Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3812 Skyline Blvd, Cape Coral, FL 33914
Phone: (239) 837-8221
Website: http://longislandbrotherspizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Long Island New York Pizza – Cape Coral, FL – 3812 Skyline Blvd …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Long Island New York Pizza in Cape Coral, FL. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Long Island New York Pizzeria of Cape Coral – Facebook
Our recipe is simple: family, passion, and fresh dough. 3812 Skyline Blvd Cape Coral, Florida 33914 Monday-Saturday ⏱️11am-9pm.
Long Island New York Pizza – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Cape Coral, FL! Long Island New York Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Reviews
Scott Miller
My family and I just tried this place for the first time. We were all very happy with the pizzas and garlic knots. This pizza is very good, although not to the level of our favorite pizza place, Bleecker Street Pizza in NYC.
… moreGulf Coast Terry
Long Island Bro. New York Pizza
Stopped by on a Saturday round 5:30ish. Place was not that full, but they looked busy with takeouts. We ordered a Stromboli with Pep, Ham, and Sausage. Also, we got a Salad for two and an Italian Sub. Our friends ordered a Pizza and a Salad for two. Our orders came out in a reasonable time, and all looked good. The Salad was good it tasted fresh and had all the fixings that went with it. It was big enough for two. The Italian Sub was ok and large enough to fill you up. My Stromboli was ok not fantastic it was warm not cold but not that hot in the middle it was a little doughy and the cheese did not taste fresh. The Pizza was ok nothing fantastic there either. I must give this place 3 out of 5 stars.
⭐⭐⭐
Gulf Coast Terry
… moreStopped by on a Saturday round 5:30ish. Place was not that full, but they looked busy with takeouts. We ordered a Stromboli with Pep, Ham, and Sausage. Also, we got a Salad for two and an Italian Sub. Our friends ordered a Pizza and a Salad for two. Our orders came out in a reasonable time, and all looked good. The Salad was good it tasted fresh and had all the fixings that went with it. It was big enough for two. The Italian Sub was ok and large enough to fill you up. My Stromboli was ok not fantastic it was warm not cold but not that hot in the middle it was a little doughy and the cheese did not taste fresh. The Pizza was ok nothing fantastic there either. I must give this place 3 out of 5 stars.
⭐⭐⭐
Gulf Coast Terry
mellissa davis
The best so far
I think we’ve tried every place in Cape Coral for Pizza so far, and this is the best by far. The people were wonderful. The crust is thin and crispy. The toppings were quality, and the price was great.! We will definitely be back
… moreI think we’ve tried every place in Cape Coral for Pizza so far, and this is the best by far. The people were wonderful. The crust is thin and crispy. The toppings were quality, and the price was great.! We will definitely be back
Nick Signorelli
Friday afternoon I expect busy, no complaint on time to get food.
Someone brought in a dog, walked through the kitchen, everyone pet the dog, no one washed their hands. Had my pizza not already been in the oven, I would have left
Every single piece has multiple bubbles. Very disappointed. Won’t be back.
… moreSomeone brought in a dog, walked through the kitchen, everyone pet the dog, no one washed their hands. Had my pizza not already been in the oven, I would have left
Every single piece has multiple bubbles. Very disappointed. Won’t be back.
Mike Rado
Im not a regular cheese slice person , so I don’t know about their pizza , but their grandmother slice is and was delicious , everything about it was nice . And I was able to walk in at 7:15 pm and get 2 slices . They had many different slices at that time as well , so that means a lot to me because where im from there was always slices available until they close at night . So this will be a new regular spot for 2026 .
… moreEliezer Serrano
Amazing humongous pizza slices like New York style and delicious! Drove here from Port Charlotte and worth the drive! And you can order a 28″ pizza to go with a custom box!
… moreJason Cottrell
Down to earth hard working folks that know how to make a great pie! 3rd time we’ve ordered here everytime its been great!
They also have a hot and ready section for just a slice. My bet is they will be on the Best in Cape Food List before you know it!
… moreThey also have a hot and ready section for just a slice. My bet is they will be on the Best in Cape Food List before you know it!
Shelby GT500
My wife and I just moved to Cape Coral. Our first venture, was to find a good East Coast thin crust pizza. Being originally from Philly, I am a Pizza Critic per say. And hard to please. But being honest, we ordered a whole pie, fresh from the oven and it was delicious!! Tried a couple other places in the Cape and none of them even came close to as delicious as this pizza is. We are definitely heading back for sure. The Owner and his helper were super cool. If I had one negative, it would be the door was wide open and their were some flies to contend with. But that does not warrant any reason, to say this pizza isn’t DELICIOUS!!
… moreBling New York
I’m a NY-ER, I moved here a month ago and the pizza here is delicious. Love that they actually cook the bottom and brown it. My Yorkies love their crust as well
Most pizzeria’s locally don’t make the pie with the bottom cooked/well done way too doughy… . They are from Long Island obviously and they nailed it.. Will be a regular here for sure.
… moreMost pizzeria’s locally don’t make the pie with the bottom cooked/well done way too doughy… . They are from Long Island obviously and they nailed it.. Will be a regular here for sure.
Charles Cheese
Incoming Pizza review
Let me start by saying that new owners are the most friendly people and are the staple that hold this excellent pizza joint together
The Sicilian slice was breathtaking, and I say that with a serious stern face, first bite through the last was bellissimo, the buffalo chicken slice was authentic as if like a slice from roses in Penn Station we will continue to come back and suggest you do the same, Sicilian sauce was sweet and the regular slice had the right herbs and sauce ratio,a Italian punch in the mouth that you were looking for when you say a pizza from New York, best in the Cape hands-down no contest!
… moreLet me start by saying that new owners are the most friendly people and are the staple that hold this excellent pizza joint together
The Sicilian slice was breathtaking, and I say that with a serious stern face, first bite through the last was bellissimo, the buffalo chicken slice was authentic as if like a slice from roses in Penn Station we will continue to come back and suggest you do the same, Sicilian sauce was sweet and the regular slice had the right herbs and sauce ratio,a Italian punch in the mouth that you were looking for when you say a pizza from New York, best in the Cape hands-down no contest!