Hello neighbors, we have been making pizza as a family for over 20 years using the finest flour, cheese, sauce and making the brick oven pizza.Finally, tomorrow ( 6/27 /2025 ) we are opening our second location at 171 Forest St, Montclair, NJ 07042. We can’t wait to serve you our thin New York style pizzas, deep dish Detroit style pizzas, square pizzas, and gluten free pizzas at our nice patio , dine in or delivery to your home.
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 171 Forest St, Montclair, NJ 07042
Phone: (973) 440-1055
Website: http://makerpizzamontclair.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Maker’s Pizza Website
Address: 171 Forest, Montclair NJ 07042, United States. Restaurant Hours: Everyday. 10:00 am -8:00 pm. Email: [email protected]. ©2025 Ali Gourmet LLC.
Order Now – MAKER PIZZA
At Maker Pizza, it must be be perfect or it must be made again. Haven’t had it yet? It’s time to Meet Your Maker.
Meet the Brothers Behind Maker Pizza: A New Montclair Restaurant
Maker Pizza, located at 171 Forest Street, Montclair, is the creation of Fahri, Mustafa, and Ahmet Demirpence. Fahri, who was studying hotel …
Reviews
Sanjana Shah
Amazing pizza in Montclair! Close to downtown and at a nice location. We got the Detroit style margherita, buratta pesto, veggie pizza and veggie stromboli, and a side of fries for the 5 of us and they were large portions. Definitely get the fries. So crispy!! The flavor was amazing, the sauce tasted so yummy. But I would say the veggie pizza felt more like a veggies dump so that could have been better. But other than that, an amazing place with wonderful owners. Will definitely come back!
… moreAztech Management
What a pleasant place! They completely remodelled the space. I came in for a few slices and decided to get a white slice and a chicken bacon ranch slice. The service was great and the staff friendly. The slices were delicious! Thin crust, not greasy, fresh! I’m so impressed. Highly recommend this gem
… moreAustin Song
I wanted to find a new pizza place in Montclair and I enjoyed their pizzas for sure over many in town.
We ordered veggie pizza which is hard to find a great one and I would def recommend their veggie. We also got classic margherita and it was good.
I loved the wings and curly fries as well!
They forgot to give us our Caesar salad and when I called, he said “don’t worry, I got you next time”
I trust their words as locals that they will follow through so I didn’t contact uber for refund. Will keep everyone posted!
… moreWe ordered veggie pizza which is hard to find a great one and I would def recommend their veggie. We also got classic margherita and it was good.
I loved the wings and curly fries as well!
They forgot to give us our Caesar salad and when I called, he said “don’t worry, I got you next time”
I trust their words as locals that they will follow through so I didn’t contact uber for refund. Will keep everyone posted!
Julia
Delicious pizza and fun different options. This is our favorite go to pizza in Montclair.
My favorite is the chicken bacon ranch and general tso. Buffalo and pepperoni is good too. Pizza is crisp and has a good thickness. I normally don’t eat crust but this one I do!
Love that they have a patio in the back to sit with dogs.
… moreMy favorite is the chicken bacon ranch and general tso. Buffalo and pepperoni is good too. Pizza is crisp and has a good thickness. I normally don’t eat crust but this one I do!
Love that they have a patio in the back to sit with dogs.
Bryan Kowacich
Wow wow and triple wow!
I can honestly say this is the best pizza I’ve ever had.
The flavors are not only perfectly balanced with utterly delicious fresh ingredients, but the pizza crust is a straight 10.
Perfect crunch on the bottom of the pizza and crispy exterior with perfection chewiness!
I’m very happy I stopped by here.
… moreI can honestly say this is the best pizza I’ve ever had.
The flavors are not only perfectly balanced with utterly delicious fresh ingredients, but the pizza crust is a straight 10.
Perfect crunch on the bottom of the pizza and crispy exterior with perfection chewiness!
I’m very happy I stopped by here.
Oktay Oz
I recently visited this maker pizza and was genuinely impressed. The dough was fresh, the toppings were high quality, and everything was cooked to perfection. The staff was friendly and attentive, and my order came out quickly even during a busy time. Definitely one of the best pizza spots in the area. Highly recommended!
… moreBenjamin Lehar
This place rocks. Lots of selections. No pork fyi but not inherently a bad thing. Really awesome NY Style pizza and other varieties including Detroit and Sicilian. They’re all good. The chicken stromboli is also good and the sauce on the side portion is great. My go to spot now. Also grab a slice of cake at the counter. Why not? Your already eating pizza!
… moreJenette Lindahl
Maker Pizza in Montclair, NJ is an absolute gem. The staff is excellent—friendly, welcoming, and always on top of their game. The pizza is consistently fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Every visit has great food and even better vibes. If you haven’t been yet, you’re truly missing out on one of Montclair’s best pizza spots. Highly recommend!
… morePhilip Schertz
We have ordered pizza from maker pizza several times before but I have to say that the pizza tonight was fabulous. We had a 16 in pizza with beef pepperoni and meatballs. We didn’t order a cooked any special way, but the crust was fabulous and delicious and the texture of the pizza, the taste of the sauce and the toppings were special. If you’re not going to this place, you’re really missing out.
… moreJosh Jones
Read about this new place in the Montclair Girl – tried out some delivery coming home from a work trip and was not disappointed. It’s hard to find Detroit style pizza in the area and they truly delivered.
Happy these guys opened up nearby and would recommend. Will be back!
… moreHappy these guys opened up nearby and would recommend. Will be back!