Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
FYI: White Claw is not the same as Carbliss.
Three stars is the lowest review I will give. I’m being generous right now. My husband & I stopped in today at 6³⁰; there were 4 bartenders on a pretty low-volume day, about 20 customers. We waited 10 minutes before a bartender came to take our order. 10 minutes. In those 10 minutes, 3 bartenders walked past us, and 3 bartenders made eye contact with us from behind the bar. Finally, we saw one bartender talk to another regarding us, as she was staring right at us at the time. Before the bartender came to our table, she stopped at another table to check in on them. Finally, we were asked what we’d like to order. I ordered a Black Cherry Carbliss. When she came back to the table, she said they were out of BCC but offered a BC White Claw. Uhh…NOT equivalent, thanks. The bartender then turned to walk away, even though we both had closed menus in front of us (and I’m certain they saw the menus opened, previously). I had to stop her and ask if we could place an order.
I ordered a Rueben wrap, vs sandwich. It was tiny in comparison (I’ve ordered the Reuben before). It was very void of meat and cost an extra $1 for a wrap.
When the bartender came to ask how our food was, she started walking away without asking if we wanted another drink; we’ve now been here for an hour. I addressed the drink before she walked away.
Previously, we had great experiences here…tonight is a game changer. We will try again to see if this is the new norm. I’m hoping this is this bartenders first day at such a job and not indicative of how Lucy’s is doing business these days.… more… View more
Welcome to Lucy’s Hideaway, a cozy bar & grill nestled in the heart of Milton, WI. Founded with a passion for serving delicious food and creating a warm, inviting atmosphere, Lucy’s Hideaway is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. Our menu features a variety of mouthwatering dishes from appetizers to salads and soups, ensuring there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you’re looking to dine-in or grab some takeout, our friendly staff is here to provide exceptional service. Join us at Lucy’s Hideaway for a memorable dining experience and unwind with a great meal and a drink in our charming bar and restaurant.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–2 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5847 County Hwy N, Milton, WI 53563
Phone: (608) 868-5829
Website: https://lucyshideawaywi.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Lucy’s Hideaway – Milton, WI
Welcome to Lucy’s Hideaway, a cozy bar & grill nestled in the heart of Milton, WI. Founded with a passion for serving delicious food and creating a warm, …
Lucy’s Hideaway | Milton WI – Facebook
Lucy’s Hideaway, Milton. 6631 likes · 90 talking about this · 8708 were here. Lucy’s Hideaway located at 5847 E. County Road N, Milton, Wisconsin…
Lucy’s Hideaway | Milton WI – Facebook
Lucy’s Hideaway, Milton. 6621 likes · 231 talking about this · 8706 were here. Lucy’s Hideaway located at 5847 E. County Road N, Milton, Wisconsin…
Reviews
Brandon Brabender
Solid local spot for great bar food, drinks, & service. Definitely will be back!
… moreAmanda Brewer
My husband and I hadn’t been to Lucy’s in awhile so we decided to stop in for a fish fry on Friday night. It was absolutely packed but we found a seat right away. Our Server greeted us immediately and we had drinks in minutes. The old fashioned was good. My husband ordered the blue gill and I ordered the walleye. Both were reasonably priced and delicious. The Walleye was huge and you get a nice amount of blue gills. Our server was very attentive wish I knew her name to give her credit. Only complaint I had is it was so loud in there my husband and I couldn’t hear each other ( I’m not that old it was just very loud…lol) and the food took awhile but thats to be expected on Friday night and it came out hot and fresh. We will definitely be back again.
… moreEimee Izthachu
FYI: White Claw is not the same as Carbliss.
Three stars is the lowest review I will give. I’m being generous right now. My husband & I stopped in today at 6³⁰; there were 4 bartenders on a pretty low-volume day, about 20 customers. We waited 10 minutes before a bartender came to take our order. 10 minutes. In those 10 minutes, 3 bartenders walked past us, and 3 bartenders made eye contact with us from behind the bar. Finally, we saw one bartender talk to another regarding us, as she was staring right at us at the time. Before the bartender came to our table, she stopped at another table to check in on them. Finally, we were asked what we’d like to order. I ordered a Black Cherry Carbliss. When she came back to the table, she said they were out of BCC but offered a BC White Claw. Uhh…NOT equivalent, thanks. The bartender then turned to walk away, even though we both had closed menus in front of us (and I’m certain they saw the menus opened, previously). I had to stop her and ask if we could place an order.
I ordered a Rueben wrap, vs sandwich. It was tiny in comparison (I’ve ordered the Reuben before). It was very void of meat and cost an extra $1 for a wrap.
When the bartender came to ask how our food was, she started walking away without asking if we wanted another drink; we’ve now been here for an hour. I addressed the drink before she walked away.
Previously, we had great experiences here…tonight is a game changer. We will try again to see if this is the new norm. I’m hoping this is this bartenders first day at such a job and not indicative of how Lucy’s is doing business these days.
Desiree Shaw
We go to Lucy’s a lot, we love it!! They have a wide selection of food but we get our favorite thing because Lucy’s makes the very best turkey club wraps. Also I’m not a fan of beets but something told me to try the beet salad, now we both get it every time. Yum!!!
… moreFrank the Tank
We’ve been here before and always had a good experience. Today’s visit, however, was a great disappointment.
Before I begin, please note that I prefer not to leave a rating lower than 3 stars. Before I do so, I always try to discuss with the manager. Before leaving, I asked “may I speak to the manager?” The response was an immediate and disgruntled “why?” To me, that speaks volumes.
Service was absolutely horrible. When we arrived and picked our table, we weren’t greeted for over 10 minutes. I generally don’t mind waiting, but several of the staff walked by without saying anything, for example, “we’ll be with you soon.” And when we were finally greeted, it was very much not a greeting. There was no “welcome” or “how are you?” It was the most transactional experience I’ve ever had.
We each ordered a drink…both promptly received. Side note: White Claw is not analogous with Carbliss. When we got our drinks, we thought it was time to order dinner. Menus were out, but at that point closed because we knew what we wanted. There was no “would you like to order?” We had to prompt, which seemed to bother the waitress/bartender. She had to go and get her pen and pad.
Food was up fairly quick. I ordered the Brisket Sandwich. Despite looking good, the beef was tough…more like a couple of pieces of beef jerky with BBQ sauce on it.
Service continued to be dismal. There was no follow up to see if we needed anything (except another drink when we were ready to leave). We asked for the bill. Again we waited…and waited. Once I had the bill, I tried to pay using the Clover QR code. It didn’t work. We waited a little longer, then I finally went to the bar to pay. This is when I asked to speak to a manager.
If we ever decide to go to Lucy’s again, I’ll update this review accordingly.
… moreBefore I begin, please note that I prefer not to leave a rating lower than 3 stars. Before I do so, I always try to discuss with the manager. Before leaving, I asked “may I speak to the manager?” The response was an immediate and disgruntled “why?” To me, that speaks volumes.
Service was absolutely horrible. When we arrived and picked our table, we weren’t greeted for over 10 minutes. I generally don’t mind waiting, but several of the staff walked by without saying anything, for example, “we’ll be with you soon.” And when we were finally greeted, it was very much not a greeting. There was no “welcome” or “how are you?” It was the most transactional experience I’ve ever had.
We each ordered a drink…both promptly received. Side note: White Claw is not analogous with Carbliss. When we got our drinks, we thought it was time to order dinner. Menus were out, but at that point closed because we knew what we wanted. There was no “would you like to order?” We had to prompt, which seemed to bother the waitress/bartender. She had to go and get her pen and pad.
Food was up fairly quick. I ordered the Brisket Sandwich. Despite looking good, the beef was tough…more like a couple of pieces of beef jerky with BBQ sauce on it.
Service continued to be dismal. There was no follow up to see if we needed anything (except another drink when we were ready to leave). We asked for the bill. Again we waited…and waited. Once I had the bill, I tried to pay using the Clover QR code. It didn’t work. We waited a little longer, then I finally went to the bar to pay. This is when I asked to speak to a manager.
If we ever decide to go to Lucy’s again, I’ll update this review accordingly.
Tyler Ziegler
Good food, friendly staff, and a fun spot for everybody. Had roughly $25 in drinks for myself and ordered an app at $4.99 to go. To go orders supposedly charge $1.00 as my bill shows. 20% charge for styrofoam seems bogus honestly. Staff and food easily 5 stars but overall a 4 for the establishment now.
4 star changed 7/18/21
Today I order a pizza to go and have a few drinks while I wait. Nearly 50 minutes for the pizza on a quiet Sunday. Over that 50 minutes staff are killing flies on the bar around customers and making a game out of it. I get my bill and my pizza is a dollar more than the menu price not including the to go charge they also inflict. I ask the bartender about the price and he looks it up and confirms I was correct. I think this place has just rubbed me wrong enough now to no longer return. Not to mention the pizza was super dry and looked unappetizing.
… more4 star changed 7/18/21
Today I order a pizza to go and have a few drinks while I wait. Nearly 50 minutes for the pizza on a quiet Sunday. Over that 50 minutes staff are killing flies on the bar around customers and making a game out of it. I get my bill and my pizza is a dollar more than the menu price not including the to go charge they also inflict. I ask the bartender about the price and he looks it up and confirms I was correct. I think this place has just rubbed me wrong enough now to no longer return. Not to mention the pizza was super dry and looked unappetizing.
Barry Dean
These guys have the best burgers for the price for sure. I recommend going on Tuesday for the two for one deals. My wife had the Lucy burger and loved it.
… moreJim Hopton
What a great detour to relax and enjoy!!! Lucy’s Hideaway should be on your rotation of places for down time. Great service, well stocked bar and beautiful outdoor seating area. Great job to Lucy’s Hideaway, KUDOS!!!
… moreNathan Engler
Nice bar with a patio. We ordered a few appetizers and a sandwich. Everything was decent bar food. Only 1 bartender on for a busy bar, but she ran like crazy and did a good job.
… moreJon M
Great place to go. Friendly staff and good food.
… more