Tim Parker
Tracy McMichaels is the owner she has a light about herself that everyone could see from anywhere her establishment is full of old Nostalgia the atmosphere is great the pizza is even better so please if you want great pizza and great memories of old rock n roll go check her place out you will not regret it I’m sure of it..
… moreRandy Reagin
Loved the atmosphere of the place. We called in early because it’s always busy and we’re able to get our food when we wanted it. The pizza and salad were both delicious and the prices are especially reasonable. I’ve been in Jasper County for 35 years and have always considered this place to be a stable in Monticello.
… moreMonticello Talks
We have been in the area for over 20 years but never had eaten there until two weeks ago, and now again today. It was absolutely incredible!! We got the 16” Big Hammer Pizza and a small Super Salad both times.
We so wish we had started eating here years ago but unfortunately we didn’t but now it’s going to be a regular thing!
Thanks for having a fantastic restaurant!
… moreBre 1806
The food is great but the atmosphere is better! The owner, Tracey, seems to know just about everyone in town. She makes each customer feel like a friend, even if it’s their first time. If you’re within 50 miles, worth the drive. But call your order in early!!!
… moreBill Yox
Love this place. I always call in my order as “Bill from down the road” but I think yall recognize our voices. That hometown touch is also evident in the food. Always good, and each one is in contention to be your new favorite choice there. Tiny little place with a big atmosphere, that makes customers smile to each other.
… moreSamantha Schiripo
Absolutely the BEST pizza I have ever had in my entire life! I’m from up north and have a military family so I’ve traveled around the US and have been exposed to a lot of different types of food/pizza. I was honestly surprised how amazing the food was. The subs are awesome as well and aways friendly customer service.
… moreJudy Huddleston
This pizza is the best I’ve ever had. If your ever in the area you need to try it. But call 2hrs ahead or you will have to wait. The Buffalo chicken is so good. Just the right amount of sauce.
… moreLisa Anne
BEST pizza ever! I am not really a “pizza” person, but when I’m near Monticello (normally visiting friends) I ALWAYS vote for and/or pick McMichaels!
The toppings are fantastic, and they use the exact proportion of cheese to the other toppings. I also love that it’s thin crust.
Sorry, no pictures, I was too busy devouring the slices. Lol
… moreEric Prichard
Super great pizza, but plan ahead the orders back up quick!
… moreKaykay Carrara
The pizza is pretty decent. I love getting their salad, especially with the awesome pickles they use. I do wish I could get delivery more often, but with a small restaurant, I know that is hard to do, especially in Monticello.
… more