Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 3–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 4–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mama Shelbys Pizza | Rogersville AL – Facebook
They are also now offering Mama Shelby’s Homemade Ranch as a dipping sauce. However, if you’re still in the mood for pizza tonight and want to support your …
Mama Shelby’s Pizza, 16428 Highway 72, Rogersville, AL 35652, US
Get more information for Mama Shelby’s Pizza in Rogersville, AL. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Mama Shelby’s Pizza (@mamashelbys) • Instagram photos and videos
99 followers · 58 following · 15 posts · @mamashelbys: “16428 Highway 72 Rogersville, AL 35652”
Last Updates
Reviews
Calvin Mclaughlin
On 10/11/25 We ordered the Butchers Special,some cheese sticks, and last but certainly not least the loaded garlic knots! ALL of the food was HOT and FRESH and some of the MOST DELICIOUS Ive EVER EATEN!!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! WILL BE ORDERING FROM HERE AGAIN!!
… moreKathryn Richley
I ordered their Italian sub. Let me tell you, it was a big sandwich! The toppings were fresh, the bread crisp. The garlic knots are a must have!! Also had the pizza with pepperoni, delicious!! Will always go there when in town!
This is only half of the sub I received!
… moreThis is only half of the sub I received!
Amy Davenport
First time trying this place and it is my new go-to for pizza. They had me at sauerkraut (and if you haven’t tried sauerkraut with pepperoni or bacon, you are missing out), but I was also really happy that the sauce wasn’t sweet like some places. It was all really good. Not stingy with the toppings, perfectly proportioned ingredients, homemade dough, friendly staff – highly recommend! (The only reason I gave four stars for atmosphere is because it’s really just a takeout place. But it looks clean and well-kept.)
… moreDavid Jones
Food was delicious. Cooked perfect and had leftovers. We fed 4 people. The cinnasticks were better than any we have ever had. This restaurant is definitely my new favorite pizza place.
… moreMackenzie Jackson
We have eaten here many times and are never disappointed!! Just tried their new cheese ravioli and wow! needs to be a permanent addition to the menu immediately. Definitely recommend them.
… moreJonah Griffin
About gave up on Pizza in the Rogersville area. I am glad i didn’t. This place made two of the best pizzas I think i ever had. I was more surprised by how good the meat lovers pizza was than anything else! It was by far the best one I have ever had. And then the Pickle Ranch Chicken??? Out of this world good. Will be recommending for pizza for anyone around here.
… morewesley swaim
Pizza was excellent. I called ahead and it was hot and ready when I arrived. I had the large pepperoni and it easily fed 4 adults and 1 pizza crazed toddler. My son said it was the bestest pizza he ever ate. I even had a few left overs for the next day.
… moreDavid Alexander
First time here. Three large take-out pizzas for just under $90??! Seems high to me. If it were great pizza, I would have been ok with it. For the price I paid, I expect lots of quality toppings, good flavor and freshly made crust. That is not what we got. It was soggy, borderline undercooked, greasy, and way too salty. Topping’s were skimpy and low quality. I may be wrong but the crust was chewy like pre-made/ frozen. At best, this pizza was ok. The price is out of line for what you get. The gas station down the road makes a comparable pizza for $10-12/ just not as big.
… moreJonathan Rhodes
Tried Mama Shelby’s due to our normal spot Clays pizza letting us down our last time but I’m glad it happened, Hands down the best pizza in Rogersville is at Mama Shelby’s!! Glad we gave it a shot. Hate we didn’t make the switch sooner.
Update: been coming for months and picked up a pizza on 1-17-25. Not sure if they need to clean their ovens or not but had chunks of like black ash on our pizza. Absolutely ruined the taste and pizza. Never had this issue anywhere and don’t work in the food industry so not sure what causes black chunks of ash on the food.
… moreUpdate: been coming for months and picked up a pizza on 1-17-25. Not sure if they need to clean their ovens or not but had chunks of like black ash on our pizza. Absolutely ruined the taste and pizza. Never had this issue anywhere and don’t work in the food industry so not sure what causes black chunks of ash on the food.
PJ Pucci
This place is awesome, their pizzas are all amazing and the chicken pickle sub is new and its amazing. Everything that comes out of their kitchen is perfect. Probably got them Keebler elves back their cause these flavors are magical I swear
… more