Mary Spillane
I placed an order for pick up which wasn’t quite ready when I got there. While I was waiting, I watched an employee very carefully and deliberately cut a pizza into very even slices. The halves had different toppings and he made sure to keep them separate when slicing. I very much appreciated the attention to detail and almost left a 5-star review without even receiving my pizza.
Food wise, I got the pesto pizzette and a corner grandma slice. I finished both because they were so tasty but definitely didn’t need to. 10/10 would recommend!
… moreAnthony Parris
I got their secret menu item which is garlic knots covered in cheese and pepperoni with a side of vodka sause!! Yum!!! Everything was amazing and great. Also had to try their MVP which is marinara, Vodka and Pesto sauce pizza….as I right this I realize why they call it MVP!! OMG! I would give this place 6 stars if I can! Delicious slice. I recommend this spot! 10/10
… moreNeha Vl
Finally found a new pizza place that not only has a wide and unique selection, but also great tasting pizzas. We tried 6 different slices – plain cheese, margherita, Sicilian, mushroom, eggplant parm and white cheese. It was hard to pick a favorite, they were all so good. The staff at the restaurant were very friendly and let us sit and finish our pizza even after closing time. Will definitely come back!
… moreMegan Gillen
Very tasty pizza spot – they have a lot of good options to choose from and the crust was the optimal level on the chewy/crunchy scale for me. The service was quick. We came at a good time because after we got our pizza, we sat outside and saw a consistent line of people coming/going.
… moreJosh Klein
I order regularly from the 2nd ave location without issue. This is the 3rd and final time I’ll order from Park Avenue. Twice, I’ve received pinwheels which are completely raw inside (unsafe). Tonight, my parm arrived both cold and overcooked via microwave. The chicken and cheese were both dry, hard and chewy. There’s definitely a quality issue at this location.
… moreTracey Juron
My favorite pizza place— not only in the city, but anywhere. Love all the topping options especially the white pizza with ricotta and mushroom. The pizza is perfectly rebaked and has the best crunch to it. Tables are always available along with parm cheese and crushed red shakers. Love it here and I will always be coming to Marinara when I want pizza.
… moreSita Riddle
What’s my first thought when I land in New York? Pizza !!!! Marinara is the cutest Pizza shop, sweet staff and yummiest selection of pizza. I’ll miss you! Treat yourself to some traditional New York Pie! Everything I tried was delicious.
… moreZach
Really, really enjoyed the food! Highly recommend the vodka parm hero as it was absolutely delicious. I enjoyed it more than standard chicken parm. I found the price point was really good as well. The cheese slice was still my favourite, though we had the Buffalo chicken, vodka pasta, and tri sauce square as well. The server was friendly and patient with us as we tried to figure out our order and the food came warm promptly.
… moreGary Wilson
Well I was surprised when they said $4 for the slice, but it is a decent size.
Very thin crust, with a crispy edge.
Good coverage of sauce and cheese.
Excellent flavor.
Really, can’t find anything wrong with it.
I’ll give this one a 96.
… moreEzra Luna
Great pizza!
Little slow but not too bad. Definitely a must visit.
… more