Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Large family-owned Neapolitan-Italian restaurant serving red-sauce fare since 1919.
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mario’s Restaurant
Welcome to Mario’s Restaurant of Arthur Avenue. Timeless Italian Recipes … 2342 Arthur Ave, Bronx, NY 10458. Open now • Closes at 9PM. All hours. View …
Menu – Mario’s Restaurant
Official menu for 2342 Arthur Ave. See the most up-to-date menus with photos and descriptions.
Mario’s Restaurant of Arthur Avenue (@mariosarthurave) – Instagram
Since 1919, 5 Generations. Located in the Bronx’s Little Italy Neighborhood …
Reviews
Lux
Mario’s of Arthur Avenue—Where Time Stands Still and Service Means Something
This place is old school in all the good ways. The waiter was exceptionally well-trained and provided a level of service that’s become virtually extinct in this city. It feels like peering through a window into an era when they had your table waiting and your favorite dish already on the way.
They started us with a selection of olive oils and pickled carrots that were aggressively spicy in the best possible way—sharp, tangy, and unapologetic.
I ordered the prosciutto and burrata to start, and it was delicious: paper-thin prosciutto, creamy burrata, simple and flawless.
For the main, I took the server’s recommendation and went with the lasagna. Layers of perfectly cooked pasta, rich with flavor, nothing overwrought or trying too hard.
The entire meal felt like being genuinely taken care of…an art form in itself.
Mario’s isn’t chasing trends or trying to reinvent Italian food. It’s just doing what it’s always done, exceptionally well, with the kind of hospitality that makes you feel like a regular even on your first visit.
If you’re taking a trip to Arthur Ave in the Bronx, this is mandatory.
… moreThis place is old school in all the good ways. The waiter was exceptionally well-trained and provided a level of service that’s become virtually extinct in this city. It feels like peering through a window into an era when they had your table waiting and your favorite dish already on the way.
They started us with a selection of olive oils and pickled carrots that were aggressively spicy in the best possible way—sharp, tangy, and unapologetic.
I ordered the prosciutto and burrata to start, and it was delicious: paper-thin prosciutto, creamy burrata, simple and flawless.
For the main, I took the server’s recommendation and went with the lasagna. Layers of perfectly cooked pasta, rich with flavor, nothing overwrought or trying too hard.
The entire meal felt like being genuinely taken care of…an art form in itself.
Mario’s isn’t chasing trends or trying to reinvent Italian food. It’s just doing what it’s always done, exceptionally well, with the kind of hospitality that makes you feel like a regular even on your first visit.
If you’re taking a trip to Arthur Ave in the Bronx, this is mandatory.
Ares Deleon
I went with my girlfriend and we both enjoyed the food. She didn’t like my Penne Alla Vodka but she did enjoy her Alfredo. They had a love singer and a nice decor. I made a reservation since it was a Valentine’s date. The atmosphere was very nice and the lighting was good. I enjoyed her Alfredo too. I would recommend trying this spot out.
… moreShelly C
My husband surprised me with a visit to this delicious restaurant! It has an Old time Italian restaurant feel with lots of activity at all time. Somehow the waiters and waitresses are able to make each customer feel welcomed and well served. I love their manicotti with velvety thin pasta, melty ricotta, and delicious sauce. We enjoyed dessert too trying a new favorite of tartufo-a chocolate covered ball of Gelato with fudge in the middle. My husband had his old favorite, tiramasu, which had the perfect amount of coffee flavor with chocolate. A whipped cream topped cappuccino finished our meal and then we had to leave. We really appreciated the valet parking as finding a spot would have been impossible!
… moreLamaura Bodrick
I had to take away one star for lack of seasoning everything needed salt which was slightly annoying! However my mom’s dish was perfect and I lovedddd the Cesar salad you can tell the dressing is made in house. My clams also weren’t that fresh had a funky taste I could finished them, we also loved the bread we got 2 round. The service was great we were ah party of 5 and we didn’t need for anything just napkins lol. This place is ah family style place quiet and quaint however it was packed on ah Saturday tables full people enjoying themselves. The drinks were also good the pear martini was my fave but it’s not pictured.
… morebetty pierre
A wonderful Neal meat balls were tasty but cold, antipasti bread delicious. Definitely a return visit. Atmosphere, service price great!
… moreVeronica Hunter
I googled which restaurant on Arthur Ave sells stuffed artichokes.Mario’s stood out with the artichokes photo. I arrived when they opened the restaurant, around 11:30 AM. The moment, I read the menu, I remembered my ex mother in law’s lasagne. Mario’s lasagne is authentic Italian style.
Vhuntermassage LLC
… moreVhuntermassage LLC
maddy
Such amazing service and when I say the food was great I really mean the food was to die for. SO SO GOOD! Our server chatted with us and gave us awesome recommendations of in housemade pastas and made the whole experience absolutely amazing, if you have a chance to eat here I would completely recommend it
… moreEleanor Katz
Like others have said – dining at Mario’s is a step back in time! We stopped in after an afternoon at the NYBG. An old school red sauce joint, tableside singer included. Food was good. Calamari was delicious – very generous portion, perfect fry, served with a great marinara sauce. A different but equally delicious marinara accompanied the chicken parm, also very tasty. Alfredo pasta was just ok, but maybe my fault for straying from “red sauce”. Service was mediocre. Very friendly, but took too long to get our appetizers, then entrees. We came at 5 PM (with a reservation) and the place was packed. Was also family friendly (especiallly at this hour), with a highchair, etc. Make a reservation if you can to avoid the long wait. I’d return!
… moreM A
It was like stepping back in time in an era of nostalgia and Italian food in an atmosphere of a time gone by with dim lit dining room, stories of stars visited and movie references. The visit here was an experience, the food is great, old school traditional sauces, which u can tell were homemade. The owner walked around greeted people had beautiful conversations gave us a little history Lesson about the neighbourhood and menu highlights.
… morePatrik Cela
My first time here was absolutely incredible. Fried calamari and Mario’s salad to start was insane. The best damn calamari ever and a perfect salad. The linguine alfredo was insane with 3 spoons of parmesan. We also had a wine from kosovo for under 50 bucks that was phenomenal. For desert the creme brulee cheesecake sealed the deal. Mario’s is top 3 restaurants on the block guys. Hand down worth every penny. And the service was 10 out of 10 obviously. I didnt even mention the wster, bread and butter and this delicious seasoned sliced carrots they brought to the table before I could even look at the menu. If you need a place to enjoy and feel and eat like a king this is it.
… more