Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Fish | Make my fish | New York
Make My Fish is your premium sea food restaurant located in the hearth of Harlem Nyc.
Make My Fish, 1777 Central Park Ave, Yonkers, NY 10710, US
Make My Fish, located in Yonkers, NY, specializes in fresh seafood offerings. Customers can choose from a variety of fish and shellfish, which are prepared to …
Make my fish Yonkers Central Park Avenue COMING SOON …
Make my fish Yonkers Central Park Avenue COMING SOON!!! · Without the Love And support From our customers there would Be no “Make My fish” so we …
Reviews
Denise Vill
Food was delicious, management and staff were great, answering all my questions even though they were busy.
I’ve been to the Harlem location, so happy the food is equally great in Yonkers. The juice bar was a pleasant surprise, they gave some nice samples and I don’t even like juice bars usually, so there’s some healthy options opposed to the fried goodness.
We loved all our food, I got catfish, shrimp, Mac n cheese, collard greens and fries.
Tips:
– They don’t serve chicken on Friday’s
– They just opened so phone and online ordering isn’t setup yet but coming soon.
… moreI’ve been to the Harlem location, so happy the food is equally great in Yonkers. The juice bar was a pleasant surprise, they gave some nice samples and I don’t even like juice bars usually, so there’s some healthy options opposed to the fried goodness.
We loved all our food, I got catfish, shrimp, Mac n cheese, collard greens and fries.
Tips:
– They don’t serve chicken on Friday’s
– They just opened so phone and online ordering isn’t setup yet but coming soon.
Mesha B.
I tried the Yonkers location because I frequent and really enjoy the Harlem spot, so I was excited to have one closer to home.
Starting with the positives: the establishment is new, very clean, and the wait time was minimal. We ordered for four people and had our food in about 10 minutes, which was great. Packaging was fine for takeaway as well.
However, there were some issues. The ordering process felt a bit disorganized and our order was messed up. I actually overheard another customer mention their order was incorrect, but I assumed it was a one off and didn’t double check mine before leaving. I would definitely recommend checking your order before you walk out. There also doesn’t appear to be a phone number available to call if something needs to be corrected, which makes it harder to resolve issues after you leave.
We also noticed inconsistency with portions. We ordered multiple fried shrimp meals at the same price, yet everyone received a different amount of shrimp. That shouldn’t happen when customers are paying the same price.
Food wise:
Fried shrimp 7 out of 10. Fresh, good but the batter was a bit bland.
Fried fish 5 out of 10. Mostly batter.
Mac and cheese 3 out of 10. Dry, oily, heavy on salt and black pepper, and no cheese stretch.
Candied yams 5 out of 10. A safe choice.
I understand they just opened, so I’m hoping consistency improves. I genuinely want this location to do well, but for now I’ll be sticking with the Harlem location
… moreStarting with the positives: the establishment is new, very clean, and the wait time was minimal. We ordered for four people and had our food in about 10 minutes, which was great. Packaging was fine for takeaway as well.
However, there were some issues. The ordering process felt a bit disorganized and our order was messed up. I actually overheard another customer mention their order was incorrect, but I assumed it was a one off and didn’t double check mine before leaving. I would definitely recommend checking your order before you walk out. There also doesn’t appear to be a phone number available to call if something needs to be corrected, which makes it harder to resolve issues after you leave.
We also noticed inconsistency with portions. We ordered multiple fried shrimp meals at the same price, yet everyone received a different amount of shrimp. That shouldn’t happen when customers are paying the same price.
Food wise:
Fried shrimp 7 out of 10. Fresh, good but the batter was a bit bland.
Fried fish 5 out of 10. Mostly batter.
Mac and cheese 3 out of 10. Dry, oily, heavy on salt and black pepper, and no cheese stretch.
Candied yams 5 out of 10. A safe choice.
I understand they just opened, so I’m hoping consistency improves. I genuinely want this location to do well, but for now I’ll be sticking with the Harlem location
Jeff Brown
Delicious and Fresh! Very Fast service despite long lines from grand opening. Sides were amazing, shrimp and fish were crisp and flavorful.
… moreVikki Licona-Gomez
Best fried fish and shrimp! Seasoned and cooked perfectly. Yams were absolutely delicious too. It was packed but the wait isn’t terribly long. Will be back soon!
… moreTakisha Wilson
I had the fried whitings with the side of mac and cheese fish was okay the mac and cheese was too salty and too oily… The atmosphere of the place was very nice customer service was excellent… Next time I will try the juices
… moreMin. Jamel C Peterson
Would have given this place 7 stars!!! I love Make My Fish…. But today, they made my fish, but not my day. They forgot some sides, my 2 drinks, and don’t have any space where you can stop and peek at your food to ensure everything’s there. FRUSTRATING! No love lost tho! They were super busy, which was great!! I’m definitely going back, and highly recommend! But ya gotta check your food- stop somewhere and make sure.
… moreDev Web
Decided to try out this new spot today, as it was recommended by a relative. I got the Whiting Fish Dinner w/ Mac & Cheese & Candied Yams. Waited about 30 mins for the food, but wasn’t too bothered as I got the chance to taste test a couple smoothies and juices while I waited.
Okay, so here’s the good news. The seasoning and flavors were on point! Everything tasted great. Not too salty or sweet. Dare I say seasoned to perfection.
And now, the bad news. The Mac & Cheese was a bit oily, and the noodles were separated from the cheese, so the dish didn’t feel cohesive to me. No indicator of a cheese sauce or any sign that it was baked, so that wasn’t great.
The Candied Yams were edible, but didn’t have that softness or slight mushiness you get from cooking the yams in the sauce long enough. It was just a bit undercooked. Had it been cooked for a bit longer, the flavor would’ve been stronger and stuck to the yams better. Maybe a bit more brown sugar, honey or vanilla could’ve made that flavor pop.
And finally the fish. I really loved how light & airy the breading was. And while flakey, the fish was a bit too thin so the breading to fish ratio was super off. More breading than fish for sure. I would’ve rather had 3 pieces of regular fried fish filets than 6 pieces of thinly sliced fried fish filets.
Overall, there’s definitely potential for this location to be as good as the Harlem one (I’ve never been there, but existing reviews suggest that many love that location). Just gotta work on the way the food is actually prepared.
… moreOkay, so here’s the good news. The seasoning and flavors were on point! Everything tasted great. Not too salty or sweet. Dare I say seasoned to perfection.
And now, the bad news. The Mac & Cheese was a bit oily, and the noodles were separated from the cheese, so the dish didn’t feel cohesive to me. No indicator of a cheese sauce or any sign that it was baked, so that wasn’t great.
The Candied Yams were edible, but didn’t have that softness or slight mushiness you get from cooking the yams in the sauce long enough. It was just a bit undercooked. Had it been cooked for a bit longer, the flavor would’ve been stronger and stuck to the yams better. Maybe a bit more brown sugar, honey or vanilla could’ve made that flavor pop.
And finally the fish. I really loved how light & airy the breading was. And while flakey, the fish was a bit too thin so the breading to fish ratio was super off. More breading than fish for sure. I would’ve rather had 3 pieces of regular fried fish filets than 6 pieces of thinly sliced fried fish filets.
Overall, there’s definitely potential for this location to be as good as the Harlem one (I’ve never been there, but existing reviews suggest that many love that location). Just gotta work on the way the food is actually prepared.
Nicole Goldson
I’ve been here 2x and each time the food, service and wait time have been excellent ! The food was seasoned well and they give you a large portion! I had the shrimp and catfish combo, cornbread. I was shocked at how large the pieces of catfish were. I also had the half and half drink. No complaints! 10/10. Everyone behind the register was was very nice and patient when and when it was handed off to me . I’ve never waited more then 15 min. I want to try their juice bar next.
… moreJonathan Nateesri
So glad to see this Harlem staple open a location in Yonkers! I stopped by recently and the experience was excellent from start to finish.
The food is the real deal. I ordered the all whiting, all catfish, and the shrimp. The seasoning is fantastic and the texture is perfectly crisp. The catfish portions are huge, and while the shrimp has a hearty seasoning and breading, the freshness and sweetness of the shrimp still shine through.
For sides, the candied yams were sweet and tender, a perfect contrast to the savory fried seafood and the mac and cheese was delicious.
The service was quick, the prices are very fair, and the staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming. It’s a great addition to the neighborhood and I’m happy to support a business that clearly takes pride in what they do.
… moreThe food is the real deal. I ordered the all whiting, all catfish, and the shrimp. The seasoning is fantastic and the texture is perfectly crisp. The catfish portions are huge, and while the shrimp has a hearty seasoning and breading, the freshness and sweetness of the shrimp still shine through.
For sides, the candied yams were sweet and tender, a perfect contrast to the savory fried seafood and the mac and cheese was delicious.
The service was quick, the prices are very fair, and the staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming. It’s a great addition to the neighborhood and I’m happy to support a business that clearly takes pride in what they do.
Chenelle Lewis
Lived in Harlem so familiar with the place and was excited to see one up in Yonkers. I only ordered a fish sandwich. It was overdone and dark. Not many soft pieces. Even though they gave me five pieces of fish, they were super tiny, thin, and overly crispy so really not edible. I might give them another try and order something different to see if that was just a fluke. We shall see.
… more