A modern American restaurant, with full bar and wine list, featuring a rotating, seasonal menu of eclectic food, featuring locally sourced ingredients and global flavors, along with an inventive cocktail program and curated wine list focusing on both classic and iconoclastic winemakers from every corner of the winemaking world
Address and Contact Information
Address: 12 Coles St, Jersey City, NJ 07302
Phone: (201) 331-0160
Website: https://maxwell-alley.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Related Web Results
Maxwell Alley: Home
MAXWELL ALLEY 〰️ Restaurant & Wine Bar (@maxwell_alley_jc)
Maxwell Alley: A New Farm-to-Table Restaurant in Jersey City
Reviews
Definitely one of the best places we’ve been to in a while! Well done Mark and Kati!
The wine selection is expansive, the owner is also of coolvines which makes this place extra special because of the knowledge & personal touch they bring to your dinner. Reservations are getting harder to grab peak hours, so i recommend going for brunch or early week night. The best evening I’ve had in a VERY long time.
The cocktail and wine program is among the best in the area – thoughtfully curated, well-executed, and backed by a knowledgeable team that clearly knows their stuff.
We loved the salads and pastas, each full of flavor and finesse, and the dessert was a perfect finish. A welcome new go-to for dinner, drinks, or just a great vibe.
5 stars though – incredible potential and a few kinks they’re working through (we went week 2 of service)
Service was very calm and friendly. Cocktail list was nice — we enjoyed our drinks (pretty and thoughtful). Fairly contemporary offerings and around the $18-20 range.
Food menu was small. Not sure if they plan to up it when they get more of a handle on things. They should. Not that it needs to be large but I felt it the apps and small bites lacked any substance. $8 sourdough with butter isn’t a a great offering (1 of 3 choices up top for small bites.
Menu was printed on a plain piece of paper. Odd. Those small negatives aside, we really enjoyed our entrees and dessert. We tried a variety and everything was well executed.
Most importantly, patio is lovely and interior feels nice and they were fantastically patient with our baby stroller (lots of families out on date nights). Give them an A+ for making us feel welcomed.
We started with some cocktails. The Maxwell Alley Martini is fresh, fun, and delicious! However, as avid wine lovers, the wine list is what we were most interested in. (This is not your Aunt Linda’s wine list — Sorry, Aunt Linda.) Featuring rare bottles that are thoughtfully curated, we were so happy with each bottle we selected. (A 2021 Brendan Stater-West Saumur Blanc ‘Les Chapaudaises’ and a 2022 Chantereves Hautes Cotes de Beaune ‘Paris L’Hopital.’)
All of the food we ordered was so delicious, too. (The menu focuses on seasonal produce, house-made pastas, and thoughtfully sourced protein.) I have to specifically highlight the guanciale pasta as it is one of the best pastas I’ve ever eaten (and I studied in Rome for a semester).
We are so happy to have this new restaurant in Jersey City and can’t wait to go back again (and again, and again).
I would recommend the beef tartar and duck breast. Beef tartar is pretty fresh and the sauce goes well with the beef. The duck breast is not super soft but in combination with other ingredients are well balanced, both textures and flavors. The mackerel crudo is interesting with strawberries but not that impressive. The ink squid one has good texture but a bit too salty for my taste. The dessert…was way to sour. My mouth is still watering while I’m typing this review thinking how sour it was.
Service:
It’s still a new and busy restaurant. The food came out relatively fast. For people who don’t drink alcohol, the restaurant can make mocktails that are not on the drink menu. The waiter was nice and handling a lot of tables.
Space:
We sat in the indoor dining room. The distance between tables is pretty tight and close to others. It’s a bit loud but you can still hear each other without yelling. The lighting is great, not too bright and not too dark. When we walked out, the indoor patio looked even nicer and quieter.
Overall, I’ll come back when my mood strikes.
They had really fun drinks like a corn cocktail! We had crudo for appetizer then shared the Squid ink pasta and duck breast which were so yummy. The duck especially was such a good portion for the price we thought.
We also had their seasonal desserts which were blueberry compote ice cream and a corn ice cream, both super flavorful and unique
The seating inside felt a bit tight but we were there pretty early so no one sat right next to us during our meal. The bar filled up just as we were finishing up our meal but it was pretty open before 630ish. They also had outdoor seating which could be a great option in a nice day