Josh C
Excellent service, delicious drinks, excellent drafts selection, friendly service, burgers delicious! I think I’m Irish after being here I felt like family! Caleb is the best Bartender! He over serves! Olivia is my favorite Server! They are so nice! Come, spend your money, tip well and enjoy!
… moreKelsey Dowell
Stopped by for a pre flight and a snack after a weekend of boarding. What a great place to hang out. Lots of tv’s with various sports. Drinks were excellent and the corn beef egg rolls were super scrumptious. I used the different sauce instead of the 10,000 island one and it was perfect.
I definitely recommend!!
… moreChris Miller
I’mnOut of town and i’ve been here a couple times and Olivia is an excellent waitress. The only thing is they a little bit controlling over the TV, and for some reason , had the same game on 3 different tvs, one in particular, the whole room could see and would not change one of them while we were watching football.
Otherwise the service has always been exceptional.
… moreMaine Girl
Food and atmosphere were great! Plenty of tvs if you enjoy sports. The service wasn’t the best. It was a weekend and she was younger. Probably 1st job and not excited to be there, but she tried. Wasn’t horrible, but definitely could have been better. Would definitely recommend stopping in. Try the maple chicken burger, it was delicious.
… moreGreg Wilson
Exactly what you’d expect. Order something that you would expect this place to sell a lot of because it’s probably good…burgers, fried fish, etc. Vast beer menu and hard liquor as well. My usual meeting spot for me and my buddy.
… moreAldin Puzic
I had to put up a review and let people know….this is by far the best location of all the 3 McGillicuddy’s. Service was very attentive and quick. We got our food fairly quickly. I had the Reuben O’Flaherty. It was a fairly good Reuben, the bread was good and the corned beef was very tender and flavored well, I’ve had better but definitely not bad! My Marg was good as well, very strong. Every booth has its own TV. Would come again!
… moreDave DeLaRosa
I came into McGillicuddy’s simply trying to enjoy a meal, get some work done, and have a couple of drinks. Nothing excessive, nothing irresponsible. In the middle of my visit, Emma, the bartender, (who was not rude in the entire exchange) cut me off, claiming I had reached my “allotment” of drinks under “Vermont Law.” Oddly enough, I had more drinks there on a previous Sunday with zero issue. When I mentioned that, she casually said, “Yeah, the Sunday guy is loose and lets people like you slide.”
That comment alone was unprofessional, but the inconsistency was even worse. While I was cut off for allegedly reaching some undisclosed limit, a visibly intoxicated patron was yelling across the bar, flipping people off, and carrying on with his “allotment” yet Emma laughed with him and continued serving without hesitation. She even joked to him about over-pouring a previous customer earlier in the evening.
So it became very clear: this wasn’t about “allotments” or “Vermont Law.” It is about selective enforcement and an environment where the rules depend entirely on who you are and whether the bartender decides you “fit.”
The experience was hypocritical, uncomfortable, and completely inconsistent with responsible service. Quite certain Williston Police Department enforces this behavior as well. I will not be returning, and when I’m back in the area, I’ll be heading to Burlington instead. Stay far away from this “establishment” (and that is naming it LOOSE)
… moreMatthew Schinasi
This place sucked. Two people in my party got the maple chicken sandwich. One was dry and the other was over cooked. Another person ordered an apple walnut salad and the walnuts were stale. When she told the waitress, she said “Oh” but did nothing. Would have been great for her to say something like “Sorry, can I get you something else.” But that definitely didn’t happen. She really was not that helpful. I sure hope that we were just there on an off night but who knows.
… moreLuisa Hutt
My boyfriend and I went for dinner last night I got the mix match tocos and the chicken I do not think was cooked and I got food poisoning from it. I have been throwing up all night long and the chicken is pink (not cooked). Make sure to check your food!
… moreBernadette Pellegrino
Tried their chicken maple sandwich. Delicious and cooked to perfection. Coleslaw was very good and so was the fries. And they have a great Selection of beers. I highly recommend to check it out. And one more note no waiting to be seated.
… more