Hours
| Thursday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–9 PM |
Menu
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Magic’s Pizza Shack | Selah WA – Facebook
Magic’s Pizza Shack, Selah, Washington. 746 likes · 3 talking about this · 625 were here. Owner – Sherry Raymond.
Online Menu of Magic’s Pizza Shack, Selah, WA
View the menu for Magic’s Pizza Shack and restaurants in Selah, WA. See restaurant menus, reviews, ratings, phone number, address, hours, photos and maps.
Magic’s Pizza Shack menu – Selah WA 98942 – (877) 585-1085
Magic’s Pizza Shack · Ham and Turkey Sandwich $3.50+ · Roast Sandwich $3.50+ · Grilled Turkey, Bacon and Swiss Cheese sandwich $4.30+ · Italian Caesar sandwich …
Reviews
Shannon lobdell
It’s a nice little place I just don’t like the flavor of the sauce they use on the pizza and the thin crusts but it’s still a good pizza place and the ppl are really nice and friendly and so is the atmosphere. They also have a few arcade games and I’m always a sucker for places like that =) they serve Pepsi which is a plus in my book and they also have a salad bar. I also had breakfast there and that was very good as well!! Fresh and of course made to order the chief cooked my eggs perfect and you get 4 pieces of toast instead of just 2 sounds silly but that definitely made my day.
… moreJamie Smith
This place is known for its salad bar & it was the worst salad bar I have ever seen. No bacon bits. I’ve never seen that before. No bacon bits. Nobody cared. Just took my money.
… morejames spafford
Normally I call across the street for ease of the menu, but tonight decided on something different. I ordered a pie and some spaghetti and settled in for the evening. The service was completely out of this world and the pizza, though a bit on the salty side was great!!! The spaghetti was definitely exceptional as well!!! I read in the reviews that some had complained about the flavor of the spaghetti, well, for $8 you’re not eating at the Osteria Francescana!!! I’ve paid twice that much, gotten half the size, and wished I’d settled for a can of Campbells Spaghetti O’s!!! The Fat Man will definitely be back!!!
… moreKyle
Breakfast at a pizza place?! It was excellent & the menu is fairly diversified. Anything from pancakes to biscuits & gravy. We got the breakfast pizza (egg, sausage, ham, & bacon with gravy as the pizza sauce) & the country Benedict (eggs your choice served over a sausage patty & biscuits with a side of hash browns). We also got a mimosa & bloody Mary. Everything came out hot & fresh. Our server Annie was super nice & made sure we were taken care of.
… morefabian cantu
Great pizza and very nice staff! A pregnant woman was serving us and she was so incredibly sweet! Thank you to this server!!!!
… moreAshley Heether
Was my 1st time here. Asked to get a salad, I was told there was only small and large. Got the large and was charged almost $15. Another person in my group got a small salad for $9. Someone else in the group was offered all you can eat salad bar for $13. I’m unsure if it was the staff that didn’t know what was available and how much or a lack of training.
… moreMandy Pink
The magic must have fizzled out at Magic’s Pizza Shack because there was nothing magical about it. I ordered 2 spaghetti’s with bread and 1 with added salad using Uber Eats. I didn’t get my salad which was an extra 4.25. I called and they said they couldn’t see the salad part on the ticket. I wrote in notes to add dressing for the salad. They saw the dressing part but couldn’t see the 4.00 price difference? Or give a ring and ask? I’m not from here nor do I have an available vehicle at this time to go get a salad so I’m just SOL. Save your money and go to the store to buy spaghetti ingredients. There is absolutely nothing magical or special about their spaghetti. Tastes like it came straight from a cafeteria; bland and boring. Their bread was literally one half of a soggy small hoagie bun. The servings are small for what you pay. Didn’t try the pizza but probably wouldn’t ever just from poor customer service and not-so-magical spaghetti.
… moreMichael Antoldi
The pizza portion size was great. The taste however was subpar and cheese was not great. Garlic cheese bread had barely any garlic and tasted cheap. Would not recommend
… moreScott Brusaw
Pizza was good. They actually have a salad bar. Also had my favorite beer on tap. Service was great. Reasonably priced.
… moreGhost Rogue Adventures
Great pizza and fast delivery! The young man who delivered was polite and professional. Will eat here again when we come back for softball next year.
… more