another pizza, but trust me, it is really that good!
… moreAyaan Singh
Miami slice lives up to the hype , amazing pizza, came all the way from hollywood to try it. It’s amazing tastes good , mushroom and Margherita was my fav , I tried all 5 slices , pepperoni proper has hot honey, so at first it has a tiny sweet bit , but it’s eatable . Mushroom was amazing, same with Margherita. It’s a must try. Outside sitting is for takeaway , so what we did is that we ordered in the restaurant cause there was no space inside , then we picked it up and ate in the outside space
… moreDrea S
Honestly $48 for a pizza is crazy. It was good pizza but the price was over the top especially since they have like no seating and I had to put additional toppings myself. I’ve had better pizza before for a lower price. If the price was better, I would understand. We also had to sit inside so the atmosphere was okay. There was limiting seating inside.
… moreIndiana Rodrigues
Honestly after moving down here from NYC, this is the one spot that makes me feel like I’m back home again! The cute speakeasy vibe at the bar and being able to see into the kitchen provides a fun, interactive experience that gets even better when your pizza arrives. The pizza is perfectly crisp and the toppings, sauces and herbs are so well executed. I love this spot and will always come back for both dine in and take out. While it’s on the pricier side, it’s 100% worth it.
… moreMatthew Brenner
Didn’t have to wait long on a Saturday night, maybe 15 minutes. We did take out, and ate outside on the picnic tables. The crust was very good, and the pepperoni honey slice was fantastic, but the plain slice wasn’t very crispy, and I like the sauce to be a little sweeter. Very good, but steep at $9 / slice. Definitely one of the best slices you can get in Miami if you like thin and crispy
… moreSusie Sands
The pizza was delicious!! Loved the crunch of the pie, the sweet sauce mixed with the pepperoni cups and hot honey! The combo was perfect. Family members ordered other slices and raved too. Get an extra dipping sauce for the thick crust that eats like a well cooked bread stick.
… more