Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Unassuming local chain eatery serving up thin-crust pizza, plus calzones, subs & salads.
Hours
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2770 S 25th E, Idaho Falls, ID 83404
Phone: (208) 523-7777
Website: https://www.lucysnypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria
Lucy’s New York Style Pizza! View Menu. Roberts Lucy’s storefront. Big City … 2770 S 25th E, Idaho Falls, ID 83404. Open now • Closes at 10PM. All hours.
Order Online – Lucys NY Pizza
Order Online from Lucy’s NY Pizza. Get the best prices and service when ordering directly … 560 W Broadway St., Idaho Falls, ID 83402. Closed • Opens Monday at …
Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria – IDAHO FALLS – Facebook
. 86% recommend (484 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 560 W Broadway St, Idaho Falls, ID, United States, 83402. . Idaho Falls, ID. Links. . lucysnypizza.
Reviews
Micheal Newsom
I walked in and was instantly given a table. The place smells like great food, and everything is so clean. The waitresses would come by and ask if there was anything we needed, and they weren’t overly present. The food was quick and so delicious. My favorite eatery in town
… moreKatie Terry
You just earned yourself a lifetime customer. Cozy vibe inside, kids had a blast with the markers on the table. Awsome way to keep them distracted. But the thing that got me to write a review…the box for my left overs. you guys have a sense of humor and I’m here for it!
… moreJessi shaw
Id give it 10 stars. The classic atmosphere of an old fashioned sit down pizza restaurant. Quarter prize and sticker machines at the front for the kids. They offer dry erase markers for the kids to draw on the metal tables while you wait for your food. The pizza was amazing, the dough had such a nice flavor and texture, soft bubbly with a slight fire roasted char. Just good homemade food and not the quick cookie cutter pizzas of big chains. Now the wings…. these are EXACTLY how wings are meant to be served, hot, crispy, fresh and loaded with sauce. I havnt had wings this good in a very long time. The buffalo sauce was a unique type of sauce that if my taste buds are correct is made using an Italian dressing in lue of butter. My family and i had such a great experience and cant wait to make this our new family staple.
… moreNoah Lloyd
I had gotten a gift certificate in the mail for a pizza here. My wife and I love to do pizza Fridays so we thought why not try a free pizza here. WE LOVED IT. It was a lot bigger than I thought it was going to be. The taste was very v good and it was a nice good NY style pizza. Definitely want to try different flavors of pizza here. Will come again and recommend this for anyone looking for a good local pizza place.
… moreGabby Joliet
Love their pizza and so does my picky family. I love love that they have so many options from baked pizza to take&bake to their pre-made dough balls. Their maranara sauce is delish and we appreciate their $5 off deal on Mondays. I’d highly recommend Lucy’s!!!
… moreFMV obsession
Has always delivered reliable pizza. Love the $2 slice deals. The appetizers are great. I’d never considered appetizers before eating pizza before, but now I need them. Love that they offer soda in a 2 liter!
… moreKatie Comstock
Mackenzie took such great care of us! So kind and great with our group of kids. They loved her. Food is always good. Love taking our family here for the half price slices for lunch.
… moreChristine Thorne
We have ordered Lucy’s pizza 2x now. The pizza is beyond delicious! We also ordered wings this last time and they were also good. We ordered honey garlic & med buffalo. We also ordered two pizzas. One with ham & sausage & one with pepperoni & mushrooms. Both were just delicious! Will be a regular place for us to order from!!
… moreJ Cavness
This is the second time dining here and it will be the last. I ordered a 12” meat lovers pizza and “firesticks” as an appetizer.
The pizza crust was soft and spongy and the meat tasted freezer burned.
I arrived over an hour before closing time and most tables already had chairs on top of them and the staff seemed unconcerned about customer service.
I usually do not leave negative reviews but after spending over $30 for a meal that was this terrible, I feel compelled to warn others who think they are purchasing “New York style” pizza that this is not, in my opinion, anything close to “New York style” pizza.
… moreThe pizza crust was soft and spongy and the meat tasted freezer burned.
I arrived over an hour before closing time and most tables already had chairs on top of them and the staff seemed unconcerned about customer service.
I usually do not leave negative reviews but after spending over $30 for a meal that was this terrible, I feel compelled to warn others who think they are purchasing “New York style” pizza that this is not, in my opinion, anything close to “New York style” pizza.
Wayne Austad
Great tasting pizza, fun server McKenzie! Was perfect meal before movies. GLUTEN FREE options are very helpful. Love the Parmesan/Chili seasoned olives as appetizer.
… more