Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5645 Mayberry Square E, Sylvania, OH 43560
Phone: (419) 517-5580
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mayberry Ice Cream: Home – original
Mayberry Ice Cream is owned and operated by the Scott Family of Sylvania, Ohio! … © 2020 by Mayberry Ice Cream LLC. Proudly created with Wix.com. bottom …
Mayberry Ice Cream | Sylvania OH – Facebook
Mayberry Ice Cream ; Details · 5645 Mayberry Sq. East, Sylvania, OH, United States, 43560 ; Links. . mayberryicecreamsylvania.com ; Contact info. . (419) 517-5580.
Mayberry Ice Cream – SYLVANIA, OH 43560 (Menu & Order Online)
Online ordering menu for Mayberry Ice Cream.
Reviews
Felipe Zafani
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A Local Gem in a Charming Town!
Mayberry Ice Cream in Sylvania, Ohio is everything you hope for in a small-town ice cream shop — warm, welcoming, and absolutely delicious. From the moment you walk up to the quaint little building with its retro charm and inviting atmosphere, you feel like you’ve stepped back into simpler, sweeter times.
The ice cream itself is phenomenal — creamy, rich, and clearly made with quality ingredients. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors like vanilla bean and chocolate fudge or prefer to branch out into seasonal favorites and unique blends, there’s truly something for everyone here. The portions are generous, the prices are fair, and the staff is always cheerful and patient — especially when kids (or adults!) are having a hard time picking just one flavor.
One of the highlights of visiting Mayberry is the setting. Located in the heart of Sylvania, a beautiful and family-friendly suburb just outside of Toledo, the neighborhood adds so much to the experience. The tree-lined streets, well-kept homes, and nearby parks create a picturesque backdrop that makes enjoying your cone or sundae outside feel like a scene from a movie.
After grabbing your treat, take a stroll through downtown Sylvania. The area is full of charm — local shops, cozy cafés, and flower-filled planters line the sidewalks. It’s a community that feels close-knit and proud, and Mayberry fits right in as a beloved gathering spot for families, teens, and anyone looking to slow down and enjoy life for a few minutes.
All in all, Mayberry Ice Cream is a must-visit whether you’re a Sylvania local or just passing through. It’s the kind of place that turns a simple stop for ice cream into a cherished memory.
… moreMayberry Ice Cream in Sylvania, Ohio is everything you hope for in a small-town ice cream shop — warm, welcoming, and absolutely delicious. From the moment you walk up to the quaint little building with its retro charm and inviting atmosphere, you feel like you’ve stepped back into simpler, sweeter times.
The ice cream itself is phenomenal — creamy, rich, and clearly made with quality ingredients. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors like vanilla bean and chocolate fudge or prefer to branch out into seasonal favorites and unique blends, there’s truly something for everyone here. The portions are generous, the prices are fair, and the staff is always cheerful and patient — especially when kids (or adults!) are having a hard time picking just one flavor.
One of the highlights of visiting Mayberry is the setting. Located in the heart of Sylvania, a beautiful and family-friendly suburb just outside of Toledo, the neighborhood adds so much to the experience. The tree-lined streets, well-kept homes, and nearby parks create a picturesque backdrop that makes enjoying your cone or sundae outside feel like a scene from a movie.
After grabbing your treat, take a stroll through downtown Sylvania. The area is full of charm — local shops, cozy cafés, and flower-filled planters line the sidewalks. It’s a community that feels close-knit and proud, and Mayberry fits right in as a beloved gathering spot for families, teens, and anyone looking to slow down and enjoy life for a few minutes.
All in all, Mayberry Ice Cream is a must-visit whether you’re a Sylvania local or just passing through. It’s the kind of place that turns a simple stop for ice cream into a cherished memory.
Alyssa Jennings
Ice cream was good for sure. Service is what I did not like. My young daughter was up at the counter picking out her cone and got laughs from two of 3 girls on staff. Whether or not they were laughing at my child or an inside joke it seems like laughing was more important than customer service? I would not go again.
… moreMatthew Harpst
Had a birthday party and booked Mayberry to provide ice cream service. The ice cream was the best. The two servers/employees were very pleasant with all the children.
… moreAndy VanValkenburg
Fantastic little shop in a great area. Giant selection of ice cream flavors and non ice cream offerings. Clean inside and nice setting outside. Good value and friendly servers!
… moreDavid Cohen
Had the best root beer float here while waiting for my dog to get groomed. Super chill spot with great service — definitely coming back. Highly recommend if you’re in the area!
… moreMary Anne Nanney
We had a half sheet ice cream cake made for my grandson’s 3rd birthday! It was amazing! The details and extras were over the top and it tasted delicious!! Thank you Mayberry Ice Cream!
… moreBrittany
I rode my bike here to get ice cream and had a lovely time. The young ladies that served us were nice and the ice cream was yummy.
They have tables outside the ice cream place to sit and a lobby with plenty of seats, too.
… moreThey have tables outside the ice cream place to sit and a lobby with plenty of seats, too.
Kristen Dennis
Ordered the blast or whatever is called. We ordered the Andy’s mint one. It was all vanilla soft serve ice cream in a cup with about maybe two Andy’s mints sprinkled on top. She compared it to the McFlurry. Actually the McFlurry is 100% better with tons of candy mixed in with the ice cream. Never again!!
… moreLuke Hill
The ice cream is always a delightful treat, the service is to good be true. Maberry ice cream is a 10/10 to me I highly recommend
… moreYour Mom
Ordered 4 blasts or whatever the cream with blended candy is called. We might have gotten one peanut butter cup in each one. It was 95% vanilla ice cream. This place is average ice cream, with sub par toppings, at outrageous prices. Never again.
… more