Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 587 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 11769
Phone: (631) 589-9640
Website: https://www.mamaslasalle.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Original Mama’s Italian Restaurant – Oakdale
Mama’s Oakdale(631) 589-9640 … Heritage is very important to any family… especially the Martino Family. Mama and Papa Martino came here from Italy in 1955 …
Mama’s Pizza Restaurant | Oakdale NY – Facebook
Mama’s Pizza Restaurant , Oakdale. 191 likes · 23 talking about this … 587 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY, United States, 11769. Links. . mamaslasalle.com …
Mama’s – Oakdale, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery – Seamless
Mama’s Pizza Specialties · Garlic Knot Crust Pizza · $33.50 · Eggplant Pizza · $32.99 · Broccoli white Pizza · $29.99 · Buffalo Chicken Pizza · $35.25. Chicken …
Reviews
Louise Tedesco
I’m not sure if we would go back. Service and atmosphere were nice.. but the tomato sauce on the lasagna was not that great. Had no flavor at all. I ordered fried veal cutlet.. I was disappointed, as it was batter dipped deep fried.. I guess I expected pan-fried in breadcrumbs and seasoning on it. Maybe just an off night.
… moreTroy Sessions
Not a very happy experience but I don’t really blame them. It’s Christmas eve, maybe 6:15pm. We happen to be driving by, and saw the place was crowded. We stopped in, at the counter we said we wanted to make an order to go and the young girl was happy to help us. Out of the blue a gentleman groans out, no more kitchen orders loudly. The girl looked horrified, and was apologetic. It smelled good inside so disappointed we couldn’t try it. A simple I’m sorry the kitchen just closed, happy holidays, goes a long way. I get the frustration of running a food establishment especially during the holidays. But we felt like we were the problem. Maybe we’ll try again, maybe not.
… morePatriot The Penguin (Bottlesgonewild)
Kyle.was.our server
Started us off with
2 glasses of water
Bread sticks
House Salad
Lobster Raviolli in creamy sauce with seafood bits
Chicken Romantica
Chicken Cutlet topped with cheese in a bed of sauce with Asparagus pieces topped with Artichoke
Side dish of pasta and sauce
Kyle was attentive, cordial.
Food runner was great also.
… moreStarted us off with
2 glasses of water
Bread sticks
House Salad
Lobster Raviolli in creamy sauce with seafood bits
Chicken Romantica
Chicken Cutlet topped with cheese in a bed of sauce with Asparagus pieces topped with Artichoke
Side dish of pasta and sauce
Kyle was attentive, cordial.
Food runner was great also.
Glenn
Friday night is go out to dinner night…and a treat indeed to find such a gem. Home cooking with no waiting! Cozy and warm, friendly and delicious. Generous portions with a full menu and reasonable prices. We’ll be back!
… moreJoey “Joey Baggadonuts” Brown
My wife and I visited yesterday afternoon for their pasta special. We live nearby, but we haven’t been here in years. Friends have told us to give it another try, and we loved our meals and the service. Kyle was our server, and he welcomed us both just as he did his many “regulars”. I had the rigatoni di Spago and she had the Penne Rigate Alla Bellini. The servings are more than enough for 2-3 meals, and their homemade lentil soup was also excellent. This place is a hidden gem, and we will become frequent customers. Thank you, Kyle and your team!
… morekevthepoolguy
Food was extremely lackluster with almost 0 flavor. Server was slow and honestly seemed like he didn’t care when we didn’t like The quality of the food. We didn’t even eat the food that was served to us just left it on the table and asked for the check
… moreKerry Collins
Whether you dine in or order pizza to go, you will be happy you went to Mama’s. I love coming here on pasta nights (Monday and Tuesday) for the (very reasonably) fixed price meals that include soup/salad, entree, dessert, and wine. There’s always enough to re heat for lunch the next day. If you have friends from out of town that want to try real long island pizza you should order from Mama’s. I moved away and I cry every time I eat their za. The servers are so hard working and friendly. Shout out to Christy!! She’s killing it!! Ps – pasta nights get BUSY so it would be smart to make a reservation.
… moreJustJrmy
Their pizza is pretty good, otherwise I haven’t tried their fancy restaurant side. The crust has a nice crunch to it and the flavor is good, toppings always seem fresh as well. Location is nice as it’s in a little plaza next to some other stores.
… moreKaren Smith
I’ve been ordering Sicilian pizza my entire life, this pizza is pathetic. Everything has gone up , we all too dollar and there is minimum cheese, nothing like sicillian. Awful. Waste of money. Del by Door dash asked to be handed to me, left on cement ground, when I realized outside ice cold. Note: it’s very hot here. What is wrong with that driver!!!
… moreAustin Coppola
We’ve gotten good pizza from here before as takeout, but the dine-in experience was pretty horrible.
This place needs to be staffed better, we waited for over 90 minutes to get food for two people (two plates of pasta without meat or anything fancy) and the whole time it seems as though the entire dining room was being managed by a singular waitress.
Food was not worth the wait, the salad we got was clearly unwashed lettuce, and the Alfredo we ordered was basically inedible.
our server was really helpful and friendly the entire time and seemed as though she was doing her best, but the bottom line is that it was just way too much for one person. I hope and pray that they were short because someone called out, and that there isn’t normally a lack of staffing like this.
… moreThis place needs to be staffed better, we waited for over 90 minutes to get food for two people (two plates of pasta without meat or anything fancy) and the whole time it seems as though the entire dining room was being managed by a singular waitress.
Food was not worth the wait, the salad we got was clearly unwashed lettuce, and the Alfredo we ordered was basically inedible.
our server was really helpful and friendly the entire time and seemed as though she was doing her best, but the bottom line is that it was just way too much for one person. I hope and pray that they were short because someone called out, and that there isn’t normally a lack of staffing like this.