Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Marcello’s Pizza has been York’s hometown favorite since 1990, serving up authentic New York-style pies with a side of family tradition. From our legendary pizza and cheesesteaks to pastas, wings, and subs, every bite is made with quality ingredients and a whole lotta love. With six convenient locations and a reputation built on flavor, friendliness, and value, Marcello’s is where locals gather for good food and great vibes. Dine in, take out, or get it delivered—either way, you’re family here.
Standard pizzeria turning out classic pies & pastas, with salads, hot subs & wings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 7 S George St #1406, York, PA 17401
Phone: (717) 854-5454
Website: http://marcellosonline.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Marcello’s Pizza | Pizza, Wings, Pasta & Subs in York County
Pizza Shops in York, PA ; EAST YORK. 17 Cinema Drive York, PA 17402 717-755-1001 ; RED LION. 3149 Cape Horn Road Red Lion, PA 17356 717-244-4000 ; WRIGHTSVILLE.
Marcello’s Pizza East York | York PA – Facebook
Marcello’s Pizza East York, York. 7037 likes · 1110 were here. York’s go to pizza shop for classic subs, wings, pasta and award winning pizza! We Deliver!
Marcello’s Pizza (@therealmarcellospizza) · York, PA – Instagram
223 followers · 70 posts · York County’s Favorite Since 1990.
Reviews
Brian Martini
We just live Marcello’s pizza. They don’t deliver to our address, so we go and eat at restaurant. The place is spotless. The condiments were all clean to the touch. A big pet peeve of mine. We will continue to come downtown for their delicious food.
… moreNigar Bayramzade
‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️I stopped here couple of days ago this was by far the wost food I have ever been served. The smell alone was enough to make me lose my appetite it had a strong, rotten, almost sour odor like something that had gone bad. It was absolutely unacceptable.The taste was even worse. One bite was enough to realize the ingredients were not fresh. It tasted old, poorly prepared, and completely flavorless in the worst possible way. The texture was off, and everything about it felt low quality.I genuinely regret spending money here. This was not just bad food it was inedible. I could not finish it and honestly would not recommend this place to anyone
… moreD Rowell
My kid wanted a Marcello’s stromboli and being a YCP student had obviously visited the shop plenty times before and enjoys the food. We decided to give it a go since it would provide food options the family could agree on.
It’s an interesting place for sure. Interior is decent so we decided to eat there. We take a look at the menu presented above the pizza display and it’s anyone’s guess how much each item costs. Not a good start. There are no prices listed anywhere until we head to the register where a paper menu is open. Ok, not bad, prices are reasonable. Looking up there’s a plexiglass screen between the customer and cashier. A little off putting but I get it. It’s in York City, I’m sure they’ve seen and had crazy things happen in the shop. I place the food order and try to also purchase a 2 liter since the individual drink prices are close to $4 for a regular size. Immediately, the cashier barks out that bottled drinks and 2 liters are for take out orders only. Minus 1 ⭐. The only option is the fountain. Fine. We get cups for the fountain, turn around to fill them, and see a letter sized note indicating 1 refill per customer. You know they are guarding that fountain like a hawk. That’s not cool. 1 ⭐ removed.
Sitting at our table waiting for the food to come wasn’t terrible. The $10 subs came out fast but weren’t as full as I hoped. The bread to filling ratio was two notches off and it was an okay sub. Nothing incredible that I’d want to come back for. Minus 1 ⭐. The medium $19 stromboli came out 10 mins later and it looked fantastic. Kid was happy, so I was happy. Add a ⭐.
The owner was nice and it appeared he did most of the work at the shop from the cooking to the cleaning. The cashier stayed behind the counter doing light duties, like handing out overpriced styrofoam cups, ketchup packets, and pizza boxes. Seemed off balance. The shop wasn’t particularly busy on a Friday night.
All in all it’s not a bad place to grab a quick bite as long as it’s to go. Skip the subs, get a stromboli.
… moreIt’s an interesting place for sure. Interior is decent so we decided to eat there. We take a look at the menu presented above the pizza display and it’s anyone’s guess how much each item costs. Not a good start. There are no prices listed anywhere until we head to the register where a paper menu is open. Ok, not bad, prices are reasonable. Looking up there’s a plexiglass screen between the customer and cashier. A little off putting but I get it. It’s in York City, I’m sure they’ve seen and had crazy things happen in the shop. I place the food order and try to also purchase a 2 liter since the individual drink prices are close to $4 for a regular size. Immediately, the cashier barks out that bottled drinks and 2 liters are for take out orders only. Minus 1 ⭐. The only option is the fountain. Fine. We get cups for the fountain, turn around to fill them, and see a letter sized note indicating 1 refill per customer. You know they are guarding that fountain like a hawk. That’s not cool. 1 ⭐ removed.
Sitting at our table waiting for the food to come wasn’t terrible. The $10 subs came out fast but weren’t as full as I hoped. The bread to filling ratio was two notches off and it was an okay sub. Nothing incredible that I’d want to come back for. Minus 1 ⭐. The medium $19 stromboli came out 10 mins later and it looked fantastic. Kid was happy, so I was happy. Add a ⭐.
The owner was nice and it appeared he did most of the work at the shop from the cooking to the cleaning. The cashier stayed behind the counter doing light duties, like handing out overpriced styrofoam cups, ketchup packets, and pizza boxes. Seemed off balance. The shop wasn’t particularly busy on a Friday night.
All in all it’s not a bad place to grab a quick bite as long as it’s to go. Skip the subs, get a stromboli.
Antoine Everette (AJ)
Really good experience my mom loved her food she’s in a wheelchair and I was looking for other places to buy food for her so I came across Marcellos bought a shrimp salad it was very good
… moreRyan
Walking into Marcello’s is like being teleported to the 1990’s. The menu sign is probably the same one they’ve had since they opened, and the restaurant looks and smells like your classic mom and pop pizza shop.
I only ordered a slice of cheese pizza as a snack, so I can’t speak for their whole menu. The slice was okay. The crust, a bit hard for my liking. The prices, although not from the 90’s, were very reasonable!
… moreI only ordered a slice of cheese pizza as a snack, so I can’t speak for their whole menu. The slice was okay. The crust, a bit hard for my liking. The prices, although not from the 90’s, were very reasonable!
Christine Harlacher
We ordered two slices of pepperoni pizza. They took cheese pizza that had been sitting out on the counter for a while and added pepperoni. After they reheated it, it was hard and a little burnt. We weren’t able to eat any of the crust, as it was as hard as a rock.
… moreZiG Ninth
Their chicken salads are usually really good! But they changed their mozzarella sticks! They used to have thick cheesy ones now they have the skinny ones. Not as good! And they were overcooked the last time I got them. Almost burnt. Didn’t taste good. I was disappointed! Please go back to your old mozzarella sticks they were the best!
Update…they finally got their old mozzarella stix back! Happy about that! But lately they’ve been forgetting stuff in my order. If it’s not the diced seasoned tomatoes on my chicken salad, it’s either the French dressing or the plastic fork. So now I really have to check my order before I leave now so I don’t end up disappointed or frustrated. So for that I have to deduct one star
… moreUpdate…they finally got their old mozzarella stix back! Happy about that! But lately they’ve been forgetting stuff in my order. If it’s not the diced seasoned tomatoes on my chicken salad, it’s either the French dressing or the plastic fork. So now I really have to check my order before I leave now so I don’t end up disappointed or frustrated. So for that I have to deduct one star
Yama R1
Ordered pepperoni pizza and was delicious as always. Been going here for a few years now and whether I eat in or take out I have never been disappointed with any of their food. Employees are courteous and do their job well. Sometimes you’ll see the owner helping out and you can see he takes pride in his business. Keep it going!
… moreGulay Huseynova
Very bad experience overall. The food smelled sour and tasted even worse. It seemed low quality and rushed. I couldn’t finish my meal and left completely unsatisfied
… moreGul Nabiyeva
Food was disgusting. The service was bad as well. Employees were rude and careless. I don’t recommend at all
… more