SR
On our first night in West Bend, we asked a few locals where to find the best pizza in town, and they pointed us to Maricio’s in Barton.
It was a busy Friday evening, and the place was packed. We almost ordered takeout, but just as we were deciding, a booth opened up — clearly meant to be! From the moment we walked in, the aroma of Italian food was incredible and made my stomach growl. Every single employee was hustling, yet somehow still friendly, attentive, and upbeat. Our table was cleaned and ready quickly, drink refills were prompt, appetizers came out fast, and our pizza followed soon after. This place runs like a well-oiled machine!
We started with the Haystack Onion Strings and Cheesy Garlic Bread. The onion strings were thin, crispy, and full of flavor, and that garlic bread… absolutely to die for — buttery, cheesy, with perfectly golden crunchy edges and a soft, chewy center.
For our main, we ordered a thin crust cheese pizza with half pepperoni. After those delicious appetizers, we were already pretty full, so we asked them box it up to go. Of course, we couldn’t resist having a slice before we left — and it was fantastic. The rest made the perfect late-night snack back at the hotel!
Maricio’s came highly recommended by locals, and it did not disappoint. Great food, great service, and great people — definitely worth a visit!
… moreCraig Haupt
Maricio’s USED to be our “go to” place till we picked up a pizza and when we got home it was missing the sausage. I called and they said I would get a replacement pizza for the mistake but order it soon. 2 weeks later I called to claim it and they said I had to order a pizza the same way but they wouldn’t charge me for the sausage!! I couldn’t believe it! They never said that’s how it would work when I called them after the mistake!! I am not a complainer or a person that looks for free product. I will not order from there again!!
… moreJoe Z
The best pizza I’ve had in this area so far. Pretty close to being an amazing thin crust pizza. The crust and toppings are great especially the sausage. The sauce is not for me though. Really good prices and deals! Quality product at fair prices makes this one of the best stops in town.
… moreash_lee_GB
Have dined in and most popularly get take out. Pizza is always delicious! I like the traditional wings too! They were busy on a Saturday evening and still had our takeout order ready in 30 min. A favorite for us!
… moreJames Slaughter
Stopped in and had the fresh made chips and cheese, deep dish pizza, and a Gluten-free pizza.
Was so good I could only eat 2 pieces of the deep dish and will use the rest for my lunches.
Our server was excellent.
… moreKa Bao Yang
The gal who took my order on the phone was so pleasant and kind, she made ordering such an ease and gave me suggestions! When I picked up my order, though she was visibly busy, she stopped to greet and thank me which was so sweet of her! The pizza, pizza bread and wings, DELICIOUS! I will definitely be ordering from here again!
… moreRick Neuman
Maricio’s in Barton – DEEP DISH #PIZZA served with a TON of ❤! This isn’t my first time having their pizza, but it is the first time I have dined at the restaurant. This is a very Special Pizza Family! Kind, Attentive, FUN, & ENERGETIC! Mary Waters, Melissa Hammen, & Ali Dixon really make you feel welcome and their smiles shine right through the masks, I like that!
The chips and cheese + the super saucy boneless chicken wings were the perfect way to keep the kids calm while they waited for the pizza! The deep dish pizza does not disappoint. Perfectly balanced in sauce and toppings. Don’t forget to save room for dessert. The Homemade Cannoli was a superb treat. A perfectly crispy shell and creamy sweet filling with chocolate chips and whipped cream! YES PLEASE! Go enjoy their food and make some new friends!
… moreMike Henry
Solid hometown option if you’re looking for a unique experience. You can tell the staff takes pride in what they do. Their pizza sauce is clean and tastes naturally sweet … then add the dialed-in thin crust with the perfect crisp level… together they are covered with quality cheese and toppings. You can’t go wrong.
Their calzone is cheese-topped and delicious with a cup of sauce on the side. Definitely worth a try.
My favorite item on the menu is the chicken parmesan sandwich… it tastes so good.
… moreChristine Brettingen
Pizza is delicious. Service is excellent. Everyone is extremely friendly, including the owner.
… moreBrian Andaloro
Looking for somewhere new, we tried Maricio’s at the recommendation of a coworker. We ordered a deep dish pizza. It wasn’t a typical Chicago style deep dish nor was the crust significantly thicker like a pan or Detroit style pizza. Regardless, the pizza was tasty. This was a solid, quality pizza. We will definitely be back for more!
… more