Social Profile: 
✔️Take out
… View more
Compact, locally owned bakery providing a variety of homemade pastries, desserts & custom treats.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 378 Market St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407
Phone: (201) 797-2470
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
McCrum’s Bakery | Elmwood Park NJ – Facebook
McCrum’s Bakery, Elmwood Park. 1957 likes · 1 talking about this · 121 were here. We specialize in fresh baked breakfast pastries, muffins, cookies, and…
McCrums Bakery (@mccrumsbakery_ep) – Instagram
Elmwood Park’s favorite bakery. Offering fresh baked Danish, Muffins, Pies & Pastries & specializing in custom cakes and cookies for every occasion.
McCrum’s Bakery, 378 Market St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, US
Breakfast pastries, muffins, cakes and cookies. We specialize in custom cakes and cookie cakes for all events. Located across from the Elmwood Park Diner. Come …
Reviews
Majlinda Bacaj
I can’t say enough great things about McCrum’s Bakery. Randy knocked it out of the park with the custom cake he made for my sister’s 30th birthday. From the flawless design (which matched my reference photo exactly) to the insanely delicious flavor—every detail was perfect. The cake was super moist, and the raspberry mousse filling was the perfect balance of sweet and light. (Note: edible image on cake has been drawn over to respect the privacy of the person in the photo.)
Out of all the bakeries I contacted, McCrum’s had the most fair pricing by far. On top of that, Randy was incredibly kind and helpful throughout the entire process. This was actually my second cake from McCrum’s—he also made my wedding cake back in 2020, which was a huge hit—and five years later, the quality and care are still unmatched. His cakes are worth every penny.
I’ll absolutely be coming back for all future dessert needs and recommending McCrum’s to everyone I know!
… moreOut of all the bakeries I contacted, McCrum’s had the most fair pricing by far. On top of that, Randy was incredibly kind and helpful throughout the entire process. This was actually my second cake from McCrum’s—he also made my wedding cake back in 2020, which was a huge hit—and five years later, the quality and care are still unmatched. His cakes are worth every penny.
I’ll absolutely be coming back for all future dessert needs and recommending McCrum’s to everyone I know!
Michelle S.
I just want say how thankful I am for Randy and the cakes/treats he has done for my family. Randy is simply the best in what he does. He literally makes my vision come to life on the custom cakes he has made for me. Not only do they have amazing cakes but their pastries are also fresh and tasty. Try the pies too! Everyone you come encounter with at this place are super friendly and professional. I highly recommend them!
… moreViolette Cruz
Can’t say enough how much I loved my custom order cake. Not only did it look amazing and exactly how I wanted it to look, but it tasted amazing ! I knew I didn’t want an ordinary vanilla or chocolate cake and instead went for a walnut w/orange mouse and everyone loved it. Really a great cake and ill definitely order again for my twins christening soon.
… moreashley marino
We ordered our daughter’s birthday cake here last week and it came out amazing! Exactly how we wanted and tasted absolutely delicious we could not have been happier they were extremely busy when we went in to order and still took the time to take our custom order when other places told us they could not do what we were asking and the price was better than what I have paid at the supermarket! we will definitely be back for all our special occasions thank you so much McCrum’s bakery!
… moreNicole Berlin
McCrum’s Bakery is my go-to bakery. We moved almost an hour away, but still ordered my daughter’s birthday cake from McCrum’s. It was beautiful and delicious. The girls at the party were so excited to see the pink strawberry cake when they got a slice. Thank you for making the day special!
… moreCindy Haner
Attended a birthday party. Was told this baker made the cakes. Fresh and delicious. Highly recommend.
… moreSvjetlana Ivanko
We ordered cake, cake pops and cupcakes for our daughter baby shower. Everything looked so beautiful and elegant. But tasted even better! Cake was star of the party. Fresh, light, tasty. Thank you so much
… morePeter Parker
For my aunt/mother figures 60th birthday Randy pulled through last minute with this flawless cannoli cake along with 60 cannolis for take home! Family and friends were blown away and every thanksgiving I pick up a blueberry crumb pie and it’s always the first to get gobbled up! The 1hr trip is always worth it especially the employees are cheerful! 10 out of 10 in my eyes!!
… moreKajal Pillai
The best decision ever i took was this one for my son’s 1st birthday. I wanted to celebrate his birthday with and under the sea theme and i was struggling to find a bakery who can give me exactly wat i wanted. I asked so many bakeries but everyone gave their suggestions and to compromise with the cake with buttercream instead of fondant design. But i was not ready to compromise on it and thats when i found randy, he is an amazing guy and a very understanding and active listener too just like how every customer wishes for. HE MADE THIS CAKE POSSIBLE. Im so happy that i chose this bakery and its completely worth it. The cake tastes soooo good and all my guests were awestruck by seeing the cake and by tasting it. Thanks to randy.
… moreKristin
Recently had a cake made for my sister’s baby shower. Came out beautiful. Freshly made that morning. Moist and delicious. Was able to get a diff flavor for each tier. Very reasonably priced!
… more