Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Casual NY Style Pizzeria serving Slices, Salads, Pastas, Heros, Wraps, Soups, Oven Baked Dishes, Classic Chicken, Veal, Eggplant & Seafood Dishes, Desserts, and of course a large assortment of hand crafted specialty pies or build your own. Delivery-Take Out-Catering. Beer & Wine Served. Fast and easy to use ONLINE Ordering system for delivery and pick up orders.
Hours
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1372 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733
Phone: (631) 751-3400
Website: http://icraveluigis.com/setauket/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Setauket – Luigis Pizza
Tel: (631) 751-3400 · 1372 RT. 25A Easte Setauket, NY 11733. Copyright © 2019 | All rights reserved. Designed with by MazeMedia · AccountREWARDS; CALL US; Order …
Luigi’s Pizzeria of East Setauket – Facebook
Luigi’s Pizzeria of East Setauket, East Setauket. 449 likes · 1 talking about this · 409 were here. Casual NY Style Pizzeria serving Slices, Salads,…
Luigi’s Pizzeria of East Setauket Delivery Menu | Order Online |
Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings! $25.05. 16″ – Large Cheese Pizza …
Last Updates
Reviews
Dylan Smith
luigis has become our Friday night go-to. pizza is solid, nice soft knots, reasonable prices, generous rewards program and online ordering that doesn’t suck. AND they support the community – they’re running a fundraiser that supports my daughters elementary school. happy to have this place in my town
… moreruff xm
We typically use two pizza places as our go-to and Luigi’s is one of them. I’ll share some realistic aspects of Luigi’s. In transparency, we do not typically order dishes from Luigi’s and use them mainly for pizza.
Firstly, I ignore any review based on delivery (door dash, grub hub, etc.). Once it leaves the restaurant it’s out of their hands. And besides, delivery usually takes time and the pizza and other items sit in a box or container and steam and get soggy. But I know lazy people will never give up delivery – enjoy your steamy mush.
Secondly, you have to be discerning in what you order – Look at the specialty slice pizzas in the showcase. Yes, sometimes certain types of slices will sit there for hours and dry up a little. You can always try putting your phone down and having a human-style conversation and politely state “this one looks a little old, can you add sausage to a new slice?”. I’m sure they’ll accommodate, although this can’t be done with certain specialty slices like mac-and-cheese, penne vodka, salad slices, etc.
I think it would be nice if counter staff would be a little more friendly. Some are very transactional and cut and dry…It can come across as feeling like you’re just an order and not a customer. This is a simple matter of training and selecting the right person for the job, although I understand good service-oriented employees are not easy to find these days.
Their slices are normal to large in size. I’ve noticed plain cheese slices are fairly large. There’s a cute attempt by another review pointing out the “smaller pizza sizes”. Sometimes when a whole pizza is cut, it’s rushed and not done perfectly symmetrical – resulting in smaller slices than others. This is not an issue when ordering a whole pie, as you are getting the whole pie. I’m referencing the review with a picture of her hand next to a very small slice, when other larger slices are in the picture. A reasonable person can see the cuts were simply not done as equally as they should be. This is not indicative of the overall pizza size, but nice try.
Overall, Luigi’s is a respectable pizzeria that turns out some good pizza. Like most pizzerias, it’s always best to order fresh. It remains as one of our top 2 pizzerias in the area. Anyone saying they are “the worst” is clearly exaggerating. This is why I write reviews – to provide a touch of reality and balance to the the drama reviewers.
… moreFirstly, I ignore any review based on delivery (door dash, grub hub, etc.). Once it leaves the restaurant it’s out of their hands. And besides, delivery usually takes time and the pizza and other items sit in a box or container and steam and get soggy. But I know lazy people will never give up delivery – enjoy your steamy mush.
Secondly, you have to be discerning in what you order – Look at the specialty slice pizzas in the showcase. Yes, sometimes certain types of slices will sit there for hours and dry up a little. You can always try putting your phone down and having a human-style conversation and politely state “this one looks a little old, can you add sausage to a new slice?”. I’m sure they’ll accommodate, although this can’t be done with certain specialty slices like mac-and-cheese, penne vodka, salad slices, etc.
I think it would be nice if counter staff would be a little more friendly. Some are very transactional and cut and dry…It can come across as feeling like you’re just an order and not a customer. This is a simple matter of training and selecting the right person for the job, although I understand good service-oriented employees are not easy to find these days.
Their slices are normal to large in size. I’ve noticed plain cheese slices are fairly large. There’s a cute attempt by another review pointing out the “smaller pizza sizes”. Sometimes when a whole pizza is cut, it’s rushed and not done perfectly symmetrical – resulting in smaller slices than others. This is not an issue when ordering a whole pie, as you are getting the whole pie. I’m referencing the review with a picture of her hand next to a very small slice, when other larger slices are in the picture. A reasonable person can see the cuts were simply not done as equally as they should be. This is not indicative of the overall pizza size, but nice try.
Overall, Luigi’s is a respectable pizzeria that turns out some good pizza. Like most pizzerias, it’s always best to order fresh. It remains as one of our top 2 pizzerias in the area. Anyone saying they are “the worst” is clearly exaggerating. This is why I write reviews – to provide a touch of reality and balance to the the drama reviewers.
Brendon O’Sullivan
I’ve tried so many different spots on the island throughout my life, and i can’t believe i had never tried Luigi’s. Their pizza is just classic LI pizza, and I don’t understand the one-star reviews. The amount of sauce is perfection, and the crust is nice and light. I have some best friends who live out-of-state. When they visit, we’re going here.
… morestephen erato
My first time here stopped in for a slice. I got a regular wit garlic knot crust it was excellent. I want to go back and try the food what i saw looked good.
… moreLevi N
This pizza is absolutely horrendous. This is the most un edible pizza in the setauket area. 4/5 times the pizza is burnt, stale or lacks flavor. I was at the moment when almost nobody was at the pizzeria, and the pizza still came burnt. This shows the lack of effort and laziness of the employees. I do not recommend going here unless you’re desperate for over priced, low effort, burnt, and tasteless pizza. I would recommend avoiding this place there are so many more better options within a 10 minute drive.
… moreNatalia Ilina
It was delicious pizza for our party. I liked the pizza with pineapple, I’m not sure about the name because I didn’t place the order, but it looks a lot like Hawaiian Pizza (pizza sauce, cheese, cooked ham, and pineapple).
All pizzas were delivered on time in good condition and we ate everything quickly.
… moreAll pizzas were delivered on time in good condition and we ate everything quickly.
S WR
Delicious vegan pizza! Delivered on time and still hot! Courteous friendly driver and easy online ordering! Will be buying again and recommending!
… morePb Jelly
The big blonde girl is very nasty and has no professionalism she also adds her tip onto the credit cards onto of the additional credit cards fee. When I asked for the receipt it said TIP 15% with the price at the counter. Be leary of the shady dealings going on here. There are definitely extra charges on your bill. Be aware I tried to post the pic of the receipt but it’s not posting
… moreAlyona Gismondi
Ordered from this pizza shop and had my pizza delivered in this horrible condition !!! Was my FIRST time ordering from them and it will be my last.
… moreVicky Jones
I used to go to Luigi’s years ago. I came back to LI for a wedding and took my grown children to a “real” pizza parlor, cuz VA does not know what real pizza is. They were blown away and I wanted to move back to LI the next day. I gotta come back up when I have time to kill and eat some of your pizza again.
… more