American bar & grill with a relaxed vibe pitches nightly drink specials & carousel-horse decor.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 501 E Main St, Islip, NY 11751
Phone: (631) 210-0011
Website: https://www.bayberryislip.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Maxwell’s in Islip closes for renovations, and the Lessings have big …
… New York City and Florida. The rest of the Lessing clan were just a few blocks away. “There was at least 40 of us nearby,” he said. So where …
‘Needed To Give It A Change’: How Restaurant Is Love Letter To Islip
ISLIP, NY — When Lessings Hospitality group closed the doors of Maxwell’s restaurant in August 2022, they already knew their next big move.
Maxwell’s – CLOSED, 501 Main St, Islip, NY 11751, US – MapQuest
Maxwell’s … Maxwell’s is a great casual dining spot located in the heart of Islip offering the best of everything: an innovative menu, family-friendly …
Reviews
Barsnobs
The old Maxwell’s is now Bayberry. The food was very good. We had Beet Salad with Blackened Chicken. It was good, not amazing. Very fresh though. The French Onion Soup was very good. The bread was crispy in the soup. The pasta was amazing. Lemon spaghetti with Artichokes and Arugula and garlic. You can order half or full sizes, which is very cool. We like to split meals so this came in handy. For drinks we had Polemo, The Bayberry, Mezcal Marg, and Lavender drink that was normally zero proof but they added Gin. Overall, very good. It’s worth checking them out. Tell ’em Barsnobs sent ya!
… moreMeryl Schultz
It was great. Just thought the server looked a little annoyed. We also accidentally walked through a private party trying to exit and got an attitude. Other than that the food and atmosphere were great!
… moreJonathan Kowalik
What a great place. Bar is amazing, huge, well staffed. A great place for happy hour or dinner. Family friendly, kitchen is slamming with an ever changing menu. Out door lounge looks fun. High score on Ms. PacMan was 10370. There are no arcade games here at all, FYI. Potato chapstick.
… moreLove Life and food
The food was good but the drink that I order did not taste like blueberry vodka and cranberry juice.
… moreJackson McNally
The service was fantastic, food flavorful, the atmosphere was welcoming and comfortable.Thank you to Rob, our waiter, Alex our bar back and to Laura the General Manager! The food was great; the ambiance was amazing & the service was extremity professional and friendly. Thank you Bayberry for providing an exceptional experience. We will be sure to come back.This is an easy 5 star review. I was extremely satisfied and would highly recommend !Thank you !
… moreJohn Schaefer
Great all around experience. Ordered the first tacos which were light, crispy, and had a very tasty sauce. Friend ordered the quesadilla which was cooked perfectly and dressed up great. Bartenders were super friendly and knowledgeable about local beers on tap. Ashley in particular was a great help! Definitely will be coming back.
… moreBernadette Ohare
We had our granddaughters Communion party on Saturday and had a wonderful experience. The food was excellent. The staff were terrific especially Michelle and her co-worker, who were always available to help with our requests. The bartender was great. The outside area was a plus for the children and parents to enjoy. What a wonderful day and we hope nothing changes so we can do our next event here at Maxwell’s again!
… moreJanet Worsley
Unfortunately we were surprisingly disappointed today. We were a party of 8 adults and 2 children. We were one of the first tables seated and they were no where near crowed, maybe 2 – 3 others tables while we were there. It took approximately 1 1/2 hours to get our orders and that was after asking twice. The eggs were served cold and/ or floating in water. When I spoke to the gentleman I assume was the manager and told him how displeased and unpleasantly surprised we were he offered dessert (do you know anyone who eats dessert after breakfast?!) He also offered a round of drinks, but since we had almost 2 each waiting for our food we were not interested. He really showed no remorse and actually said “will that do it”, NO. IT DIDNT. I’ve eaten there in the past and it was good. This was a very disappointing experience. The waitresses were good, unfortunately they had no control over the situation. You wouldn’t expect this especially when the menus we were given literally consisted of 5 choices! Poor planning, poor management.
… moreDew Maur
it was nice, the menu seemed a little limited. 2 people had salads, one with shrimp one with chicken, both very good. I had the roast beef dip sandwich and another had the hamburger. they were also good. Not a great place, not a bad place – just a good place, not sure I’ll go back again.
… moreJim “JC” Carleton
Went in recently with a party of 6. Great bar food and small plates. Very reasonable price. Cozy atmosphere. Tried their wings for the first time and wow! I’m definitely coming back just for them!
… more