R F
Owners a genuine nice guy, friendly staff, extremely clean interior and the food is amazing. They sell specialty items you cant find at every pizza shop. Definitely worth the time, come check them out.
… moreChristopher Lumia
I am going to make a bold statement. Today I ate the best slice of pizza I have had since I can remember. We get pizza from a lot of places in the area and Marinellis more than others, but today, it was beyond exceptional. Major kudos to the team that crafted this pizza. You raised the bar for me!
… moreKenneth
I very rarely will give 5 stars on a review but this place deserves it. Its hard to find a good, reasonably priced pizzeria that can stay open in Suffolk County, NY. I have 0 complaints. The pizza is excellent! The service has been exceptional. Sausage and pepper roll, hero is great too. My wife loves the eggplant and the seafood is fresh. Check it out yourselves!!!
… moreChris K
I tired Marinelli’s the week it opened and was underwhelmed by the slices I got at the counter. I considered it my last option in town. Tonight I wanted a pizza after a week long vacation out of town and it was later in the night than usual. My usual spot was basically closed and didn’t want a bad pie. I went for a change and it worked out good.
Marinelli’s killed it tonight. One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a while and I’d definitely consider them legit as far as their pizza goes. I’ll definitely be back to try some more.
… moreJUDY COVEY
I just had one of the best experiences ever at Marinelli’s Pizzeria. Every weekend I pick a different place to eat pizza. Some are good some are not. This pizza was a 10!!! The guys behind the counter were a 20!!! Thanks guys for a sweet time..
I will be back for sure.
… moreBrian Loiacono
My wife and I tried Marinelli’s Pizzeria for the first time tonight, and the Sicilian pizza was cooked to perfection. We’ve been looking to try a new place, and tonight’s visit did not disappoint. Simply stated — job and pizza was “well done”, the way we wanted it.
Brian Jude Loiacono
… moreAJR
One of the BEST pizza parlors on Long island! Perfectly tossed pie with quality and balance ingredients. If you’re looking for a perfect pie, this is the place.
… moreneversaydie
Ordered a meat stromboli and got a ham calzone.
Ordered a pie with sausage, overcooked, dry and sausage was over cooked and rubber.
Been here a few times normally pretty good.
… moreChelo Cave
I’m in town for a weeding and my wife found this place, without any exaggeration one of the best authentic Italian food that I have ever had, I’m only here for three day, already been there 3 times, brought some of my family and friends from the trip the second time and they loved it as well, just to mention a few of the items I personally had, and we even got some to go the third time we went, spicy calamari out of this world, pasta fagioli soup, caprese salad, gorgonzola salad, margarita pizza, and for dessert some regular and chocolate cannoli, the last thing I have to say is try it you with all certainty won’t be disappointed, and Joe the owner very friendly and made all of us feel welcome, so thank you for such a wonderful experience and amazing food.
… moreJustin Weidman
Excellent pizza and I would like to say thank you to Joey for bringing us food at the gas station I really enjoy the penne alle vodka slice and chicken bacon ranch
… more