Address and Contact Information
Address: 145 2nd St NW, New Philadelphia, OH 44663
Phone: (330) 343-1188
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Mary Zifer Pizza New Philadelphia – Facebook
Mary Zifer Pizza New Philadelphia. 177 likes · 15 talking about this. Restaurant.
Mary Zifer Pizza – New Philadelphia Guide
Thanks to our wonderful, loyal customers, Mary Zifer’s pizza has been serving the area since 1953! 145 2nd Street Northwest, New Philadelphia, Ohio, 44663, …
Mary Zifer’s Pizza in New Philly – Cozy Local Spot for Delicious Italian
Discover the warm, welcoming vibe of Mary Zifer’s Pizza, where hearty Italian flavors meet hometown charm in New Philadelphia.
Reviews
DEAN ESMAY
Cash-only local family restaurant run by locals, boosting our economy and also providing a unique pizza you cannot get anywhere else in the USA or world. 🙂 Plus their pizza subs are particularly good. No pretention, just order your food and go–and it’s fresh and delicious!
… morelisa kelly
Have always loved this place. But this time was terrible.. The salad was not cut up at all 4 pepperoni and the tiniest bit of cheese. Not even a full cup of salad dressing. Speggetti had no flavor very bland.. Pizza was not how I remember, one piece had one pepperoni on it. Definitely very disappointing..
… moreN.
Best pizza anywhere! I live in New York now and whenever I cone for a visit I have to stock up on unassembled pizzas to take home. Service is always excellent, staff is always polite. Highly recommended!
… moreMissy Philpot
I live in Cincinnati now, and have for 25 years. I was very pleasantly surprised to find the sauce tasted exactly the same as it did when I was growing up! The staff were also very pleasant! The food was STILL amazing
… moreJeremy Bower
This is still one of my favorite pizza places to frequent even after not living in New Philadelphia for almost 20 years.
Cash or check only. Every pizza establishment I’ve been to with those options have been top tier good and Mary Zifer’s is in the the top tier of that top tier. I miss it already!
… moreCash or check only. Every pizza establishment I’ve been to with those options have been top tier good and Mary Zifer’s is in the the top tier of that top tier. I miss it already!
M E
The inside is literally pickup and go so atmosphere is low for that. But absolutely best pizza around! Only the NP Mary Zifers NOT DOVER!!! I wish they would make the large bigger though it is like a medium at the other places in comparison.
… moreFrancesca DePrator
Food was quick, delicious, and unique. The sauce is flavorful with a delightfully crunchy thick crust, the ingredients seemed fresh, and the cheddar cheese really did make it. I’m so glad we didn’t ask if they had mozzarella. Staff was nice, service was quick, and this is clearly a popular place, because they had a steady stream of customers while we waited for our pizza, and it wasn’t too long before closing.
… moreKatie B
Crunchy crust is really good. They use Colby cheese but have mozzarella if you want that instead. And they only take cash or check. Yummy pizza! I included a picture of their menu which is current as of 2/24/2023.
… moreJanet Pavick
Girls working were rude. We didn’t realize they are cash only. Had to go to an atm and come back for our food. The pizza was so loaded with sauce the crust was soggy. Not at all like I remember.
… moreCindy Septer
Anytime we’re in the area to visit family, we have to grab a take and bake pizza to have for supper when we’re back in the Columbus area!
… more