4.2 – 262 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Established, laid-back pizza parlor preparing sandwiches & other casual bites to eat in or take out.
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
uploads-ssl.webflow.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reviews
Jordan M
I’d been crazing this pizza recently although I haven’t had it in nearly 10 years and I’m not usually a fan of other sweet sauce pizzas. I finally got the opportunity to see if it still measures up to my fond memories of scarfing down plain slices with the signature sweet sauce after school; It’s safe to say my cravings have been satisfied and the pizza still slaps! I also ordered the steak and cheese Stromboli which had the perfect flaky crust and is great dipped in the pizza sauce!
… moreAbel Gaska
This place has a lot of history, a community vibe and pleasant atmosphere. Also, some of the best pizza I have ever eaten. I got a medium square, with “John’s Way”(italian seasoning). Great pizza for $12.
… moreB Forte
Mamma Mia’s Pizza is that place that leaves you thinking I swear I was there before? Family brought the pizza home today and we swore we never had it. The Pizza sauce was sweet, but a different kind of sweet that left you saying what is that with each bite. The dough and crust made me think of what if a pizza fritta became a pizza? There’s something in every bite that leaves you wondering and saying how delicious. A friend referred us, but I swear we were there before. I’m still craving more and you will be too. Stop on in and enjoy.
… moreMike C
Hole in the wall place serving amazing sweet sauce pizza. Always order the XL round pie, and keep telling myself I need to try a square tray.
… moreMarkara Bermel
Mama Mia’s is my fiancé’s and my favorite pizza shop. We usually order to go, but last night we went with my parents, and it was so nice. My parents (they haven’t had it in years) were so happy. My mom said it was as good as she remembers, and my parents were saying they should have never stopped coming haha and that they will get it more often! And of course the food was 10/10 as always! The staff is so friendly too!
… moreRyan Seidof
I went Saturday around 8 my one son and his girlfriend were picking up an order and while there my other son ordered a pie. So we got the food brought it home we all took a slice took a few bites long hairs in the pizza baked into the cheese. Gross that is foul…All of the pizza had long hair. We all gagged because it was 2-3 piece i in each slice. Hairnets hello ..That is a health code violation. A piece of hair can happen but like 20 in a pizza that is foul nasty. That means you have low standards and don’t have the care for your customers that keep your business a float. I went there with the recommendation of my son, his girlfriend, and a few friends. After that experience I would tell anyone to stay away. Have more pride in your food, establishment, and name because that is your name connected to the business. I would say don’t waste you money and if you look others have found hair in their food so this is not isolated.
… moreJoey Fleming
Update: Just ordered a square meatball Parm pizza. Outstanding.
I’m still a new fan of this place, and I like to think I’m quite pizza-savvy, but this place is amazing. We get pizza from here frequently for after work pizza nights. I much prefer square pizza (old forge pizza fan), but this is probably my favorite round pizza in the area. I want to try some of the other items on the menu soon. Tonight I had chicken Alfredo. I’d post pics but it was gone too quick and I forgot.
… moreAli
Mamma Mia’s used to be our favorite pizza. I’m not sure what happened, but it’s truly terrible anymore. Drove 20mins 1 way to get home with a pizza that resembled a black rock & wasn’t edible. Called to speak with someone for a replacement & never received a call back. Won’t be ordering from here anymore!
… moreSamantha Homeier
This pizza Is AMAZING! Never had a sweet sauce before but omg it’s amazing !
Amazing service fresh pizza ! Can’t wait to order more
… morechristopher leonard
Got 6 cut cheese pizza and old bay fries which we barely had any of. . Pizza seemed like it was reheated and fries BURNT
… more … View more