Hours
| Monday | 3–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 3–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
| Thursday | 3–8 PM |
| Friday | 2–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1003 N Main St, Goshen, IN 46528
Phone: (574) 537-9800
Website: http://massimos-pizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
MASSIMO’S PIZZERIA -OFFICIAL WEB SITE- GOSHEN
family pizzeria offering high quality gourmet pizza , sandwiches , salads , bread sticks , chicken wings , pasta , spagetti , calzones and chicago style …
MASSIMO’S PIZZERIA ORDER ONLINE – GOSHEN – OFFICIAL SITE
Order online! It is fast and stress free! Carry out or delivery! We arrange delivery to goshen zip codes 46526 and 46528 if outside this range please call …
Massimo’s Pizzeria – Experience Authentic Pizza Perfection in Goshen
Discover Massimo’s Pizzeria in Goshen, IN, known for their generous portions, top-notch ingredients, and friendly staff. Indulge in their signature Bomb …
Reviews
Jeff Bigler
The pizza has been going downhill for quite some time. For probably the last year it it had been on average about every other pizza was a good one. The last three in a row were horrible! After eating this pizza for the last 15 years or so since we moved back to Goshen we will never order pizza from them again! I threw three quarters of a 20-inch Pizza in the trash it was so gross!
I don’t see where I can respond to the owner’s response anywhere else so I’ll just edit my review here. I’m glad you’ve cleaned house and got rid of some bad employees but that doesn’t change the fact that my pizza tasted absolutely horrible and our experience over the last year has been every other pizza was a good one and then something would be wrong with one. I didn’t take any photos because photos wouldn’t show that it tasted bad. I wish I would have because one side of the pizza the toppings were about 4 in from the edge of the crust which normally I would have also called and complained about because that’s happened before, but it tasted so bad I didn’t want it replaced. You asked why I didn’t call the store, because you wouldn’t have given me my money back you would have replaced it with another pizza with the same ingredients that didn’t taste good! As far as being unhappy Everywhere I Go, we frequent every restaurant in Goshen all the time and you don’t see bad reviews about all of them. You see unhappy reviews because I only take my time to review a place when I have bad food or bad service so the owner can see it and hopefully use that information to correct the problem. Usually because I normally like the place and I want them to know about the problem so they can fix it and I can keep enjoying the place. I have liked Massimo’s pizza for the last 15 years or so ever since you bought out Bruno’s and changed names. I’ve sent hundreds of people your direction and told them it was the best pizza in town. But after so many bad ones you have to give a review in my book. Throwing $34 in the trash leaves an even worse taste in your mouth than the bad pizza!
… moreI don’t see where I can respond to the owner’s response anywhere else so I’ll just edit my review here. I’m glad you’ve cleaned house and got rid of some bad employees but that doesn’t change the fact that my pizza tasted absolutely horrible and our experience over the last year has been every other pizza was a good one and then something would be wrong with one. I didn’t take any photos because photos wouldn’t show that it tasted bad. I wish I would have because one side of the pizza the toppings were about 4 in from the edge of the crust which normally I would have also called and complained about because that’s happened before, but it tasted so bad I didn’t want it replaced. You asked why I didn’t call the store, because you wouldn’t have given me my money back you would have replaced it with another pizza with the same ingredients that didn’t taste good! As far as being unhappy Everywhere I Go, we frequent every restaurant in Goshen all the time and you don’t see bad reviews about all of them. You see unhappy reviews because I only take my time to review a place when I have bad food or bad service so the owner can see it and hopefully use that information to correct the problem. Usually because I normally like the place and I want them to know about the problem so they can fix it and I can keep enjoying the place. I have liked Massimo’s pizza for the last 15 years or so ever since you bought out Bruno’s and changed names. I’ve sent hundreds of people your direction and told them it was the best pizza in town. But after so many bad ones you have to give a review in my book. Throwing $34 in the trash leaves an even worse taste in your mouth than the bad pizza!
Jen Mark
If you want the better of the Massismo’s pizza, go to Gerace’s at Waterford Mills. The manager at this place has no business managing anywhere. If you have any complaints about the pizza or your service, she attacks you and tries to make you sound like you’re the crazy one. We stopped going to both of the pizza places because the pizza had just gotten so bad, was run by children and the manager did not care one bit. They got rid of her as manager at Gerace’s and now their pizza is back to being the best we’ve had. Massimo’s owner should be ashamed to have someone running their restaurant like this. It’s clear that many other people feel the same way
… moreEvan Bennet (AnAmericanComposer)
I’ve been eating here since 2019. This used to be my guilty pleasure pizza, prices were a bit high but the pie was fantastic and filling. I ordered a pizza tonight and I’m not a fan at all of the recipe changes.
The sauce is really sweet and acidic, and almost reminds me of the sauce for the Lunchables pizzas I ate as a kid. Very little cheese, and the crust was incredibly thick and doughy. It’s really disappointing to write this because I used to think this was the best pizza in town. Not sure anymore.
… moreThe sauce is really sweet and acidic, and almost reminds me of the sauce for the Lunchables pizzas I ate as a kid. Very little cheese, and the crust was incredibly thick and doughy. It’s really disappointing to write this because I used to think this was the best pizza in town. Not sure anymore.
Leon Hluchota
Massimo’s has always been excellent pizza, until last night. Very generous toppings, but they were all on top of the cheese and there was a lot less of their delicious sauce. Recent reviews aren’t good, so what happened?
… moreSteve Squires
They changed their ingredients and the pizza was gross. We ate one piece and threw it in the trash. The pizza looked good but the flavor was not good at all. The pizza here, about 6 months ago, was good but not anymore. Many other reviews agree that it’s a waste of $25
… moreJohn Purdy
Tonight’s experience at Massimos was exceptional. The best I’ve ever had. Ordered the Deluxe 16”, well done. Toppings were generous, pizza was cooked perfectly, and right on time. I’ve gotta say my recent orders here are getting better and better. Congrats to the team tonight 7-21-24. You all hit it out of the park.
… moreDebi Datema
We have tried the pizza 3 times in the past couple years and have found the taste to be declining from what they used to be. It is no longer worth the price. It doesn’t taste fresh and a sweeter sauce.
… moreSpend’n & Eat’n Living Da Life
I really am glad this pizza parlor is right in the neighborhood. Unfortunately…
They started out with free delivery and they were very generous with the toppings. The prices were lower as well. Then they decided to charge for delivery $3.50 and they updated their prices on each size of pizza by $2.00. I will say I wasn’t happy about that.
I can say that the staff is very very nice. Other than that, the pizza arrives hot, you can take a slice right out the box and not have to put it in the microwave to heat it up. The quality is present, the pizza is gooey and cheesy and it does taste good like an Italian pizza should. Far as pricing, you get what you pay for! They do offer a rewards card they punch after 10 orders you get a free 2 topping 16” free!
… moreThey started out with free delivery and they were very generous with the toppings. The prices were lower as well. Then they decided to charge for delivery $3.50 and they updated their prices on each size of pizza by $2.00. I will say I wasn’t happy about that.
I can say that the staff is very very nice. Other than that, the pizza arrives hot, you can take a slice right out the box and not have to put it in the microwave to heat it up. The quality is present, the pizza is gooey and cheesy and it does taste good like an Italian pizza should. Far as pricing, you get what you pay for! They do offer a rewards card they punch after 10 orders you get a free 2 topping 16” free!
Janiece de Jonge
The pizza was amazing. The sauce and toppings were edge to edge. Yes, it was a little pricey, but this out of towner is not going to complain. Plus the app is worth the download and is easy to use. Thanks, Massimos!!
… moreLeo Lopez
First time getting carry out here. Ordered the 12″ Bomb and it didn’t disappoint!! Will definitely be back!!! Loved the meatballs in this one! Just under $20.
… more