Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553
Phone: (845) 561-6262
Website: http://mamatheresasnewwindsor.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria & Italian Eatery
Nestled in the small town of New Windsor, Mama Theresa’s roots are in Brooklyn, New York. Our family recipes of traditional Italian Dishes and Imported …
Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria and Italian Eatery, New Windsor …
Pizza · Anchovies Artichoke Hearts** Bacon* Black Olives Broccoli Buffalo Chicken* Buffalo Shrimp** · Calamata Olives* Eggplant Extra Cheese Fried or Grilled …
Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria and Italian Eatery – Facebook
Page · Pizza place · (845) 561-6262 · mamatheresasNewWindsor.com · See more about Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria and. Italian Eatery.
Reviews
leslie simek
You can never go wrong ordering dinners or pizza from this yummy place. Though portions have shrunk slightly, the chicken parm and eggplant rollatini with penne vodka are scrumptious and reasonably priced . They have the best homemade pizza rolls and delicious salad, too. I have catered many events from here. I would also rather order from here for Christmas Eve dinner than make dinner myself. Love their sauce. Love their pizza, too. Great hot wings, too. If you are looking for awesome hot or cold sandwiches, then look no further. Momma T’s Italian and Vailsgate bravest or finest are very yummy, too. My son loves their meatballs and won’t eat mine. Lol! Take out or eat in. They have delivery too.
… moreTim Morgan
I didn’t realize lasagna construction consisted of 5 layers of straight pasta sheets. Your $17 is better spent elsewhere. In the past, my chicken parm has been pounded so thin that I was basically eating bread. I’m about done with this place. Gets one more star for the flavor and that’s about it.
… moreRich Tejeda
Food is consistently the best in the area. All through the pandemic they remained consistent, never raised prices and still give massive portions. A dinner here is easily good for 3-4 meals. Grandma pizza for $20 weighs a ton – such a great bargain! The best.
… moreS A
Food is great. Pizza is great atmosphere is great. The service is ok . Messed up my order one time and gave my pizza to someone else. Other than that I can’t complain.
… morearlene jimenez
It’s fine if you order their Italian stuff. The Philly cheese streak was bland with only imitation nacho cheese. It was the worst Philly I’ve ever had
… moreKiera Worner
The new windsors finest hero is unbelievable. 10000% recommend; I believe they use terranova for bread too which is always a plus. Quick and friendly service as always.
… moreMatthew Weil
Without a doubt the best in the area and THEY DELIVER!!! Always fresh and never lets us down. Thank you!!
… moreAndy P
Love their pizza! Best I’ve had in this part of town! Sicilian is bomb
… moreFred Whitaker
A simple place with great food and fairly big portions. Waitress was very pleasant. Dining room in the back was clean and not crowded when we were there
… moreAlyssa Bennett
Edit: whoever is working here now has zero concept of what they’re doing. Who ever answered on Feb 1 for dinner service was incredibly rude and unknowledgeable about the menu. We were told that we couldn’t get just the appetizer eggplant and had to get an entire entree. When picking up our food we were told we “just called” so our food wasn’t ready. We were told 15-20 minutes and arrived after 30 minutes. Then after waiting another 10 minutes, our chicken Marsala came with pasta and red sauce. Since when does chicken marsala get served with red sauce? The same guy told us to just ask for it with marsala sauce next time. Sorry but there will not be a next time after this. Such a shame because it really was a great takeout spot.
… more