Social Profile: 
![]()
… View more
Landmark dessert spot dishing up housemade ice cream in traditional & custom flavors, plus cakes.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Magic Fountain – Where Ice Cream Dreams Come True!
Magic Fountain – Mattituck, NY | 9825 Main Road. Call us at 631-298-4908. Skip to content. Magic Fountain. Home · About · Flavors · Contact · Join Our Team …
Magic Fountain – Mattituck, NY
Serves approximately 6-8. All pre-made cakes are vanilla and chocolate with chocolate crunchies in the middle.
Magic Fountain | Mattituck NY – Facebook
Magic Fountain, Mattituck. 4408 likes · 109 talking about this · 6776 were here. Homemade ice cream store located in Mattituck, NY on the north fork of…
Reviews
Tina H
I finally got to try this ice cream spot! I passed it so many times and the line has always been so looonnnngggg! The lines moves quickly. Everyone is happy and friendly as who isn’t when they are about to indulge in ice cream. Lots of choices. Try a sample if u r not sure. But not too many…I witnessed this woman on her fourth “try” . Really yummy treat! U won’t b disappointed
… moreFeed My Wife
Did you know this spot use to be a Dairy Queen? All the way back in 1977. Love that it has turned into a long running mom and pop shop. It is certainly a staple in the community – with a line around the block! They’ve got some eclectic flavors – like kulfi, goat cheese, vegan options and no sugar added options.
Skip the toppings, the star lost was for the stale topping – so just skip it. Because the ice cream is the star of the show and was a good consistency and sweetness.
Check them out!
… moreSkip the toppings, the star lost was for the stale topping – so just skip it. Because the ice cream is the star of the show and was a good consistency and sweetness.
Check them out!
Jeneane Solz
This ice cream is staple to our north fork visits! They have awesome and creative flavors of hard ice cream, but don’t sleep on their soft serve which is so creamy and delicious!
… moreWilliam “Will” Montolio
Worth the hype. The flavors are usually bold and not subtle. Excellent service. You get three free tastes to help you select from their massive list of flavors.
… moreBianca Dvorsky
I will be dreaming of their Chocolate Cherry Bourbon ice cream. They can get very busy, but they have a nice system in place to help. They move very quickly, so you shouldn’t be waiting too long 🙂
… moreSkylar Bachisin
They have a wide range of delicious and creative homemade ice cream flavors! My favorites include red velvet and cake mix! The staff had always been friendly and helpful!
… moreMagnets and Memories
Delicious chocolate malted, so many ice cream flavors and really nice staff!
… moreStephen Pratel Sr.
Best, ice cream on the North fork!
This place has been here since the ’70s or as long as I can remember.
Very proud of the fact in 1979 when to make your own Sunday fad with a bunch of different toppings you could add was new, I invented (or so I believe in my own little world ) the Oreo shake when I asked them to put a couple tablespoons of the crushed Oreo toppings into my soft serve milkshake. The lady working the counter looked at me like I was crazy but I talked her into it. Then when I was home visiting during college I saw they had it on their menu
Anyhow, it’s wonderful to see this place still open and doing great business. If you’re out on the East end or North fork, come to Mattituck and enjoy this local treasure.
… moreThis place has been here since the ’70s or as long as I can remember.
Very proud of the fact in 1979 when to make your own Sunday fad with a bunch of different toppings you could add was new, I invented (or so I believe in my own little world ) the Oreo shake when I asked them to put a couple tablespoons of the crushed Oreo toppings into my soft serve milkshake. The lady working the counter looked at me like I was crazy but I talked her into it. Then when I was home visiting during college I saw they had it on their menu
Anyhow, it’s wonderful to see this place still open and doing great business. If you’re out on the East end or North fork, come to Mattituck and enjoy this local treasure.
Anna-Kaye Rowe
Love this ice cream shop. It’s the perfect place for a treat, they have so many yummy flavors. On my most recent trip I tried the almond joy and hazelnut biscotti. 10/10!
… moreKaritas Mitrogogos
This place has a great variety of really nice homemade ice cream and sorbet … in perhaps too many flavors as I had a really hard time deciding what I wanted to taste!
The service was friendly and helpful, and the prices reflected the high quality of the ice cream.
I’m pretty sure I’ll go back for more …. pretty soon.
… moreThe service was friendly and helpful, and the prices reflected the high quality of the ice cream.
I’m pretty sure I’ll go back for more …. pretty soon.