Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Meatball Mafia – A Meatball You Can’t Refuse!
Meatball Mafia in Hilliard, OH. Family owned and operated, we offer Youngstown-Italian style Pizza and Subs from our location in Old Hilliard (Center Street …
Menu – The Meatball Mafia – A Meatball You Can’t Refuse!
Menu for Meatball Mafia in Hilliard, OH. … with provolone and mozzarella cheese, crushed meatballs and sauce in an Italian torpedo roll. 83005. 2 Reviews …
Order Online – A Meatball You Can’t Refuse!
Pizzas · Cheese Pizza · Pepperoni Pizza · Sausage · Brier Hill · White Pizza · The Butcher · Sloppy Guiseppe · Big Fat Antnee.
Reviews
Nikk Spiert
A friend from Youngstown recommended this to “get a taste” of Youngstown… We now have plans to go to the Briar Hill Festival in Youngstown… The food here is phenomenal (try the Briar Hill pizza)! The staff is friendly and helpful and the service is quick. Thanks for the great experience. And of course… you have to try to meatballs!
… moreE B
I’m from Youngstown-Warren Ohio… Born and raised. Went to YSU. This place is really good. The meatballs and the sauce are delicious. The Satriale Bowl is “Y-town” in a bowl. DiRusso sausage… Pepperoni… OMG. The most amazing Italian peppers in oil and fresh bread reminds me of being home, with friends, with family… Good times, great food. I’ve been here 4 times… Each time is excellent.
… moreErin Monroe
If you’re from Youngstown, you know good pizza. Since moving to Columbus, I seriously struggled to find pizza that was up to par with the quality and flavors I grew up with. Meatball Mafia was exactly what I was looking for! The pizza was amazing, and the decor was so nostalgic of home. Even the names of some dishes were spot on. I will definitely become a regular here!!
… moreaquateen 28
Their Briar Hill pizza truly lives up to their “st Anthony style” claim. My body has been overwhelmed with multiple waves of goosebumps. It’s so damn good you can almost taste the potholes
… moreMark B.
Enjoyed the pizza at this place. More of a pan pizza style, only size offered is 12 inches. Had a lot of cheese and the toppings were pretty tasty. The sub on the other hand was pretty subpar. I wouldn’t have a sub here again but would def come back for the pizza.
… moreTexas, Garth Brooks&Dunn
Had the meatball consigliere sub and it was average. Sauce overpowered the ricotta or else there wasn’t much ricotta. Meatballs also seemed a little dry. Seemed like they may have been sitting in the sauce or a food warmer for too long.
… moreSara Kilpatrick
Are you from Youngstown and have been desperately seeking good pizza in a cardboard square loving Columbus? Then Meatball Mafia is for you! Seriously, best pizza I have found in Columbus. meatballs are good, too. For Brier Hill pizza is better than what I’ve had in Youngstown. The Butcher and Vindicator pizzas were excellent, too. Will be back.
… moreSarah Hall
The best pizza! I love their white pizza with hot pepper, my husband loves all the meat so the Butcher Is his favorite. My mom loves the Briar Hill pizza, and we both love the hot peppers. A little piece of Youngstown in Columbus.
… moreDano
Maybe it was the 14 mile run or the solid IPA, but this pizza hit home hardcore. Very enjoyable. Loved the soft thicker dough (but not too thick). I’ll definitely buy again
… moreJeff Rettinger
Stopped in for pizza mainly, had a pepperoni mushroom and sausage. Crust was very good. Thick but not doughy. Flavors were good. Toppings could be more plentiful. Especially for a 20.00 12 inch pie. In my opinion.
… more