Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Limited reservations available. No openings listed? Walk-ins are always welcome! Magnolias is a cocktail bar that brings timeless cocktail culture to Bay Shore. Known for impeccable martinis, elevated small plates, and hospitality that makes every guest feel like a regular. Our menu features timeless cocktails crafted with precision, spirit-forward creations, and a fresh raw bar designed for sharing. The atmosphere is upscale but approachable—perfect for after-work drinks, date nights, or lingering with friends. Located in the heart of Bay Shore, Magnolias is a community gathering spot where classic cocktail culture meets modern hospitality. Join us for martinis, oysters, and an evening that feels effortlessly refined.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 52 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Phone: (631) 980-2714
Website: https://www.magnoliasbayshore.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Related Web Results
Magnolias | Cocktails & Eclectic Bites
Timeless cocktail in Bay Shore, NY — a cocktail bar serving handcrafted drinks and eclectic bites. Perfect for date nights, happy hour, or late-night vibes.
Magnolias – Bay Shore (@magnoliasbayshore) – Instagram
Bay Shore’s Martini Destination Classic Cocktails · Elevated Bites 52 E Main St Bay Shore, NY 11706 ⏰ Open Tuesday – Sunday …
Magnolias Restaurant – Bay Shore, NY | OpenTable
Magnolias, a Manhattan-inspired martini-forward cocktail bar, has opened in Bay Shore at the former King’s Chophouse. The menu features eclectic small bites, a …
Reviews
Seana Kelly
The service here is fantastic! We had reservations and were seated quickly. The host kindly gave us a quick rundown of the menu and specials while we waited for our server. Our server then greeted us with welcome drinks, we had the Pineapple Express which was delicious and inspired my partner to order it. We also tried the “Fancy” Vodka Soda which was great. To start, we ordered the Shrimp Cocktail and the Bourbon BBQ wings, which both came out looking (and ended up being) so yummy that I didn’t even get a chance to snap a pic before we dug in. For mains we got the Chophouse burger and the French Dip served with au jus, horseradish mayo, and ketchup for the chips. The food was absolutely delicious! Everything was fresh, hot, and flavorful. The great reviews are well deserved and we will 100% be coming back here.
… moreFrank Todarello
Such a great new place! Food, service and staff were all 5 stars! Wife and I LOVED the food and drinks! The cocktails we got were the Caprese Martini, Egg-spresso Martini, Autumnal-Gròni, and the Lucky Duck. All 5 stars!! The food we got was the Seared Tuna Steak, the Chili Crisp Brussels Fried Rice and the Black Pepper Bourbon BBQ wings (as an app). All 5 out of 5. Go! Enjoy!
We just went back and enjoyed two more cocktails; the Hot and Dirty Martini and Stifler’s Mom! Both amazing! To eat we loved the Flat Iron Steak and the Crispy Buttermilk Chicken! 5/5 for everything
… moreWe just went back and enjoyed two more cocktails; the Hot and Dirty Martini and Stifler’s Mom! Both amazing! To eat we loved the Flat Iron Steak and the Crispy Buttermilk Chicken! 5/5 for everything
J V
Stopped in Magnolias on a whim and we were so Happy we did. Greeted with a welcome drink while we decided what we wanted to order. The cocktails are fantastic, Joey was our server and he was amazing! Guided us with our orders and was very patient and fun with two undecided girls. The Fried olives are a must and the Pineapple was to die for. Can’t wait to visit again and try more. A wonderful addition to Bay Shore
… moreJoe B
We had a great experience at magnolias during restaurant week. 3 course meal for 46.00. Everything from apps to dessert was great. I ordered the caprese martini. Taste like just that: mozzarella tomato and basil, it wasn’t my favorite but not the worst. The regular menu had lots to order from as well. The oysters were very good! I Highly recommend going here. Connor our server was excellent.
… moreNatalie D’Ambrosio
Stopped in on a Sunday afternoon and loved the vibe. The drinks were great. Only had the burrata but it was delish. The bartenders were so friendly and cool. Loved hanging out and chatting. Will definitely be a regular spot for me and my girls!
… morePaul Laska
Probably the best “date night” spot in Bayshore. Cocktails are out of this world and there’s so much variety. Joe the manager was super attentive and involved. Connor our waiter was incredibly knowledgeable! The food is absolutely amazing. Had the buttermilk chicken and my gf had the steak. Was shocked this came from a cocktail bar kitchen. The wings are a SLEEPER don’t miss out!!!
… morestacey
Appetizers were good. Baked clams. Tuna sliders and oysters. We ordered for entree lobster tail over risotto. Very Disappointed. Not edible. So salty. And baked gnocchi with lobster also salty. I never write reviews but i feel they should know. Waitress was attentive at first but it took forever to get drinks and constantly had to ask for water. Nice atmosphere.
… moreSophia Worst
Joey, Kayla, Dani and Connor are truly so good at what they do. The food is fantastic, the cocktails are amazing, and the service is top notch. I have loved every bar and dining experience at magnolias. It is definitely worth the visit 🙂
… moreJennifer
Went with one of my friends for the first time the other night, and absolutely love the place! cute and quaint. The drinks and food was absolutely to die for and over all service was great. We’ll definitely be doing another girls night there again soon!
… moreJake Leone
I’m rarely ever pushed to make a public review but I had the most amazing experience. Service was amazing and went the extra mile to be descriptive and knowledgeable. I had the gorgonzola filet special and i’ve never had a steak so perfectly at temperature even at steakhouses in the area. So happy to have this option in the area.
… more