Bakeshop with a warm vibe serving old-fashioned cakes & pastries, plus gelato & an espresso bar.
BA
• Everything here is so good—you really can’t go wrong with any of their pastries or cake slices!
• We tried the carrot cake, very berry Napoleon, and apple crumble pie. All were rich, creamy, and absolutely delicious with excellent flavors.
• Despite the busy evening, we were able to order and receive our items quickly.
• Staff were kind and accommodating.
• Cozy, clean interiors. Will definitely be back to try more desserts!
… moreChristopher Spitaleri
Came in for take out. Staff worms efficient. Greeted, asked if I was here for pickup of takeout. Directed to the line. Waiting and one of the many staff members assisted me with my order. I had the pleasure of having Selena assist me with my purchase of an Apple crumble pie. Selena was almost as sweet as the pie was! Thank you!! And don’t forget to tip these workers they work extremely hard in a fast paced setting to get everyone’s orders packed and served up! Thanks again.
… moreAndrew
I had such a wonderful experience at Martha’s Bakery! The waiter who helped me had the brightest smile and made me feel so welcome. She recommended the Oreo cheesecake, and it was absolutely delicious—rich, creamy, and one of the best I’ve ever had. She even checked in to make sure I was okay, which made the visit feel so warm and personal. The staff here are all so kind, and the overall atmosphere is just as sweet as their desserts. I’ll definitely be coming back!
… moreEsraa Fahmy
Number one choice in NYC if you want dessert everything I tried is so good. The best thing for me is very berry Napoleon it’s like Martha’s signature cake, but all other cakes / menu are so delicious too tables are a bit close from each other but still ok.
All the menu items are great, I went there many times also chocolate layer and the tart is amazing.
Service is so good and very fast, sometimes they are so busy specially in the weekends so there will be waiting but they’re fast
… moreMohammad Islam
THE BEST hot chocolate and Chocolate Mousse I’ve ever had in my life. Our Server, Yazmin was delightful and perfect addition to my trip to New York! Please give her a raise!
*see picture: we finished EVERYTHING!!*
… moreSarah
Martha’s, oh how I love you! My sister lives in Forrest hills so I’d go with her to come here many times growing up. I remember thinking they had the best strawberry shortcake ever back then. I went back for the first time in years today and was not disappointed. All of their cakes are delicious and I think it’s the perfect spot for a quick catch up with a friend.
… morephillip salli
Amazing bakery. Take your time when you order because the menu is long. I’ve been here a few times, and everything I’ve had was delicious. Coffee is also very good, and the service was great. Park a few blocks away and walk it off!
… moreLaura B.
I have tried Martha’s before thru other people who brought cakes from there (always delicious) but this time I got to check it out in person. Stopped there for dessert after lunch. Great service, well organized place….you can get food to go or see the hostess to be seated. The 4 people in our group each got a dessert and we all enjoyed them! I think the mini passion fruit mousse cake that I tried is one of the best things I’ve ever tasted…not overpoweringly sweet but sweet enough, a little tart, light and small enough….it was exceptional! Their berry napoleon was also delicious. So many things to try, can’t wait to return next time I am in the area! Very reasonable prices considering today’s economy!!
… moreJhoan Castillo
Love Martha’s!!.. I’ve been coming here for years. My top favorite is their strawberry cheesecake and during the fall/winter season their pumpkin pie and pumpkin cheesecake. I used to buy a whole cheesecake for myself during pandemic and eat it in 2 days by myself
… moreJason
Love to come here! I’ve been to other Martha’s bakeries in the city, this one is the closest to me. Always a great place to stop for dessert especially with good restaurants around the area. The cheesecake is always so decadent and delicious every time! It’s usually really busy so if you want a table to sit down, best to plan before hand. If you’re getting to go, the line might be long but it moves quickly so don’t be discouraged by that. Definitely must try their Oreo cheesecake as that’s my favorite but went with something different by getting the strawberry shortcake and the flan cheesecake and they did not disappoint!
… more