M Gdd
The pizza was FANTASTIC! I was in a pizza cinch at 9pm on a Saturday night. I ordered a large half cheese half pepperoni, peppers, onions. While I was picking it up at 9:15pm I ordered a cannoli and that was top notch as well. I ate that in my car on the way home. I recommend this place and I will definitely order again.
… moreDerrick Coon
Arguably the best pizza in Johnstown. Far better than Vince’s; but the big plexiglass with handing money with gloves was a bit strange when COVID isn’t a thing really anymore. The cash only sucks, but otherwise it’s a good spot for a pizza in town.
… moreDaniel Donnelly
Certainly unique decorations, what with antique cameras, old posters, ten coin-operated vending machines, retro arcade game. Prices fair and the end product is delicious (two Sicilians with extra cheese)! Automatic Tell Machine on-site (this pizzeria is cash only!), and several tables for dining in. Friendly cashiers.
… moreTania Avey Duffin
Cash only. No dine in. Pizza was great. Our teenagers thought it was the best pizza we had during our 2 week vacation through the Eastern USA (we had pizza 4 times.) Service was a little funny. Garlic knots were great. Place looked like a dive. Not busy at all for a Saturday evening. But again, the pizza was great.
… moreFloyd Eggleston
Awesome food every time! Pizza is delicious. I used to work here a long time ago & the food was great then & still is like I remember. The owners are kind & work really hard by themselves to make everything perfect. I have no complaints whatsoever and I’ve been ordering once a week the past few weeks now. Their prices are very reasonable & I’d recommend for anyone. Btw, you gotta try their house dressing, it’s creamy & perfect for dipping certain pizzas & sides.
… moreEric Guilder
Ordered wings and fries price of wings on business website was $12.99 a dozen when I arrived I was charged $15.99 a dozen. When I brought it to his attention, he brought it to his wife’s attention who claimed she changed it but it didn’t save. Not even an apology or better yet a good business man would have honored the price on the business website. I asked for the wings to be a little crispy well to my surprise they were so crisp that the outer skin could not be eaten. The fries were grease soaked and soggy. They also do not advise anywhere that it’s cash only so then I was forced to pay his fee of $2.75 as well as a fee from my bank for an out of network ATM. This was my first time ordering and it will be my last. Worst food I’ve ever paid $45.00 for. Never again.
… moreMyob
Gourmet pies. Will help you CUSTOMIZE your own. Out of this world Homespun dressings. Service, quality, top knotch PIZZA.
… moreCali Nicole
AMAZING!! We got 2 pizzas both speciality & 2 orders of wings which were all delicious. Extremely crispy wings & crust on the pizza which makes it overall a 10/10 & everything was portioned really well together. It is honestly the best pizza i’ve tried & we will be returning.
… moreBradley Clark
Stopped in to grab a pizza on our way home. Great tasting pizza. Sauce was sweet but it worked well with the crust. No seating inside, so my wife and I sat on a park bench up the street and enjoyed the day.
… moreILLxMaya
This place is like titanium, while other pizza places change with time and employee turnover, this place remains solid. Their pizza is crisp and lighter on grease than most New York-Style pizza(but still sufficient) with thin-crust, a moderate amount of cheese, and an Italian-style sauce that tastes greener than what I normally encounter(which I thoroughly enjoy). When I stop by, it’s generally for their modestly priced lunch deals or the calzones they make on Wednesday. That’s right, this majestic establishment also makes crispy, lightly-greased calzones on Wednesday. This was news to me that has only made my amorous bond with Market St. Pizza even stronger. “Entice me, almighty enticer” – Some Guy(2023).
… more