Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Mama T’s Italian Eatery is a family run Italian restaurant that serves the best in fresh made pizza, pasta, sandwiches, appetizers, and salads. We also serve beer, wine, and sangria. Our style is very old school with big portions and that classic Italian immigrant taste that is so hard to find. Buon Appetito!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 781 E Geneva St, Elkhorn, WI 53121
Phone: (262) 379-1148
Website: http://www.mamasitalianeatery.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mama T’s Italian Eatery | Elkhorn WI – Facebook
Mama T’s Italian Eatery, Elkhorn. 3356 likes · 323 talking about this · 1341 were here. Quaint family owned and operated Italian restaurant.
Mama T’s Italian Eatery | Elkhorn WI – Facebook
Start the week off right! Mama T’s Italian Eatery now offering lunch portions for $6.95, leaving plenty of room for dessert! Bon Appetit! No photo description …
Mama T’S Italian Eatery Elkhorn, WI | Reviews, Photos & Menu
Located at 781 E Geneva St, this charming spot serves up hearty, flavorful dishes that will make you feel right at home. Whether you’re dining in with friends …
Reviews
Mary Jo Knueppel
We stopped in for dinner this evening. We graciously greeted and allowed to choose our own spot. Our server was there very shortly after and brought water and gave us the specials. Our drink order was taken, and my husband’s salad was brought just a few minutes later. The atmosphere is pleasant and not too noisy. Our dinners arrived and were simply beautiful to look at and even better to eat. Prices are reasonable and you get more than enough. We highly recommend Mama Ts for a special occasion or a night out.
… moreSamantha Brown
I hate to say this because I’m from Chicago but Mama T’s has the best deep dish pizza I’ve ever had. Their sauce is sooo good and their deep dish is always crunchy. Back home you have to order it well-done and uncut or else it will be soggy. We don’t have to worry about that here. My husband makes fun of me because this is one of the only restaurants I ever want to go to. The thing is that they are always so nice, the food is so good, they always get my order right, and online pickup or eating there is always quick and easy.
… morew fegg
We arrived at 5pm and by 6 the place was full. Tells me that popular they have good food. And it was! We had deep dish Chicag styl pizza. They have sausage with excellent flavor. Order double. Staff was very nice and took great care of us. I ordered a side salad as appetizer and it was very good. We will definitely go back to try other dishes. It was nice of Mama T to circulate among the tables
… moreIvan Phillips
Taken out here for a “farewell” meal before heading back to the UK….great service as we anticipated and the food was excellent. Desert was way above brilliant but tiramisu isy favorite .
… moreSierra
Small Italian place, seems like a mom and pop restaurant. Service was excellent and food was pretty good! They also had a small bar for those that wanted drinks. Fun place to go for a nicer meal out of the house.
… moreChew Toy
Cheerful well paced service. Eggplant Parmesan & A Calzone for entrees. Very tasty. Good value. A family atmosphere without a high volume. Witnessed a lot of curbside carry out on a Saturday evening. My first time there. I would trust anything on the menu based on this first visit.
… moreJennifer Hinrichs
Found this cute little gem in Elkhorn. It is located in a strip mall across from the high school. It is pretty nondescript from the outside. Kind of looks like a fast food place on the outside. On the inside it is pretty cute! It is small and the tables are close together. We were there early in on a Wednesday, so it wasn’t busy.
They have a limited appetizer menu, no calamari. We did not have an appetizer. Dinners come with garlic bread. Salad or soups are available for a charge. Now, the salads we saw looked delicious, but we opted to just have pasta! We tried the Fritti Di Mari, it was fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp and scallops. The pasta tasted like it may be homemade, cooked perfectly Al dente. The Alfredo was delicious and I am picky, in fact I would have liked a bit more of the Alfredo, but wanted to try it how it comes the first time! The shrimps were good, but kind of small, the scallops had good flavor but were very small, I’m including a picture. They were generous with the portion of pasta and there was quite a bit of seafood too. We tried the penne All’ Arrabiatta it was penne pasta in a spicy red sauce with sausage. It was spicy, but good! We also tried an order of meatballs. Then come 2 to an order for $5.50. These things were HUGE! They had great flavor but were a little over cooked on the bottoms. They come in marinara and that was delicious too, it had a hint of sweetness to it which I love!
They had lots of choices of desserts, we tried a 5 layer chocolate cake…it was ginormous, rich and sinful and the tiramisu also delicious, creamy would definitely have them again! They do not have a dessert menu as their desserts are always changing, so definitely ask your server!
Our server was great, friendly and efficient.
It was a great semi local find and we can’t wait to go back and try something else! The pizza looked amazing!
Prices were reasonable for the quality and amount of food. It was about $25/30 per person with an entree, soda and dessert.
The restaurant was clean and bathrooms were clean. They have a bar with stools for seating and offer a large menu of wine and fancy mixed drinks!
… moreThey have a limited appetizer menu, no calamari. We did not have an appetizer. Dinners come with garlic bread. Salad or soups are available for a charge. Now, the salads we saw looked delicious, but we opted to just have pasta! We tried the Fritti Di Mari, it was fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp and scallops. The pasta tasted like it may be homemade, cooked perfectly Al dente. The Alfredo was delicious and I am picky, in fact I would have liked a bit more of the Alfredo, but wanted to try it how it comes the first time! The shrimps were good, but kind of small, the scallops had good flavor but were very small, I’m including a picture. They were generous with the portion of pasta and there was quite a bit of seafood too. We tried the penne All’ Arrabiatta it was penne pasta in a spicy red sauce with sausage. It was spicy, but good! We also tried an order of meatballs. Then come 2 to an order for $5.50. These things were HUGE! They had great flavor but were a little over cooked on the bottoms. They come in marinara and that was delicious too, it had a hint of sweetness to it which I love!
They had lots of choices of desserts, we tried a 5 layer chocolate cake…it was ginormous, rich and sinful and the tiramisu also delicious, creamy would definitely have them again! They do not have a dessert menu as their desserts are always changing, so definitely ask your server!
Our server was great, friendly and efficient.
It was a great semi local find and we can’t wait to go back and try something else! The pizza looked amazing!
Prices were reasonable for the quality and amount of food. It was about $25/30 per person with an entree, soda and dessert.
The restaurant was clean and bathrooms were clean. They have a bar with stools for seating and offer a large menu of wine and fancy mixed drinks!
Teresa DuBose
Mama T’s is a true gem! The food is delicious, authentic, and super affordable — perfect for families. Our server Hannah was awesome! Everything was spot on from the salad, to the garlic bread and pasta dishes! Mama T herself came to our table to check on us — such a warm, personal touch. We’ll definitely be back!!
… moreRosa Vasquez (iamamiwhoami)
I came across this spot while on our way back home, and I had to give them a try! We were greeted and sat down right away when we walked in. Our server was very knowledgeable and attentive, and she was very friendly! We ordered wings and white peach sangria per their recommendation. Also an Italian Beef and Mostoccoli. Everything came to our table in a timely manner, and we dug right in! She was not kidding when she said the wings were great! We loved them so much! They were larger, crispy on the outside and sauced just right! It was amazing! The white peach sangria was spot on! The Italian beef was very delicious, it was less salty then others I’ve had, which is a plus for me personally, because I am sodium sensitive! My partners Mostoccoli was super delicious, and yes, I tried some of that too, haha! Overall the atmosphere was very wonderful, the decor inside made me feel welcomed like home, and the server was wonderful at taking care of us and the food was superb. Thank you to the chefs who made our food, we were truly satisfied and amazed by what we ordered. We will be back soon. I would highly recommend this place!
… moreKeqi Gan
Came in on a Wednesday evening around 7 pm and it was packed. We all got pastas(seafood, chicken, and spicy sausage). All of them came with garlic bread and all of them very tasty. As far as pasta goes, it is as good as it can be except some dishes I had in Milan and Germany. Services was very friendly but a bit longer wait due to the crowd. Highly recommended and worth the wait.
… more