bruce longenecker
Ive ordered from here a few times now, pizza has been consistently very good. Nice thin crust with a perfect nyc style cook to it. The personal stromboli for the price is very small and open ends unlike a normal stromboli id say about the same size as a dominoes sandwich. Still tasted good but ill stick to the pizza. Garlic knots are ok they look like they are baked in tray smashed together or something they are not your typical shape or texture.
… moreApril VanFossen
Got a Buffalo chicken calzone was not good at all barely any cheese in it very small and dough was over cooked. I ordered it with mild sauce and it was made with hot sauce. The original one they made for me was given to the driver for a delivery order so they had to hurry up and make a new one while my husband waited . I will not be returning
… moreJennifer Magi
I drove 40 minutes to get dinner from here so if that doesn’t tell you that this place is worth the trip, nothing will. The pizza is so reminiscent of Little Italy in NYC. It’s a cozy, friendly atmosphere and the people that are behind the counter are helpful and wonderful. Hands down this is a great “pizza and more” place to go and grab a bit to eat. Highly recommended!!
… moreJeremiah Sira
⚠️!!WORST PIZZA PLACE IN THE AREA!! ⚠️
After waiting 2 1/2 hrs for an order placed at 445 pm the delivery driver showed up without my salad and a pizza that was not fully cooked. I called and the owner was not willing to take any accountability blaming it on various employees. I simply asked for a full refund which he refused to do. Pizza is the easiest business there is get your act together or get lost.
… moreKathy Spagnola
I purchased an eggplant dinner from Manhattan pizzeria last week and while I was enjoying my meal, I found plastic right away two pieces of plastic. I called the restaurant and asked to speak to the person in charge. Describe what happened. They asked me to send a picture of the plastic. I asked for their name. They told me to just put it under B for my text message. I sent it and indeed it was of two pieces of the lid obviously very poor quality containers never an apology or an attempt to make it correct I’ve been going to Manhattan ever since they came to Amsterdam. I will never ever go to that restaurant again I found approximately 6 to 8 additional pieces of plastic in my food.
… moreiMacOfDeath
A really saucy pizza, but not in a good way.
Placed an order over the phone for a small Chicken Teriyaki pizza and Fried Calamari, was told it would be about 30 minutes. On my way over I got a call but I figured it was just the place letting me know it was ready, turns out they were trying to let me know they were out of calamari. Oh well.
Arrived and paid for the pizza, coming to just under $20. The pizza look good, smelled good, and had a nice weight to it. I was a little disappointed about the calamari, but not enough to dock any stars. Especially since they did call me to see if I wanted anything different.
Back home I found the pizza to be, well, too sweet. I think they perchance went a little too ham with the teriyaki sauce, resulting in it overpowering the more meaty and savory flavors. I had also requested the garlic parmesan crust, but the flavor was just not there, it was so bland and dull. Paired with the sweet flavor of the sauce, it almost had the effect of becoming closer to fried dough than anything like pizza crust. In the end, while it still satisfied me, or in other words “I ate it because I was hungry”, it was not great by any means.
I think if they had gone much lighter with the drizzling of the teriyaki sauce, the rest of the pizza would have stood a chance at fighting to be present on the pallet.
… morethomas mazza
Clean fast and friendly. If your in town and stewarts pizza just won’t do, check out Manhattan. Lots of parking. Hot and fresh
Grab and go, skip the rest.
Thank you Manhattan for keeping it happening!
… morejoseph scarano
Was with friends up in the lake sagandaga area on our way home and typically the pizza in that area is terrible but we decided we needed a quick meal for the road so we stopped at Manhattan Express. The pizza was quite good which was surprising and the service was good. We really didn’t stay in the place we were in and out so I cannot comment so much on the atmosphere but it was empty but the pizza was still good
… moreHeather Rose
Would not give this place 1 star! Completely disappointed for the last time. Ordered an Italian mix home got home opened it. For one i asked for Mayo and oil and ving… got a very small amount of Mayo no oil or Italian… very little lettuce and hardly any meat on it. My husband ordered calzone with meatball and onion… he had one meatball cut in half in the whole thing. This is not my first issue and swore I’d never go back after the first issue with the owner raising his voice and being very unprofessional to me on the phone when I called to ask questions about the menu for a party. He felt the need to raise his voice to me and said “don’t tell me what my menu says!” Needless to say I never ordered the food for the party… I gave a 300$ order to someone else… his loss not mine. I knew I should not have gave them another try! Very poor service very unprofessional rude workers and food is not worth the money! I’ll take my business elsewhere along with many others I’ve heard of lately.
… moreCheryl Reagan
Excellent delivery service . I Ordered a pizza for 1:15 . I got it at 1. It was hot and delicious. Thank you for being at my home before the time asked for. Will order again
… more