Kelly H.
This was our first visit but it will not be our last. Everything was outstanding. Portions are generous and we brought lots of leftovers home. We (hubby & I) ordered the 3 Course Combo and couldn’t even make it to dessert. Our waitress graciously packaged our Tiramisus to go. I had it the next day and it was delicious. Absolutely, hands down, best food we’ve had in a LONG time.
… moreAnita Brighton
Really great variety of very tasty food. Tastes like home made. Infinitely superior to that large chain popular Italian restaurant we all know. Our server was excellent as was each member of the support team. Very approachable, knowledgeable and made appropriate recommendations based on a thoughtful assessment, when asked. I really appreciated their help with making a selection. There were so many food choice I had a hard time narrowing down what to try. Thoroughly enjoyed everything about dining here.
… moreZoltan Barnes
The food was bland. Somehow this is the first Italian restaurant I’ve been to that doesn’t include complimentary bread with a $25 entrée. When I asked, the waitress implied she’d bring some out—then dropped focaccia (not my thing) on the table and charged me $6 for it. If you’re going to upsell bread, at least make it cheese bread or garlic bread.
For what it costs, the food doesn’t deliver. Domino’s honestly does Italian flavors better, and at least their pricing is upfront. Also worth noting: the servers at places like Domino’s tend to appreciate a $10 tip more than this place seems to.
Won’t be back.
… moreDavid W
Great food, service and atmosphere except for one very important glitch.
I found this place on Google and it has a good rating and we prefer to go to a Mom and Pop place. We got decent seats. Dee Dee was great! The food and choice were good. Three of us chose the three course dinner. All were good.
The glitch was that only three of the four plates were served. It was quite awkward waiting around while our food got cold waiting for our fourth person to get served.
If not for the above, it would have been a solid 5.
… moreJoslin Abraham
The garlic cheese bread was delicious. I also quite enjoyed the fettuccine Alfredo. Great food! Would recommened!
… moreBranden Randall
We went here today for the first time. The food had great flavor, good ideas and was very comforting but unfortunately wasn’t very well executed. My chicken parmasean was very over cooked, probably from sitting under the heat lamp, there wasn’t a single bit of moisture left inside the chicken. The sauce and breading and noodles were excellent though, great flavors.
Dessert was kind of the same. The bread pudding had incredible flavor, raspberry, brioche, custard, orange, and just the right amount of sweetness, it was great, until you go to the center and it was almost raw, just barely warm and became barely edible due to the consistency.
Great great flavors, not so great execution. Still, good enough that we plan on coming back to see if it was just an off night!
… moreiinan the mage
We were promptly seated. We ordered the meat flatbread appetizer (aka thin crust pizza), the grinder sandwich, the lemon pepper linguine with sautéed prawns, 2 cups of coffee and a bloody Mary. Total $76.00, not including tip. The flat bread appetizer was just thin crust pizza. Since there was little to no cheese when you took a bite, all the meat just rolled off, but the sauce was good. The grinder had very little meat and was mostly bread and lettuce, and it was so dripping in sauce that I had to cut it up and eat it with a fork. The lemon pepper linguine was a very small portion and a bit dry but tolerable. The bloody Mary was good but a bit spicy. Another place that’s fun to try but not a good value at all. We don’t plan on coming back for another meal.
… moreDuncan McAlpine
Absolutely loved our experience at Mama Stortini’s Happy Hour! My wife and I shared a few dishes and were blown away by the flavor and quality. The Rigatoni Bolognese was rich and comforting — the sauce was hearty and flavorful, and the crispy breadcrumbs added the perfect texture. The Goat Cheese & Tomato Bruschetta was fresh and bright, with a delicious combo of creamy goat cheese and ripe tomatoes, all tied together with a touch of basil. The Tuscan Chop Chop Salad was another standout — fresh, crisp, and loaded with bold flavors from the smoked gouda, salami, and roasted turkey.
To top it all off, they had a seasonal draft beer at a fantastic price, which paired perfectly with our food. Everything on the happy hour menu was a hit, and we can’t wait to come back to try more. Highly recommend stopping by — you won’t be disappointed!
… moreLina Cruz
The food was excellent and the service was great. Next time we’re in Federal Way we’ll definitely be stopping by.
… moreKaren Lewis
Delivered food to our home. Had colossal chicken parm & short rib ravioli with crunchy shrimp appetizer. Also dessert but have not tried that yet…The food was awesome. I order these ravioli almost every time because they are soooo good! The hubby wanted a Cajun pasta but it wasn’t available on the delivery menu. He enjoyed the chicken but said the spaghetti was good but not any thing special.
… more