Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mayfield Grill (@MayfieldGrillMayfieldNY) – Facebook
. 94% recommend (231 Reviews) ; . $$ ; . Open now ; . 8 School Street, Mayfield, NY, United States, 12117 …
Mayfield Grill (@mayfield_grill) – Instagram
Instagram. Log in · Open app · mayfield_grill’s profile picture. mayfield_grill. 924 followers · 1.5K+ posts. Photo by Mayfield Grill on March 19, 2026.
Mayfield Grill, 8 School St, Mayfield, NY 12117, US – MapQuest
Get more information for Mayfield Grill in Mayfield, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Stephani Yarber
We ordered takeout so I can’t speak to anything beyond that but overall the experience was good! Reasonable prices, everyone was friendly, both when ordering and picking up, and everything was ready on time! When picking up there was plenty of parking in the large lot by their building.
We ordered a meat lovers pizza, wings, and boneless wings! The pizza was just okay, my husband ate some of it but as excited as I was for it I just couldn’t get into it- I think it was just a bit overcooked and maybe some of the ingredients just weren’t for me. I’d be curious to try some of their other pizzas in the future for sure! It wasn’t bad, it just wasn’t especially good. I was surprised by the side sauce that came with our wings, usually you see blue cheese or ranch but this was sort of a whipped sour cream mixture, which again wasn’t necessarily bad it just wasn’t for me personally. Those things aside, I’d love to wrap up with the fact that their wings are the best wings, THE BEST WINGS, I have ever had- and we’re from Buffalo! They were literally perfect. The right amount of crispy, right amount of juicy, right amount of sauce… I am still drooling over those wings and can’t wait to go back for more.
We’ll be back again for sure and I look forward to trying out some different options! Every dish won’t be for every person no matter where you go but Mayfield Grill is absolutely worth a visit!
… moreWe ordered a meat lovers pizza, wings, and boneless wings! The pizza was just okay, my husband ate some of it but as excited as I was for it I just couldn’t get into it- I think it was just a bit overcooked and maybe some of the ingredients just weren’t for me. I’d be curious to try some of their other pizzas in the future for sure! It wasn’t bad, it just wasn’t especially good. I was surprised by the side sauce that came with our wings, usually you see blue cheese or ranch but this was sort of a whipped sour cream mixture, which again wasn’t necessarily bad it just wasn’t for me personally. Those things aside, I’d love to wrap up with the fact that their wings are the best wings, THE BEST WINGS, I have ever had- and we’re from Buffalo! They were literally perfect. The right amount of crispy, right amount of juicy, right amount of sauce… I am still drooling over those wings and can’t wait to go back for more.
We’ll be back again for sure and I look forward to trying out some different options! Every dish won’t be for every person no matter where you go but Mayfield Grill is absolutely worth a visit!
Matthew Cerasia
Had a great lunch at the Mayfield Grill with my wife today. The French onion was soup was delicious. My wife had a amaretto sour to start off with, which I stole a few sips from her because it was really good. The Bacon Blue Burger was probably the best in the area. I really love a good crumble blue cheese, especially on a burger. Can’t wait to go back and have it again.
… moreReview Squad 11
Outstanding! Visited on our vacation.
Kind staff, great prices, amazing food! Tops anything you’ll find in northville, hope, or wells too!
… moreKind staff, great prices, amazing food! Tops anything you’ll find in northville, hope, or wells too!
shantel waldvogel
My fiancé and I ordered a small pizza and it tasted horrendous! The crust was this abstract odd looking super thick glob
Of dough
and tasted Completely undercooked!. We also ordered two dozen BBQ wings and instead of ranch we were given SOUR CREAM! I would not recommend this place to anyone. This was our first time eating here and were expecting our experience to be totally different.
… moreOf dough
and tasted Completely undercooked!. We also ordered two dozen BBQ wings and instead of ranch we were given SOUR CREAM! I would not recommend this place to anyone. This was our first time eating here and were expecting our experience to be totally different.
Dayton King
We stopped in to grab some wings recently and were not disappointed ! Heather and team are doing a great job here!
We highly recommend the Mayfield Grill !!
… moreWe highly recommend the Mayfield Grill !!
Adam G.
Awesome customer service and delicious food! The establishment has a very homey feel to it and good seating. I look forward to heading back here.
… moreMisty Garafalo
Stopped in on our way home from the GSL, food is tasty, staff is pleasant and friendly. Quaint pub like atmosphere.
… moreDave Kreczko
Stopped in after some sales calls and had a great lunch! Loved the dipping sauce for my onion rings. Cobb Salad was excellent. Will definitely be back the next time I’m in the area!
… morekoi louis
i came to mayfield grill on because i was in town for a church event. i don’t live here so i have never tried before. the food was AMAZING and the lady who served my friend and i was absolutely wonderful and so nice. i had the grilled chicken and my friend had a burger, both were wonderful. i will definitely be recommending this to friends/people in the area and i will be personally returning.
… moreJennifer Hunter
Several of us got burgers, which were cooked perfectly. Can’t go wrong with the straight fries, curly fries, chips, or potato salad. Only about 5 tables and a bar, but the food was good, prices were fair, and the atmosphere was comfortable.
… more