Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 17 North Ave, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569
Phone: (845) 635-9500
Website: http://www.madisonspizzacafe.com/!contact-madisons-pizza-cafe/cyha
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Madison’s Pizza Cafe – Pleasant Valley
Catering · Special Events · Children’s Pizza Party · About · Online Ordering · Madison’s Pizza Cafe Home. 17 North Avenue, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 (845) …
Menus | Madison’s Pizza Cafe in Pleasant Valley, NY
Everyday Special. Large Cheese Pie, 2 Orders of Boneless Wings, and a 2 Liter of Soda $31.95. Cocktails; Catering Menu; Special Events Menu; Pizza …
Catering Menu | Madison’s Pizza Cafe
Madison’s Pizza Cafe Home. 17 North Avenue, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 (845) 635-9500. Toggle Navigation. Hours & Location · Menus; Catering & Special Events.
Reviews
Niki Ashmawy
We always stop here if we’re passing through town. The dough is soft and pillowy and has a nice crust. Nicely seasoned. We usually get the Upside Down pizza which is the best pizza I’ve ever tasted(showed in pic) and a couple slices out of the case. Slices are huge.
… moreJames Leatherman
I haven’t had a slice yet that wasn’t amazing. I lived in the Bronx for years, and this is the closest I have had to real New York pizza this far out of the city. We have had the margherita, sausage, meatball and onion, buffalo chicken, and stuffed slices and each one of them were outstanding. Also tried the lobster bisque and it too was perfect.
… moreRobin Harbold
Madison’s has been my family’s “go to” for pizza since they first opened. A great place too, for a dependable good meal out, in a comfortable setting with great friendly service. Jason, Madeline and their amazing staff recently catered my daughters’ wedding. They helped to make the day incredible. No surprise that the food was great (it always is), but the way they went above and beyond in every aspect was truly remarkable, helping with planning and making important suggestions beyond the food aspect. During cocktail hour, there was no searching or chasing after wait staff for — they were always there, and assured that the bride, groom & bridal party had hors d’oeuvres brought to them during pictures so they missed nothing. Dinner was plentiful and delicious. Jay, Madeline, family and staff, THANK YOU!!!!
… moreGloria Marrero
The pizza is great, but please do yourself a favor and try their other foods. I personally love their lobster bisque and their shrimp scampi. YUMMMM!
… moreEvan Baright
Austin is the best delivery driver we HAVE EVER had, request him every time you won’t be disappointed.
… moretommy greico
This place has the best pizza around , definitely give them a try
… moreDiesel tech Farm.
9.9 out of 10 times the food is always on point and perfect. Every once in a while I might get a dish that isn’t quite up to the normal standards, but the family at Madisons is always willing to take care of it right away and either make me a new plate or comp my meal. The online ordering is great and delivery is always on time. The prices are still what I would consider on the lower scale considering the economy. The portions are gigantic. I can usually get 2 to 3 meals out of one dinner portion. I’ve lived in Pleasant Valley for 40 years and there have been numerous pizzerias, this has by far been one of the best ones my whole entire time living here!
… moreChristopher Borden
What a great experience here! Had a recommendation from a friend to stop in for a quick lunch with some colleagues. I ordered the chicken parm with Vodka Sauce. It was baked to perfection and the sauce was also quite tasty. They were able to accommodate a large party quickly and get us on the move again. The staff was super friendly and on point. The price was right on the money. If you happen to be nearby and are looking for something scrumptious, don’t hesitate to give this establishment a try. You won’t regret it!
… moreMister Personality
Great pizza and always seen this restaurant clean. They are affordable too.
… moreCindy Bury
Been going to Madison’s for 11 years now. #1 in Pleasant Valley.
… more